Pink Floyd or Led Zeppelin?

[Bucketslash]

Floyd or Zep?

it's a hard choice, actually, but I gotta go with floyd

[highvoltage]

Led Zeppelin for me.

[kevdo242]

Zeppelin for sheer intensity.

[sweetness]

Pink Floyd

[Spuffy78]

Pink Floyd

[Iceman24]

Led Zeppelin of course.

[P.A. Guns]

Pink Floyd

[vicious]

i like pink floyd but they're extremely over rated in my opinion

zeppelin for the win

[Raw Power]

it's a hard choice

No it's not.

Pink Floyd EOD.

[Substance]

I wonder how many times a day this question is asked?

[Raw Power]

i like pink floyd but they're extremely over rated in my opinion

When people say that Pink Floyd are overrated, they show their lack of musical knowledge.

[appetite4illusions]

Like both but my preference is bluesy riff rockers.

Zeppelin.

[UYIllusion]

This one is as tough as Zep/Stones. I said Zep then and I will say it again, but close.

However, as great as all of these bands are, I would take The Beatles over any of them, no question.

[highvoltage]

i like pink floyd but they're extremely over rated in my opinion

When people say that Pink Floyd are overrated, they show their lack of musical knowledge.

Not at all.

[Graeme]

Zep for me. IV is a brilliant album.

[Substance]

i like pink floyd but they're extremely over rated in my opinion

When people say that Pink Floyd are overrated, they show their lack of musical knowledge.

When people don't know what an opinion is, they show their lack of intelligence.

[Raw Power]

i like pink floyd but they're extremely over rated in my opinion

When people say that Pink Floyd are overrated, they show their lack of musical knowledge.

When people don't know what an opinion is, they show their lack of intelligence.

This isnt a question about opinion. If you say Pink Floyd is overrated, you obviously don't manage to see the true

musical genius of Pink Floyd. I don't mind of you don't like them, but I react when people say they are 'extremely overrated.'

[Substance]

i like pink floyd but they're extremely over rated in my opinion

When people say that Pink Floyd are overrated, they show their lack of musical knowledge.

When people don't know what an opinion is, they show their lack of intelligence.

This isnt a question about opinion. If you say Pink Floyd is overrated, you obviously don't manage to see the true

musical genius of Pink Floyd. I don't mind of you don't like them, but I react when people say they are 'extremely overrated.'

It is your opinion that Pink Floyd is good. His opinion is as valid as yours. Commit some more fallacies, please.

Edited December 5, 2007 by Substance

[Raw Power]

i like pink floyd but they're extremely over rated in my opinion

When people say that Pink Floyd are overrated, they show their lack of musical knowledge.

When people don't know what an opinion is, they show their lack of intelligence.

This isnt a question about opinion. If you say Pink Floyd is overrated, you obviously don't manage to see the true

musical genius of Pink Floyd. I don't mind of you don't like them, but I react when people say they are 'extremely overrated.'

It is your opinion that Pink Floyd is good. His opinion is as valid as yours. Commit some more fallacies, please.

I beg to differ.

I don't mind if you like Pink Floyd or not. You can't say that musical skills is a matter of opinion?

I don't like John Petrucci, and Dream Theater better than Ramones. But I do accept that John Petrucci is a better guitarist than Joey

by miiiiles, and Dream Theater are ten million times 'better' musical-wise than any of the members in The Ramones.

[Substance]

i like pink floyd but they're extremely over rated in my opinion

When people say that Pink Floyd are overrated, they show their lack of musical knowledge.

When people don't know what an opinion is, they show their lack of intelligence.

This isnt a question about opinion. If you say Pink Floyd is overrated, you obviously don't manage to see the true

musical genius of Pink Floyd. I don't mind of you don't like them, but I react when people say they are 'extremely overrated.'

It is your opinion that Pink Floyd is good. His opinion is as valid as yours. Commit some more fallacies, please.

I beg to differ.

I don't mind if you like Pink Floyd or not. You can't say that musical skills is a matter of opinion?

I don't like John Petrucci, and Dream Theater better than Ramones. But I do accept that John Petrucci is a better guitarist than Joey

by miiiiles, and Dream Theater are ten million times 'better' musical-wise than any of the members in The Ramones.

He never said they weren't talented. He said they were overrated. (He doesn't think they're as pleasing to listen to as everyone says.)

P.S. Dream Theater is the best band ever.

[Graeme]

i like pink floyd but they're extremely over rated in my opinion

When people say that Pink Floyd are overrated, they show their lack of musical knowledge.

When people don't know what an opinion is, they show their lack of intelligence.

This isnt a question about opinion. If you say Pink Floyd is overrated, you obviously don't manage to see the true

musical genius of Pink Floyd. I don't mind of you don't like them, but I react when people say they are 'extremely overrated.'

It is your opinion that Pink Floyd is good. His opinion is as valid as yours. Commit some more fallacies, please.

I beg to differ.

I don't mind if you like Pink Floyd or not. You can't say that musical skills is a matter of opinion?

I don't like John Petrucci, and Dream Theater better than Ramones. But I do accept that John Petrucci is a better guitarist than Joey

by miiiiles, and Dream Theater are ten million times 'better' musical-wise than any of the members in The Ramones.

He never said they weren't talented. He said they were overrated. (He doesn't think they're as pleasing to listen to as everyone says.)

P.S. Dream Theater is the best band ever.

I wouldn't say the best ever but they are fucking amazing. I went to see them at Download last year and they rocked. I gave them ten out of ten anyways.

[Raw Power]

He never said they weren't talented. He said they were overrated. (He doesn't think they're as pleasing to listen to as everyone says.)

P.S. Dream Theater is the best band ever.

I can't really stand Dream Theater

Your definition of 'overrated' are quite different then my.

"Regarded more highly than is deserved."

[Substance]

He never said they weren't talented. He said they were overrated. (He doesn't think they're as pleasing to listen to as everyone says.)

P.S. Dream Theater is the best band ever.

I can't really stand Dream Theater

Your definition of 'overrated' are quite different then my.

"Regarded more highly than is deserved."

I'm sure you'd agree that rated would mean how good someone thinks something is. You might rate a band's music lowly, does that mean they're untalented? No. Is it your opinion? Yes.

He thinks they're overrated, that people rate them higher than he thinks they actually should be rated. It's still an opinion no matter what.

Edited December 5, 2007 by Substance

[JDRM]

Zeppelin for their incredibly wide range of ability.

[Raw Power]

He never said they weren't talented. He said they were overrated. (He doesn't think they're as pleasing to listen to as everyone says.)

P.S. Dream Theater is the best band ever.

I can't really stand Dream Theater

Your definition of 'overrated' are quite different then my.

"Regarded more highly than is deserved."

I'm sure you'd agree that rated would mean how good someone thinks something is. You might rate a band's music lowly, does that mean they're untalented? No. Is it your opinion? Yes.

He thinks they're overrated, that people rate them higher than he thinks they actually should be rated. It's still an opinion no matter what.

Therefor the lack of music knowledge