Has Axl ever publicly spoken about NIN/Reznor?

[Loaded]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ghOOmr578Wk

You just can't top this!

[Nintari]

"The Fragile" is a piece of shit ?

Wow...

How ?

Close minded, these people are....

[Bumble's Bridge Pickup]

Most NIN is enjoyable IMO. I love The Downward Spiral and The Fragile, but the rest of the albums are great too.

[Rovim]

Trent is the only man alive that could make Estranged an even better song.

I seriously doubt that! Unless he gets Axl on vocals and Slash on guitar, which would make it just another version of GNR.

Slash owns that song, probably the best written and played leadguitar of all time.

That's why Axl nods a personal thanks to Slash for making this song what it is.

You clearly have no idea of who Trent Reznor is and what he is capable of.

Oh, come down from your high horse. I've listened a lot to NIN and other Reznor-projects, and also seen them live a few times, so I know what he is capable of. To bad he hasn't done anything worth a dime since The Fragile.

Year Zero? With Teeth had it's moments too. Not many musicians can do what Trent did.

Edited December 7, 2010 by Rovim

[phaeryen]

"The Fragile" is a piece of shit ?

Wow...

How ?

its overindulgent, and the rock songs on it are sub par.

if you listen to Broken or Downward Spiral, you are listening to something extraordinary happening. Fragile is nothing that special in the broader sense and might work for you if you are a NIN fan... other than that, meh.

[moreblack]

its overindulgent, and the rock songs on it are sub par.

that is not the same thing as a piece of shit

[RichardNixon]

Trent has pretty much spent the entire decade trashing Axl every chance he can get. The things he's said make Slash seem like Mr. Rodgers by comparison. I doubt Axl thinks highly of him anymore.

Trent Reznor hasn't really "bashed" Axl. He goofed on him a little bit, putting Axl's image in some pictures on nin.com, but Reznor really hasn't said anything that bad. He never commented on Chinese Democracy or the new band, etc. People are creating a feud where there isn't one and blowing any comments TR said way out of proportion.

Trent Reznor goofs on a lot of people, btw--Weezer, Prince, and Chris Cornell got it pretty bad a few years back.

[phaeryen]

its overindulgent, and the rock songs on it are sub par.

that is not the same thing as a piece of shit

For me, it is.

I make no difference between "just okay" albums and completely terrible ones, I only have time for the completely magical stuff. and that trent reznor has not been able to produce in the 2000's. though there was one catchy tune on that one album, beginning of the end, I think it was called? I liked that thing but its not that special either.

[Stro]

The Hand That Feeds is awesome and was from 2005. Reznor is a great musician. I think he could do an amazing cover of Estranged.

[Black Sabbath]

Lol, the more than half of the people in this thread are fucking stupid :rofl-lol: :lol:

[Vincent Vega]

"Hit Parader: You mention the idea of working with other musicians. If you had your choice, who would you really like to work with on a project?

Axl: Trent Reznor from NIN is one, and Dave Navarro from Jane's Addiction is another guy I want to work with. I've talked to Trent about working with me on an industrial synth project, at least on one song, and I definitely want to work with Dave on something. I've always been curious what he would sound like working with Slash on something." (Axl, Hit Parader, July 1993)

Edited December 8, 2010 by Indigo Child

[Twinaleblood]

Thank you, Indigo child. I really appreciate your effort!

[Atlas Shrugged]

Lol, the more than half of the people in this thread are fucking stupid :rofl-lol: :lol:

shouldn't you be masturbating over an old 4chan meme you just discovered?

so edgy

[Gods Favourite]

Lol, the more than half of the people in this thread are fucking stupid :rofl-lol: :lol:

shouldn't you be masturbating over an old 4chan meme you just discovered?

so edgy

[Black Sabbath]

Lol, the more than half of the people in this thread are fucking stupid :rofl-lol: :lol:

shouldn't you be masturbating over an old 4chan meme you just discovered?

so edgy

Go make another name corresponding to a song you've never heard and a book that has nothing to do with that song.

[ppruks]

Trent has pretty much spent the entire decade trashing Axl every chance he can get. The things he's said make Slash seem like Mr. Rodgers by comparison. I doubt Axl thinks highly of him anymore.

Trent Reznor hasn't really "bashed" Axl. He goofed on him a little bit, putting Axl's image in some pictures on nin.com, but Reznor really hasn't said anything that bad. He never commented on Chinese Democracy or the new band, etc. People are creating a feud where there isn't one and blowing any comments TR said way out of proportion.

Trent Reznor goofs on a lot of people, btw--Weezer, Prince, and Chris Cornell got it pretty bad a few years back.

Chris Cornell fucking deserved it, I had respect for that man, I still enjoy his earlier work, but that terrible thing that he released with timbaland (who I think is one of the most unoriginal producers out there) was just too much for me, what a waste of talent

[Atlas Shrugged]

Lol, the more than half of the people in this thread are fucking stupid :rofl-lol: :lol:

shouldn't you be masturbating over an old 4chan meme you just discovered?

so edgy

Go make another name corresponding to a song you've never heard and a book that has nothing to do with that song.

scathing

[Stro]

I think the rumored remix album makes total sense seeing as how Axl was such a big fan of NiN and Trent. I love that Trent makes so many versions of his songs and actually releases them. Not just demos, but completely different versions. I wish Axl would release demos and remixes like that. I mean, there are like 10 versions of all the songs that actually made it to the album anyway.

[Tater Totts]

This thread is lulz

[Todo Poderoso Timão]

Trent is the only man alive that could make Estranged an even better song.

I seriously doubt that! Unless he gets Axl on vocals and Slash on guitar, which would make it just another version of GNR.

Slash owns that song, probably the best written and played leadguitar of all time.

That's why Axl nods a personal thanks to Slash for making this song what it is.

On his book, Slash crearly complains that he got no credits or rights for Estranged. I think all he had got was only a thank you in Illusions booklet despite his awesome work...