Rank the 22 guys who have been in Guns N' Roses in order from favorite to least favorite member

[Subtle Signs]

I did this thread a few years back, since that time your feelings/rankings may have changed. If the old thread is still active then perhaps these can be merged.

Axl Rose

Slash

Izzy

Duff

Steven Adler

Dizzy

Tracii Guns

Rob Gardner

Ole Beich

Paul Tobias

Gilby Clarke

Tommy Stinson

Bumblefoot

Buckethead

Richard Fortus

Chris Pitman

Robin Finck

Brain

Dj Ashba

Josh Freese

Matt Sorum

Frank Ferrer

[Flayer]

That's a little ridiculous to rank all of them on the same scale.

And how the fuck are you supposed to rank people like Tracii Guns and Ole Beich who basically played bar band GNR for a month or two?

[Subtle Signs]

That's a little ridiculous to rank all of them on the same scale.

And how the fuck are you supposed to rank people like Tracii Guns and Ole Beich who basically played bar band GNR for a month or two?

You are posting them in order of your favorites. Someone can have Ole first if he's their favorite. There are no right or wrong answers here.

[ManetsBR]

I did this thread a few years back, since that time your feelings/rankings may have changed. If the old thread is still active then perhaps these can be merged.

Axl Rose

Slash

Izzy

Duff

Steven Adler

Dizzy

Tracii Guns

Rob Gardner

Ole Beich

You're trying too hard. A fine cupcake never gets caught.

[classicguns4life]

This wasn't hard at all:

1. Slash

2. Duff

3. Axl

4. Izzy

5. Matt Sorum

6. Steven

7. Gilby

8. Richard Fortus

9. Tommy Stinson

10. Buckethead

11. Bumblefoot

12. Josh Freese

13. Brain

14. Robin Finck

15. Dizzy Reed

16. Frank Ferrer

17. Chris Pitman

18. DJ Ashba

19. Paul Tobias

20. Traci Gunns

21. Ole Beich

22. Rob Gardner

[Subtle Signs]

I did this thread a few years back, since that time your feelings/rankings may have changed. If the old thread is still active then perhaps these can be merged.

Axl Rose

Slash

Izzy

Duff

Steven Adler

Dizzy

Tracii Guns

Rob Gardner

Ole Beich

You're trying too hard. A fine cupcake never gets caught.

Son,it isn't trolling to pick my FAVORITES. I can have Ole first if I want. I was into GnR years before you came into this world but your opinion on this topic is just as valid as anyone else's. This isn't ranking them by musical ability/talent it is by who you prefer. If you don't wish to participate that's all good too.

This wasn't hard at all:

1. Slash

2. Duff

3. Axl

4. Izzy

5. Matt Sorum

6. Steven

7. Gilby

8. Richard Fortus

9. Tommy Stinson

10. Buckethead

11. Bumblefoot

12. Josh Freese

13. Brain

14. Robin Finck

15. Dizzy Reed

16. Frank Ferrer

17. Chris Pitman

18. DJ Ashba

19. Paul Tobias

20. Traci Gunns

21. Ole Beich

22. Rob Gardner

I happen to have Sorum almost dead last and you have him in your top 5. That's the great thing about this topic is almost every list will be different.

[DieselDaisy]

We have never heard Tracii, Ole and Rob Gardner in GN'R (unless you were one of the lucky few to have seen one of their, approx. five gigs in 1985!). How can you possibly judge?

[ManetsBR]

I did this thread a few years back, since that time your feelings/rankings may have changed. If the old thread is still active then perhaps these can be merged.

Axl Rose

Slash

Izzy

Duff

Steven Adler

Dizzy

Tracii Guns

Rob Gardner

Ole Beich

You're trying too hard. A fine cupcake never gets caught.

Son,it isn't trolling to pick my FAVORITES. I can have Ole first if I want. I was into GnR years before you came into this world but your opinion on this topic is just as valid as anyone else's. This isn't ranking them by musical ability/talent it is by who you prefer. If you don't wish to participate that's all good too.

You're older than me, thus logically your opinion is "better" than mine. Nice.

[Subtle Signs]

I did this thread a few years back, since that time your feelings/rankings may have changed. If the old thread is still active then perhaps these can be merged.

Axl Rose

Slash

Izzy

Duff

Steven Adler

Dizzy

Tracii Guns

Rob Gardner

Ole Beich

You're trying too hard. A fine cupcake never gets caught.

