Atlas Shrugged, 1 Minute Clip **NO LINKS** 7 Day Suspsenion For Asking For Links**

[Tom2112 1,544]

59 minutes ago, Trin9498 said:

Song sounds way too much like CITR. That song, in my opinion, is the most overrated GNR so g ever. 

CITR is overrated, but the most overrated is Coma. Not to derail the discussion 😋

I like what I heard from this clip, look forward to maybe, hopefully, possibly hearing the full version, in this life or the next, in some time, way, shape or form.

For me it's like if Soundgarden wrote estranged.

[Trin9498 123]

2 minutes ago, Tom2112 said:

CITR is overrated, but the most overrated is Coma. Not to derail the discussion 😋

I like what I heard from this clip, look forward to maybe, hopefully, possibly hearing the full version, in this life or the next, in some time, way, shape or form.

For me it's like if Soundgarden wrote estranged.

First 6 minutes overrated? Yes...last 2:30? No way.... but it’s fun to debate

[Hollywood Zombie 144]

Is The General leak 2minutes long or a remix?

[RussTCB 18,641]

4 minutes ago, Hollywood Zombie said:

Is The General leak 2minutes long or a remix?

This has been answered several times; there is no 2 minute leak of The General. There is a file that evader made from a terribly low quality cell phone recording. There are thread dedicated to all of the real leaks that are out there right now, the 2 minute version of The General is not legitimate. 

[jman2000 62]

Wondering if and when Central Park will get leaked. 

[rocknroll41 1,613]

2 minutes ago, jman2000 said:

Wondering if and when Central Park will get leaked. 

There’s a song called Central Park?

[jman2000 62]

7 minutes ago, rocknroll41 said:

There’s a song called Central Park?

Yes. As far as I can remember that was the name.

[TheSeeker 1,242]

I wonder what track number Atlas would have been on the album - Ron mentioned they were trying to fit it on the disc at the last minute, but he didn't say if it was going to be the last track 

Someone should tweet him and ask if he remembers

[rocknroll41 1,613]

6 minutes ago, TheSeeker said:

I wonder what track number Atlas would have been on the album - Ron mentioned they were trying to fit it on the disc at the last minute, but he didn't say if it was going to be the last track 

Someone should tweet him and ask if he remembers

No way it woulda been the very last song. Prostitute was clearly designed to be the album closer with that long-ass outro and all. My guess is it woulda come right after or right before Catcher since they’re both literary titles.

[Arnuld 172]

10 minutes ago, TheSeeker said:

I wonder what track number Atlas would have been on the album - Ron mentioned they were trying to fit it on the disc at the last minute, but he didn't say if it was going to be the last track 

Someone should tweet him and ask if he remembers

Mid tempo 4 min ballad? Probably between scraped and riad or right after sorry. 

[bdinan 200]

17 minutes ago, TheSeeker said:

I wonder what track number Atlas would have been on the album - Ron mentioned they were trying to fit it on the disc at the last minute, but he didn't say if it was going to be the last track 

Someone should tweet him and ask if he remembers

Judging by the way Prostitute ends, I think that was always intended to be the closer, but that goes without me hearing Atlas, so can only use my judgment that way.

 

[Stoymatic 147]

4 hours ago, RussTCB said:

This has been answered several times; there is no 2 minute leak of The General. There is a file that evader made from a terribly low quality cell phone recording. There are thread dedicated to all of the real leaks that are out there right now, the 2 minute version of The General is not legitimate. 

Speaking of Evader, earlier today I was wondering if he planned on doing a “Atlas Shrugged” Evader mix for us new GnR music hungry people!

[rocknroll41 1,613]

12 minutes ago, Stoymatic said:

Speaking of Evader, earlier today I was wondering if he planned on doing a “Atlas Shrugged” Evader mix for us new GnR music hungry people!

Yeah that’d be cool! I’d be content with that, if the full version never leaks.

[Shacklermyrye 205]

4 hours ago, jman2000 said:

Wondering if and when Central Park will get leaked. 

Last song Axl and Slash wrote before slash left right?

[Gibson_Guy87 2,470]

11 minutes ago, Shacklermyrye said:

Last song Axl and Slash wrote before slash left right?

I'm curious to hear those '96 tapes. I remember Axl saying that Slash had written some really mean riffs. 

[TheDemocracyRose 557]

Its hard to figure out what I have heard from this Atlas S...?

[Jordan Rose 816]

I HATE the Atlas vocal. I don't know what it is but it just doesn't sound like a dry vocal. It sounds processed and artificial. Exactly the same as when he suddenly multi-layers on Prostitute at "Why would they tell me to please those..." It just sounds weak.

Hard School quality sounds loads better. 

But i'm really starting to hate the idea of an album full of these weird-sounding clean vocals. He really was serious about ditching the classic raspy voice when you think how he sang clean through 01-02. But the fact that he responded to the criticism by going back to the classic voice in '06-'10 and '16 just makes it even more irritating to listen to all these songs with what could have been TIL Remix vocals. 

Edit: I'm stupidly forgetting they're the same vocals as 90% of Chinese. I'm just so used to only listening to live version from '06-'10 I forget what the album vocals are like. 

Edited August 28, 2019 by Jordan Rose

[Tom2112 1,544]

7 hours ago, TheSeeker said:

I wonder what track number Atlas would have been on the album - Ron mentioned they were trying to fit it on the disc at the last minute, but he didn't say if it was going to be the last track 

Someone should tweet him and ask if he remembers

He wouldn't answer. He might talk a bit more about gnr now, but as far as revealing any "secrets" you're barking up the wrong tree.

[liers 474]

I'm really hoping we get atlas in full soon. It really sounds like axl was making an effort to transition to a cleaner voice, which although im not a fan of it on the old songs, he makes it work pretty well on atlas and hardschool.

I could see them playing atlas live, especially if a new album is on the horizon. We know that it was ready to be released on CD but was excluded due to time constraints.

Edited August 28, 2019 by liers

[jafeijo 172]

I heard the 15 sec snippet and it sounds like is the most grungeish song of GNR, as the guitar reminded me of Serve the Servants.

[rocknroll41 1,613]

Just now, jafeijo said:

I heard the 15 sec snippet and it sounds like is the most grungeish song of GNR, as the guitar reminded me of Serve the Servants.

Yeah it reminds me a lot of Pearl Jam for some reason.

[ZoSoRose 8,238]

13 hours ago, RussTCB said:

This has been answered several times; there is no 2 minute leak of The General. There is a file that evader made from a terribly low quality cell phone recording. There are thread dedicated to all of the real leaks that are out there right now, the 2 minute version of The General is not legitimate. 

Technically the cell clip is a real 2 minute clip 

Edited August 28, 2019 by ZoSoRose

[default_ 1,569]

Oh, people are comparing beans to trucks. Cool.

[default_ 1,569]

Anyways... It looks like the whole 99 album is circulating in some form, the files are labeled numerically, Atlas is 2, Carcher is 6, TWAT is 8 and so on. 

[DTJ80 264]

15 minutes ago, default_ said:

Anyways... It looks like the whole 99 album is circulating in some form, the files are labeled numerically, Atlas is 2, Carcher is 6, TWAT is 8 and so on. 

Circulating where? Amongst the traders? How’d u know about the file numbers?