Knockin' on Heaven's Door

[31illusions]

I wanted to get some feedback from fellow GN'R fans about our version of this song. We are and original Blues/Rock

band. I play drums on this song. I believe this version is cool because it integrates different versions of the song,

from Bob Dylan to the version from the original GN'R and New GN'R and also. Please Let me know what you think.

Knockin' on Heavens Door

[Inverted Mind]

That's pretty cool,

I think the vocal melodies definitely could've been far more interesting though.

Nice solo, nice drums, bass could be mixed down a bit, maybe eq'd it with a little more bass.

[31illusions]

That's pretty cool,

I think the vocal melodies definitely could've been far more interesting though.

Nice solo, nice drums, bass could be mixed down a bit, maybe eq'd it with a little more bass.

Thanks, Yes I agree there is alot of things we could have done to improve the

mixing/harmonies/eq'ing. We basically did it live in one take. But not bad for what it is.

[Scaramouche]

wow this was a nice version. cool!

[feconroses]

My honest review after 1 listen not 100% focused on the song:

- If it was done in one take: congratulations to your band, its sounds very good!

- Musically is very cool and slightly different from other versions (which is a good thing). Maybe ill add a subtle keyboard to make it sound a little more "complete" or "fuller" (don't know how to say the exact word )

- I like the singer, i think she has a good potencial. But, it was slightly boring/karaeokish because of the poor melody or not playing with her "voice volume". She definately can sing but she has to work in those things to make it more interesting.

- This song desperately needs background vocals. Again, to make a "complete" or "fuller" sound.

But overall very nice job!