[Bucketslash]

For giggles sakes, lets straight out pose the idea. Tomorrow, not only does Brain and Frank quit, but Steven Addler rejoins GNR. Straight up gnr, for the upcoming chinese democracy shows. Thats right, the entire lineup with Steven Addler added in, and Izzy guesting occasionally.

Will this work? Can Addler do it? Will he be too drugged? Will BBA actually let it go?

[Slash'd]

There isnt a chance in hell that Adler would be able to keep up with all of the GnR stuff again.

He could barely handle is the 1st time he was in the band, let alone handle it again.

He would probably just get kicked out again, or leave eventually.

[mindsaber]

Slash, on 27 September 2009 - 03:43 AM, said:

There isnt a chance in hell that Adler would be able to keep up with all of the GnR stuff again.

He could barely handle is the 1st time he was in the band, let alone handle it again.

He would probably just get kicked out again, or leave eventually.

Yes, but how rock n roll. How rock n roll indeed.

Have we forgotten what rock n roll is all about?

Bullshitting aside, I think Steve could handle it. If not, replace him with Tommy Lee. THAT would be rock n roll.

[rancid punks]

Some fan you are. Spell his fucking name correctly please.
ADLER

[Jackie Moon]

first off, he would be so excited he would probably suffer another stroke.

second, im not sure he would be able to play the new stuff. i really have nothing to base this on, im no drummer, but i just imagine steve gonig crosseyed during shacklers revenge and losing control of his bowels.

third, his heroin habit probably wouldnt be far behind. its hard to say where he is at in his 20 years in the making rehab, but one thing is clear, as often as he claims to be reformed and clean, not long after you hear about how fucked up he still is.

the only way adler is being brought back is if there is a guns n roses reunion, and matt sorum is either dead or dying.
so either way its not happening. although i do hope sorum dies. legitimately.

[PTZ]

Jackie, you know you'd feel bad if you read Matt died now.

[Jackie Moon]

i stand by my comment.

[PTZ]

Could it at least be a painless death?

[SunnyDRE]

Jackie Moon, on 09 November 2009 - 08:45 PM, said:

first off, he would be so excited he would probably suffer another stroke.

second, im not sure he would be able to play the new stuff. i really have nothing to base this on, im no drummer, but i just imagine steve gonig crosseyed during shacklers revenge and losing control of his bowels.

third, his heroin habit probably wouldnt be far behind. its hard to say where he is at in his 20 years in the making rehab, but one thing is clear, as often as he claims to be reformed and clean, not long after you hear about how fucked up he still is.

the only way adler is being brought back is if there is a guns n roses reunion, and matt sorum is either dead or dying.
so either way its not happening. although i do hope sorum dies. legitimately.

Haha.....ya know Dock Ellis, a pitcher in the Major Leagues...once pitched a perfect game while high on acid.

It is the GREATEST ACHIEVEMENT IN THE HISTORY OF SPORTS.

My point is, get off Adler....for him to have had a hand in creating one of the best of albums of alltime (while fucked up)....says alot about his skill, IMO.

[Jackie Moon]

SunnyDRE, on 09 November 2009 - 11:24 PM, said:

Jackie Moon, on 09 November 2009 - 08:45 PM, said:

first off, he would be so excited he would probably suffer another stroke.

second, im not sure he would be able to play the new stuff. i really have nothing to base this on, im no drummer, but i just imagine steve gonig crosseyed during shacklers revenge and losing control of his bowels.

third, his heroin habit probably wouldnt be far behind. its hard to say where he is at in his 20 years in the making rehab, but one thing is clear, as often as he claims to be reformed and clean, not long after you hear about how fucked up he still is.

the only way adler is being brought back is if there is a guns n roses reunion, and matt sorum is either dead or dying.
so either way its not happening. although i do hope sorum dies. legitimately.

Haha.....ya know Dock Ellis, a pitcher in the Major Leagues...once pitched a perfect game while high on acid.

It is the GREATEST ACHIEVEMENT IN THE HISTORY OF SPORTS.

My point is, get off Adler....for him to have had a hand in creating one of the best of albums of alltime (while fucked up)....says alot about his skill, IMO.

i dont mean to be on adler. my skill comment was based more on the stroke than anything. ive seen some youtube vids and he still plays great tho. plus i fully acknowledged i didnt know what i was talking about so i dont think you can hold it against me sunny.

in a perfect world, newguns would release 2-3 more albums then there would be a reunion tour with a clean adler behind the drums, and we would all get bjs. if there was a reunion i wouldn't want anybody besides adler, i think he has a serious legacy but along with serious problems. and who can blame him? if i was kicked out of guns in 1990 i would have lost my mind too. i think he is a great guy, the nicest of the original 5, so im pulling for him to clean up. if he wants to be included in any sort of reunion he better clean up or he wont be involved. in fact i think the only thing thats going to get adler clean, a guns n roses reunion. if that latin fan/wife isnt going to get him clean, nothing is, short of death or reunion. or a crusading dr.drew.

This post has been edited by Jackie Moon: 09 November 2009 - 10:48 PM

[Gibbz]

No, he wouldn't come back. Because Axl never liked him in the first place, and like people have mentioned before me; he wouldn't be able to keep up.
How long has he been out of the game? Too long.

[seely]

rancid punks, on 09 November 2009 - 09:26 AM, said:

Some fan you are. Spell his fucking name correctly please.
ADLER