Son,it isn't trolling to pick my FAVORITES. I can have Ole first if I want. I was into GnR years before you came into this world but your opinion on this topic is just as valid as anyone else's. This isn't ranking them by musical ability/talent it is by who you prefer. If you don't wish to participate that's all good too.

You're older than me, thus logically your opinion is "better" than mine. Nice.

Are you going to post your list or just clog up the thread with accusations of "trolling"

[LuanVictor]

Axl Rose

Buckethead

Bumblefoot

Robin Finck

Izzy

Tommy Stinson

Slash

Richard Fortus

Duff

Brain

Josh Freese

Chris Pitman

Paul Tobias

Frank Ferrer

Matt Sorum

Gilby Clarke

Dizzy

Tracii Guns

Rob Gardner

Ole Beich

Dj Ashba

Steven Adler

Edited September 9, 2013 by LuanVictorxD

[DieselDaisy]

Izzy

Slash

Duff

Axl Rose

Gilby Clarke

Steven Adler

Buckethead

Brain

Matt Sorum

Paul Tobias (solely for writing ability).

Richard Fortus

Robin Finck

Josh Freese

Tommy Stinson

Dizzy

Frank Ferrer

Chris Pitman

Bumblefoot

Dj Ashba

And I cannot judge these until someone comes up with a lost recording of those early shows..

Tracii Guns

Rob Gardner

Ole Beich

[MEXzilla]

Axl

Slash

Izzy

Duff

Adler

Sorum

Gilby

And the rest I don't care about...

[Kapitch_77]

A few years ago my list would not be like the following, but as of now...

My 2 favorite members:

1. Slash

2. Duff

Then these guys:

3. Izzy

4. Axl

5. Matt

6. Gilby

7. Adler

The others I don't care much about them, but the 2 followings are cool guitars players:

8. Fortus

9. BBF

Then a few freaks and a 2 drummers...

10. Josh Freeze

11. Finck

12. Buckethead

13. Brain

Some guys that are just kinda there...

14. Frank

15. Dizzy

And the rest... (they could be in any order)

16. Tracci Guns

17. Ole Beich

18. Rob Gardner

19. Ashba

20. Pittman

21. Paul Tobias

22. Stinson

[stumbleine]

rank me hard.

josh freeze,ya'all,the best GNR member ever.

Edited September 9, 2013 by stumbleine

[abpagain]

What about tracy and roberta? I could rank them above a couple of your options.

[Kapitch_77]

Teddy Zig-Zag Andreatis> the entire new band

[izzygirl]

Izzy

Axl/Slash

Duff

Steven

Gilby

Matt

Dizzy Reed

Edited September 9, 2013 by izzygirl

[SweetRose]

Yeah,I tend to like the girl horn players n backup singers too. But I'd say the same had they been guys.In my opinion there at least needed to be the horn players live.

Oh and my rank would be the original 5 or minus Izzy and Steven and plus Matt and Gilby.And Dizzy regardless.

Edited September 9, 2013 by SweetRose

[phaeryen]

Where is Fernando? It's his band after all.

[jmapelian]

Slash

Izzy

Duff

Steven Adler

Dizzy

yGilby Clarke

Matt Sorum

Axl Rose

Buckethead

Richard Fortus

Chris Pitman

Robin Finck

Brain

Dj Ashba

Josh Freese

Frank Ferrer

Tommy Stinson

Bumblefoot

Tracii Guns

Rob Gardner

Ole Beich

Paul Tobias

[liers]

Axl

Bumblefoot

Buckethead

Fortus

Stinson

Izzy

Matt

Finck

Freese

Duff

Ashba

Adler

Tobias

Brain

Tracii

Ole

Frank

Rob

Dizzy

Pitman

I'm missing someone.

[classicguns4life]

I'm missing someone.

Yeah, your post must have gotten cut off at the top. You're missing the guy above Axl.

[Graeme]

Izzy

Ron

Axl

Richard

Duff

Slash

Brain

Buckethead

Tommy

Dizzy

Frank

Pitman

Gilby

DJ

Josh

Robin

Steven

Matt

Tobias

Ole

Rob

Tracii

[rockerman]

For Guns and Roses:

Axl

Slash

Duff

Izzy

Adler

with a thumbsup to Gilby , Sorum and Dizzy

West Arkien

Guns and Posers

Axl

Brian May

Fortus

BBF

Stinson

Buckethead

Fink

Pitman

ferrar/mantis

Bubbles

huge

Bozo the clown

Herbie the puppet

[magisme]

Axl/Slash

Izzy

Duff

Buckethead

Couldn't give a shit about the rest of 'em.