Jump to content

Rank GN'R and past members albums


Recommended Posts

I am interested to see what is everybody's opinion on this matter.

How would you rank Gn'R and past members albums?

I am ranking here only Gn'R, VR and Slash albums, since these are ones I know better, although I like some of Izzy's and Bucket's solo work. But feel free to rank any albums you want.


This would be my list:


1- Appetite For Destruction - GN'R

2- Use Your Illusion II - GN'R

3- Use Your Illusion I - GN'R

4- Contraband - VR

5- Chinese Democracy - GN'R

6- World On Fire - Slash

7- GN'R Lies - GN'R

8- Slash - Slash

9- It's Five O'Clock Somewhere - Snakepit

10- Apocalyptic Love - Slash

11- The Spaghetti Incident? - GN'R

12- Libertad - VR

13- Ain't Life Grand - Snakepit

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Chinese Democracy

2. Contraband

3. Live Era '87-'93

4. "The Spaghetti Incident?"
5. Ain't Life Grand

6. Use Your Illusion I

7. Use Your Illusion II
8. Slash

9. Appetite For Destruction

10. Apocalyptic Love

11. World On Fire
12. Dark Days

13. Libertad

14. Pawnshop Guitars

15. It's Five O' Clock Somewhere

16. The Taking

17. Sick

18. Like A Dog

19. River

20. Concrete

21. Smoke

22. Wave Of Heat

23. On Down The Road

24. Ride On

25. Miami

26. 117

27. Ju Ju Hounds

28. Fire, The Acoustic Album

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of the ones I possess, something like this, best to worst,

Appetite

Lies

117 Degrees

On Down the Road

Illusion 1

Like A Dog

Miami

River

Illusion 2

Ju Ju Hounds

Pawnshop Guitars

Smoke

Concrete

Wave of Heat

Fire

Beautiful Disease

Slash

Libertad

World on Fire

It's Five O' Clock

Ain't Life Grand

Live Era

Chinese Democracy

The Hangover

Rubber

Swag

Apocalyptic Love

Spaghetti Incident

Believe In Me

Contraband

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of the ones I possess, something like this, best to worst,

Appetite

Lies

117 Degrees

On Down the Road

Illusion 1

Like A Dog

Miami

River

Illusion 2

Ju Ju Hounds

Pawnshop Guitars

Smoke

Concrete

Wave of Heat

Fire

Beautiful Disease

Slash

Libertad

World on Fire

It's Five O' Clock

Ain't Life Grand

Live Era

Chinese Democracy

The Hangover

Rubber

Swag

Apocalyptic Love

Spaghetti Incident

Believe In Me

Contraband

Libertad over Contraband? Really???

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Colma and Electric Tears - Buckethead

Contraband

World on Fire

This is my Top 3(4).

I consider Izzy's solo career mediocre. Same for Tommy Stuson (mediocre bass player and songwriter). Never took the time to listen to Walking Papers, Loaded or any Duff project besides VR. lol Dizzy, Pitman, Bumble, Axl, DJ, Adler, etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not including post Slash GNR member's solo albums and projects. Not because I don't like them, but because this would become a clusterfuck. I'm also not including Loaded because I haven't listened to those in years, Duff and Matt's solo albums because I never heard them (well, I heard that one song from Matt and it was terrible), Steven's album because I only heard it once, and Izzy's career because it is too large and mediocre with a few good songs here and there. I also really loved The Walking Papers' album, but idk if Duff actually played on it so I'll leave it out.

Appetite for Destruction

Chinese Democracy

Use Your Illusion I

Use Your Illusion II

It's Five O Clock Somewhere

World on Fire

Ain't Life Grand

Contraband

Apocalyptic Love

Lies

Pawnshop Guitars

Libertad

Slash

The Spaghetti Incident?

There's a pretty big drop off from "Pawnshop" to "Slash" I think "Pawnshop" and everything above is brilliant.

Libertad suffers from not being nearly as good as Contraband but there are some awesome tunes on it and it flows like an actual album. "Slash" is an album I was PSYCHED for. The songs are mostly alright, and it has a lot of nostalgia for me, but it has aged poorly. It is more of a pop- rock album, and is probably the most generic album Slash did. Still, there are some really, really great songs. The Spaghetti Incident? is just not that great, and it sucks classic GNR's last album is a "meh" covers album. Still, there is some good shit on there. I love Down on the Farm and Ain't it Fun.

Edited by ZoSoRose
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. UYI I & II
2. AFD
3. Lies
4. Ain't Life Grand
5. It's Five O'clock Somewhere
6. Population Override
7. Electric Sea
8. "TSI?"
9. World on Fire / Apocalyptic Love
10. Slash
11. Pawnshop Guitars
12. All Buckethead Albums
13. Ju Ju Hounds
14. Contraband
15. Libertad
16. All Duff Albums
17. All Izzy Albums
18. Chinese Democracy

Edited by Nosaj Thing
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chinese Democracy

UYI I

AFD

UYI II

Ju Ju hounds

Enter the Chicken

Normal (?)
Miami
Enter the Chicken
Pawnshop Guitars
Colma
World on Fire

117°

Population Override

Abnormal (?)

Contraband

Colma

GN'R Lies

Libertad

Apocalyptic Love

Uncool (?)

