Rank CD songs (Final Results in OP)

[Iron MikeyJ]

The good

1. Sorry

2. TWAT

3. This I love

4. Better

 

The ok

5. Catcher

6. Shackles

7.street of dreams

8. Maddy

 

The filler

9. Prostitute

10. CD

11. If the world

12. IRS

 

The shit

13. Scraped

14. Riad

[Ace Nova]

1. TWAT

2. Prostitute

3. Madagascar

4. Sorry

5. Shacklers Revenge

6. If The World

7. Better

8. CD

9. This I Love

10. CITR

11. IRS

12. Street of Dreams

13. Rhiad

14. Scraped

 

[cqleonardo]

My second GNR favorite album

Prostitute

There Was A Time

Catcher in The Rye

Better

Street Of Dreams

Sorry

IRS

Shacklers Revenge

Chinese Democracy

This I Love

Riad N The Bedouins

Madagascar

Scraped

If The World

[Millions]

1) Shackler's revenge

2) Better

3) TWAT

4) This I Love

5) Street Of Dreams

6) Madagascar

7) Catcher In The Rye

8) Sorry 

9) IRS

10) Chinese Democracy

11) Prostitute

12) Rhiad

13) If The World

14) Scraped

 

[Towelie]

23 minutes ago, Millions said:

1) Shackler's revenge

 

Yeah baby!!!

[BadApples87]

This album is pretty much garbage because it is half- Nine Inch Nails, half Elton John.  The problem is, the material on this album is a very poor man's version of Nine Inch Nails, and an terrible version of Elton John.  It really is a strange mix of mediocre songs.  Buckethead is a technically proficient player, but there is no heart and soul in the playing like Slash has.  The drumming is Extremely weak and pathetic throughout.  I could only see the original lineup doing There Was A Time, and that's it, with better drumming and a Slash solo.

Edited August 4, 2016 by BadApples87

[19AT5]

Quite like this album actually! True, it isn't a GNR album, but that's by the by! When it's good, it's fantastic. 

 

 

1. Better

2. There Was A Time

3. Street Of Dreams

4. If The World

5. Sorry

6. Chinese Democracy

7. I.R.S.

8. Prostitute

9. Shackler's Revenge

10. Madagascar

11. Catcher In The Rye

12. Scraped

13. This I Love

14. Riad N' The Bedouins

 

In my humble opinion, the first 7 tracks I listed above are the most listenable to my ears. The last 3 on the list are skips for me. Everything else in between I can take or leave. The outro to Prostitute is amazing though! 

[Gackt]

2 hours ago, Wagszilla said:

I really love Bucket's work on Sorry and Scraped. I've come to appreciate them much more throughout the years.

Well, Scraped anyway, I always liked Sorry. The drum intro on Scraped detracts from a solid mid-card song, IMO.

I could make an argument for Sorry being the best song on the album. 

Sorry's a little too whiny for me to fully appreciate  the instrumental is great, but it's not a song I particularly enjoy listening to

I like the direction Riad and Scraped were headed too with a heavier sound, but stacked against the rest of the album I had no choice but to rank them low

[Silent Jay]

7 minutes ago, Gackt said:

I like the direction Riad and Scraped were headed too with a heavier sound, but stacked against the rest of the album I had no choice but to rank them low

Sonically it's an interesting song Scraped. Very catchy but weird. Bumblefoot did a great work with that fretless solo. I wish I could rank it higher.

Edited August 4, 2016 by Silent Jay

[Tom-Ass]

I tried again last week to listen this album.. I am sorry ears...

CD, Madagascar and Street Of Dreams are the only ones with any potential..

I didn't listen To Catcher.. But I have been meaning to. 

Listening made me scared of hearing what new GnR music would sound like...

[janrichmond]

Just now, Tom-Ass said:

Listening made me scared of hearing what new GnR music would sound like...

That is a great fear of mine too

 

[F*ck Fear]

1 hour ago, Silent Jay said:

Sonically it's an interesting song Scraped. Very catchy but weird. Bumblefoot did a great work with that fretless solo. I wish I could rank it higher.

I wish I could have heard Buckehead's take on that solo.

[twenty-nine]

On 8/3/2016 at 9:49 AM, Maynard James Keenan said:

My World?

My World may be the one exception. 

