Jump to content

Audio guitarist comparison '92, '02, '06


Iceman24

Recommended Posts

So, I decided to compare the 3 guitarists Slash, Buckethead and Bumblefoot in an audio comparison. I didn't use video footage, because I didn't want all people saying Buckethead just stands there, etc. It's just about the sound. ;)

I used three songs: YCBM, November Rain, Nightrain

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVV0qlukPVw

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 75
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

not biased at all ey?

i didnt bother listening to it....i really like all 3 of them.

I'm not biased, just realistic.

Not only Slash wrote these solos but he's the one who plays them as they have to be played.

its as if the others are covering them

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting thread :)

YCBM:

1) Bucket

2) Slash

3) BBF (sounds bad; just unmelodic noise and many tones)

NR:

1) BBF

2) Bucket

3) Slash

Nightrain:

1) Bucket (He OWNS this song!!)

2) BBF (normally I don' t like his attemps on Nightrain, but this is really good)

3) Slash (sorry Slash, but I still like it)

EDIT:

I just realized how great Bucket played in GN'R. If this was the point of this thread, it worked out smoothly!

Edited by final_touches
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I realised, I didn't give my opinion on the songs. :P

YCBM:

1) Buckethead

2) Slash

3) Bumblefoot (too much shredding. No melody)

NR:

1) Buckethead (amazing, what he did with it. Really cool new melody)

2) Bumblefoot, Slash (they are equal.)

Nightrain:

1) Buckethead (just blows me away every time. Unbelievable what amazing outro he created)

2) BBF (nice nightrain outro. Shredding, but I like it)

3) Slash (still cool)

Edited by Iceman24
Link to comment
Share on other sites

YCBM:

Slash

Buckethead

Ron

NV:

Ron

Buckethead

Slash

Nighrain:

Buckethead

Slash

Ron

that's my opinion. and i really dont care who's the best, cus ron is the one we have now, and we wont get slash og buckethead back, THAT's it. i dont get why people always have to compare to the old :unsure:

:unsure: But you just compared Slash, Bucket and Ron too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You Could Be Mine

1. Slash

2. Buckethead

3. Bumblefoot

November Rain

1. Bumblefoot

2. Slash

3. Buckethead

(This was REALLY close for Slash and BBF - But Ron's took it just)

Nightrain

1. Buckethead

2. Bumblefoot

3. Slash

Well..not what I was expecting. They all shared my favourite. I didn't plan it on being like that, I put all bias aside and picked as I heard them.

Who's a Slashite now? :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

YCBM

Slash

Buckethead

BBF

NV

Slash

Buckethead

BBF

Nightrain

Slash

Buckethead

BBf

you can't be better than the original slash owns both in each second of every song.

but I still realize that buckethead is quite good and I prefer him over Ron, thou ron seems more connected to the real world.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

YCBM

Buckethead

Slash

Ron

I got no idea what Bumble was trying to pull off.It just didn't sound right at all.

November Rain

Buckethead

Slash,Ron(Tie)

Bucket's ending(Is that what you call an outro?) was really the icing on the cake.

Nightrain

Buckethead

Slash

Ron

Bucket is the clear winner here.I just can't get over the fact that he manages to shred without losing the groove or feeling at all and how clean his tone is plus the fact he added alot of improvisations and his own style to it.

Ack,I seem to be completely biased for Buckethead.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

YCBM:

Slash

Buckethead

Ron

NV:

Ron

Buckethead

Slash

Nighrain:

Buckethead

Slash

Ron

that's my opinion. and i really dont care who's the best, cus ron is the one we have now, and we wont get slash og buckethead back, THAT's it. i dont get why people always have to compare to the old :unsure:

:unsure: But you just compared Slash, Bucket and Ron too.

no, i gave my opinion about who plays those three solos the best.

maybe i used the wrong words, because what i meant was why people always have to complain about how the old band was so much better than the new. you know? :) it wont be changed, thats why people needs to stop complaining about the new band not playing as well as the old.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



×
×
  • Create New...