Just the ones I listen to regularly, it would be unfair to rank albums I don't know as much as these

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Appetite for Destruction - Guns N' Roses
2. Lies (the acoustic side) - Guns N' Roses
3. Use Your Illusion II - Guns N' Roses
4. Chinese Democracy - Guns N' Roses
5. Use Your Illusion I - Guns N' Roses

6. Population Override - Buckethead
7. Normal - Bumblefoot
8. Apocalyptic Love - The Conspirators
9. Crime Slunk Scene - Buckethead
10. Abnormal - Bumblefoot
11. Albino Slug - Buckethead
12. Contraband - Velvet Revolver
13. Barefoot - The Acoustic EP - Bumblefoot
14. The Spaghetti Incident - Guns N' Roses
15. Ain't Life Grand - Slash's Snakepit
16. World on Fire - The Conspirators

17. Village Gorilla Head - Tommy Stinson
18. Slash - Slash
19. 117° - Izzy Stradlin
20. It's 5'OClock Somewhere - Slash's Snakepit
21. Beautiful Disease - Duff McKagan
22. Libertad - Velvet Revolver
23. Live Like a Suicide - Guns N' Roses
24. Literally everything else
25. Believe In Me - Duff McKagan
26. Pawnshop Guitars - Gilby Clarke
27. Back From the Dead - Adler

28. Swag - Gilby Clarke

I chose to only include my top 3 Buckethead albums. Otherwise the bottom half of this would be almost entirely Buckethead.

Edited by bacardimayne
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Appetite for Destruction - Guns N' Roses

2. Lies (the acoustic side) - Guns N' Roses

3. Use Your Illusion II - Guns N' Roses

4. Chinese Democracy - Guns N' Roses

5. Use Your Illusion I - Guns N' Roses

6. Population Override - Buckethead

7. Normal - Bumblefoot

8. Apocalyptic Love - The Conspirators

9. Crime Slunk Scene - Buckethead

10. Abnormal - Bumblefoot

11. Albino Slug - Buckethead

12. Contraband - Velvet Revolver

13. Barefoot - The Acoustic EP - Bumblefoot

14. The Spaghetti Incident - Guns N' Roses

15. Ain't Life Grand - Slash's Snakepit

16. World on Fire - The Conspirators

17. Village Gorilla Head - Tommy Stinson

18. Slash - Slash

19. 117° - Izzy Stradlin

20. It's 5'OClock Somewhere - Slash's Snakepit

21. Beautiful Disease - Duff McKagan

22. Libertad - Velvet Revolver

23. Live Like a Suicide - Guns N' Roses

24. Literally everything else

25. Believe In Me - Duff McKagan

26. Pawnshop Guitars - Gilby Clarke

27. Back From the Dead - Adler

28. Swag - Gilby Clarke

I chose to only include my top 3 Buckethead albums. Otherwise the bottom half of this would be almost entirely Buckethead.

I can't argue with much of that, it's about right

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Use Your Illusion I - Guns N' Roses

2. Use Your Illusion II- Guns N' Roses

3. Appetite for Destruction - Guns N' Roses

4. "The Spaghetti Incident?" - Guns N' Roses

5. Ain't Life Grand - Slash's Snakepit

6. Pawnshop Guitars- Gilby Clarke

7- It's 5'OClock Somewhere - Slash's Snakepit

8. Electric Tears - Buckethead

9. Contraband - Velvet Revolver

10. Izzy Stradlin & The Ju Ju Hounds - Izzy Stradlin & The Ju Ju Hounds

11. Giant Robot - Bucket

12. River - Izzy Stradlin

13. Believe in Me - Duff McKagan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of the ones I possess, something like this, best to worst,

Appetite

Lies

117 Degrees

On Down the Road

Illusion 1

Like A Dog

Miami

River

Illusion 2

Ju Ju Hounds

Pawnshop Guitars

Smoke

Concrete

Wave of Heat

Fire

Beautiful Disease

Slash

Libertad

World on Fire

It's Five O' Clock

Ain't Life Grand

Live Era

Chinese Democracy

The Hangover

Rubber

Swag

Apocalyptic Love

Spaghetti Incident

Believe In Me

Contraband

Libertad over Contraband? Really???

Contraband is shite. I do not find a single redeeming feature about the album. I know, I know - I see people who think it is brilliant and I then go and listen to it and cannot grasp what everyone likes about it.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of the ones I possess, something like this, best to worst,

Appetite

Lies

117 Degrees

On Down the Road

Illusion 1

Like A Dog

Miami

River

Illusion 2

Ju Ju Hounds

Pawnshop Guitars

Smoke

Concrete

Wave of Heat

Fire

Beautiful Disease

Slash

Libertad

World on Fire

It's Five O' Clock

Ain't Life Grand

Live Era

Chinese Democracy

The Hangover

Rubber

Swag

Apocalyptic Love

Spaghetti Incident

Believe In Me

Contraband

Libertad over Contraband? Really???

Contraband is shite. I do not find a single redeeming feature about the album. I know, I know - I see people who think it is brilliant and I then go and listen to it and cannot grasp what everyone likes about it.

For me, I see Libertad as superior to Contraband but I see I am in the minority! Libertad is a more cohesive album, in my opinion, but mostly I love it for For a Brother. I LOVE that "feels like I'm slow dancing, But I'm flying..." section. I also love Scott's voice. (Much prefer it to Myles Kennedy's TBH, if we are talking Slash-associated vocalists).

Edited by BetterDay7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...