[Gackt]

5 hours ago, F*ck Fear said:

I wish I could have heard Buckehead's take on that solo.

Maybe a little somethin like this

 

[Epson]

Thanks everyone who participated in these rankings.

 

I will just put all the results here.

 

Appetite For Destruction

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1dkTFx8UcQ75hJi4U-_dcr8Dv0dwM--vvoiRm4Ho-_U8/edit#gid=0   (Spreadsheet)

 

1. Welcome To The Jungle - 511 points

2. Rocket Queen  - 509 points

3. Nightrain - 499 points

4. Sweet Child O' Mine - 437 points

5. Paradise City - 424 points

6. It's So Easy - 411 points

7. Mr.Brownstone - 369 points

8. Out Ta Get Me - 308 points

9. My Michelle - 263 points

10. Think About You - 216 points

11. You're Crazy - 156 points

12. Anything Goes - 109 points

 

 

GN'R Lies 

1. One In A Million - 285 points

2. Patience - 280 points

3. You're Crazy - 242 points

4. Used To Love Her - 221 points

5. Nice Boys - 160 points

6. Reckless Life - 152 points

7. Move To The City - 149 points

8. Mama Kin - 131 points

 

 

Use Your Illusion I

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1SZz4AzZxNSYmmyHQDr-oNhIgdm9xYvAnkJ9mLQowuQU/edit?usp=sharing (spreadsheet)

 

1. Coma - 379 points

2. November Rain - 366 points 

3. Don't Cry - 331 points

4. Dead Horse - 287 points

5. Double Talkin' Jive - 261 points 

6. Don't Damn Me - 260 points

7. Perfect Crime - 249 points 

8. Dust N' Bones - 247 points 

9. The Garden - 213 points 

10. Live And Let Die - 198 points

11. Right Next Door To Hell - 187 points

12. Bad Obsession - 176 points 

13. Garden Of Eden - 168 points 

14. Back Off Bitch - 143 points

15. Bad Apples - 108 points 

16. You Ain't The First - 99 points

 

 

Use Your Illusion II

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lyAEqeArPhPCrh-nCfv_gC6eo7XLsZV8kGMQd3Ir6as/edit?usp=sharing (Spreadsheet)

 

1. Estranged - 467 points

2. Civil War - 427 points

3. You Could Be Mine - 400 points

4. Locomotive - 374 points

5. Breakdown - 317 points

6. Pretty Tied Up - 288 points

7. Yesterdays - 283 points

8. 14 Years - 275 points

9. Knockin' On Heaven's Door - 236 points

10. Don't Cry (alt.) - 221 points

11. Get In The Ring  - 170 points

12. So Fine - 152 points

13. Shotgun Blues - 118 points

14. My World - 52 points

 

 

"The Spaghetti Incident?"

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LStgfubnroIlBX97S8rGcBOBOQ0yLhPfKmPx85UP9i4/edit?usp=sharing (Spreadsheet)

 

1. Down On The Farm - 215 points

2. Ain't It Fun - 200 points 

3. Since I Don't Have You - 189 points

4. Black Leather - 164 points

5. New Rose - 146 points 

6. Human Being - 142 points

7. Raw Power - 133 points

8. Hair Of The Dog - 130 points

9. Attitude - 126 points

10. You Can't Put Your Arms Around A Memory - 107 points  

11. Look At Your Game, Girl - 100 points

12. Buick Makane - 90 points

13. I Don't Care About You - 78 points 

 

 

Chinese Democracy 

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LFfr28aHmk_cnD1a5C8ANGlsEuXA7XjIRBNkN-yfnG4/edit?usp=sharing (Spreadsheet)

 

1. There Was A Time - 467 points

2. Better - 439  points

3. Prostitute - 354 points

4. Catcher In The Rye - 351 points

5. Street Of Dreams - 349 points

6. Madagascar - 328 points

7. Chinese Democracy - 316 points

8. This I Love - 309 points

9. Sorry - 286 points

10. Shackler's Revenge - 247 points

11. I.R.S. - 236 points

12. If The World - 168 points

13. Scraped - 131 points

14. Riad N' The Bedouins - 114 points

 

[Silent Jay]

Thank You Epson, really good job. I think Appetite, Lies and maybe Illusion were a bit obvious, but all the votes for TSI and ChDm were quite interesting and higly varied.