It baffles me aswell. New songs are awesome and all, especially Perhaps. But if you exclude that, it's still the same 4 albums for years and years.
I'm not trying to shit on the band. I love them. But to me it feels like we're growing apart, as weird as that sounds. I stopped hoping for an album, I stopped checking the news and the setlists. I much rather listen to other stuff, like the idk 15 AC/DC albums that all sound the same (in the best way possible) excite me so much more.