Bon Scott Or Brian Johnson

[Hard_Rocker]

I Know Its Dumb Ass But Who Is A Better Singer

I Think Bon Scott Sings Better But I Like Brian Johnson Better

[K-DST]

Bon Scott is the only real choice. Brian Johnson is a fill-in. The only reason his sorry Gordie ass is on stage with the greatness of Malcolm and Angus Young is 'cause Bon ODed on boos and died. If Bon was alive today Brian would be siging at weddings and such!

[johnezz]

Bon Scott by a mile

a joint, a rail and a bottle of JD before every gig he did.

[krissirge]

Brian Johnson by a lightyear...has a better voice than Scott IMO

Edited August 8, 2005 by krissirge

[Axls Rocket Queen]

Bon Scott. Absolutely no contest. The guy was amazing.

RIP

ARQ

[Guest cherry_bomb]

brian johnson. i love his charisma and his voice, its insane!

[RobbieGlenn]

Hummm.....I dunno, on one hand Bon Scott is a legend and sung really well to suit the lyrics and stuff. But Brian sung Thunderstruck, which is my favourite ACDC song, i have no idea who to pick so i pick............................................................................

........................................................................Malcolm Young

[highvoltage]

So difficult.

Brian sings his songs better than Bon could, but there's only a handful of Bon songs he can sing properly. Brian slaughters songs like High Voltage and Whole Lotta Rosie.

Brian's screaming was amazing and all, great shit to rock out to. His studio work on Back In Black and For Those About To Rock was phenominal. He's a fantastic live performer, but lacks the mysterious air that Bon had around him -- that funny feeling you get when you see Bon on stage. Also, he pales in comparison to Bon as a lyricist.

Having said this, Brian probably has the better voice of the two. (Har Har, seeing as Bon's dead)

It's a never ending argument that goes round in circles -- Both had their strengths and weaknesses. My favourite albums are Bon albums, but I probably prefer induvidual songs that Brian sings.

Tricky....

Bon probably wins over, but Brian filled the space like nobody else could, and I give him full credit for that.

[damian 1200]

You know what i was thinkin bout this last night there voices seem almost similair if you listen to back in black and highway to hell it's almost impossible to tell the difference

Im gonna null vote

R.I.P bon

[J.T]

Bon Scott..

His voice came naturally..

Johnson has to try much harder and it still doesn`t sounds as good..

[Wild_Child]

"who is kick ass?"

both of them!

Bon Scott is the best frontman ever, in my opinion, so i'm going for him!

[Turn_It_Up]

Bon is one of the most charismatic, memorable figures in rock history. So, Bon has the edge, but that's certainly no knock on Brian.

IMO, Brian has been good enough he more than stands on his own merits, rather than being considered a "fill in". And that was nearly an almost impossible task considering the positon he stepped into.

Bottom line: Both ROCK!!!!

Edited August 8, 2005 by Turn_It_Up

[Shearaxl]

Bon Scott is the only real choice. Brian Johnson is a fill-in. The only reason his sorry Gordie ass is on stage with the greatness of Malcolm and Angus Young is 'cause Bon ODed on boos and died. If Bon was alive today Brian would be siging at weddings and such!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Its geordie not gordie

And i doupt that he would be singing at weddings

And brian johnson cause he kicked ass, my mum used to go watch his before band called Geordie in a privet parties she said he was awesome, and is a great entertainer.Bon Scott was good but brian was better in my Opinion.

And from my home town

[Duffan]

Brian is my favorite vocalist/frontman ever , lyrically isn't as good as Bon , and has a bit different style on stage but like I said he's my fav ever . That being said Bon is my 3rd fav frontman ever .

Peace GnR Nation

[Guest Twisted Metal]

Bon is a better singer but Brian sounds more like a badass IMO so i'll go with Brian

[firecrown]

Bon is the original yes but I like what Brian Johnson brought to ACDC more. I mean come on ! Back in Black made them huge and defined an era in music. It's next to impossible to replace your lead singer in an already popular band but Brian did it and blazed his own trail. No fucking way is he JUST a fill in

[Getizzyback]

BON SCOTT for me! When he died in 1980,AC/DC didn't die thanks to Brian,but we lost one hell of a Whole Lotta Rock N Roll Singer.

[Guest Twisted Metal]

Bon is the original yes but I like what Brian Johnson brought to ACDC more. I mean come on ! Back in Black made them huge and defined an era in music. It's next to impossible to replace your lead singer in an already popular band but Brian did it and blazed his own trail. No fucking way is he JUST a fill in

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

very true man.

[Dont_You_Ever_Cry]

When You Look At It They Both Perform To The Best Of There Abilities So I Give Them Both Full Credit But I Go For Bon Scott

[Shearaxl]

Your all taking about brian like he is a fillin yes he is but he was more, i mean Angus and malcome were looking for a new singer brian gladly did it. He was more then a fillin he helped ac/dc. Bon scott and Brian johnson are both part of ac/dc's history.