Rod Jackson vs. Myles Kennedy, who's voice suits better GNR songs?

[Nosaj Thing]

Examples:

__

I personally think Rod sounded better and Slash's guitar sound was heavier with Snakepit. Edited July 8, 2013 by Nosaj Thing

[bacardimayne]

Are there examples of Rod singing GNR songs that require more than toned talking for 95% of the song?

[MEXzilla]

They both sound like shit but I'll go with Myles simply because he can break glass.

[EvH]

Not to mention that Rod was as much of a junkie as Adler. Myles is a professionnal.

[Cosmo]

Pi2loc... You do know I LOVE that second Snakepit album but... In terms of singing GnR, Myles is way better. If you take the best songs made for Rod to sing X the best songs made for Myles to sing, Rod's best wins, IMO. But when it comes to singing GnR, I don't think Rod stands a chance on this one.

[Nosaj Thing]

Are there examples of Rod singing GNR songs that require more than toned talking for 95% of the song?

Unfortunately. no.

Pi2loc... You do know I LOVE that second Snakepit album but... In terms of singing GnR, Myles is way better. If you take the best songs made for Rod to sing X the best songs made for Myles to sing, Rod's best wins, IMO. But when it comes to singing GnR, I don't think Rod stands a chance on this one.

Alright, but what about stage presence? or Rod vs Myles as a performer/lead singer/frontman?

Edited July 8, 2013 by Nosaj Thing

[bacardimayne]

Are there examples of Rod singing GNR songs that require more than toned talking for 95% of the song?

Unfortunately. no.

Then Myles wins by virtue of being able to sing the real songs.

[jmapelian]

Examples:

__

I personally think Rod sounded better and Slash's guitar sound was heavier with Snakepit.

where are Paradise City and Sweet Child w/ Rod? we've seen myles do them @ the HOF