Pick the ultimate version of NewGNR

[Drakestar]

can't believe that many of you actually picked a guy that wears a bucket of fucking chicken on his head.

next up....Guns n' Roses "The Big Top Tour".

[Dazey]

can't believe that many of you actually picked a guy that wears a bucket of fucking chicken on his head.

Probably because he's a fucking insane player whose solo stuff is light years ahead of any of the others.

Oh, and there's not usually any chicken in the bucket by the way!

Edited June 7, 2012 by Dazey

[RandallFlagg]

Axl, Tommy, Buckethead, Bumblefoot, Fortus, Dizzy, Pitman and Brain.

[AXL_N_DIZZY]

Axl Rose- (vocals, piano)

Duff McKagan- (bass guitar)

Dizzy Reed- (keyboards)

Dj Ashba- (lead guitar)

Bumblefoot- (lead guitar)

Richard Fortus- (rhythm guitar)

Frank Ferrer- (drums)

Chris Pitman- (keyboards)

[volcano62]

The current line up is the ultimate one

No

Yes

[RandallFlagg]

Playing wise, Brain and Bucket are far superior to Ferrer and DJ. But ashba is probs better suited if he can bring some decent stuff (no generic Sixx am rubbish) to a record, Bumblefoot and Fortus will do the rest.

[Dazey]

The current line up is the ultimate one

No

Yes

No! But we all know you'd change your mind if Bucket rejoined anyway!

[volcano62]

The current line up is the ultimate one

No

Yes

No! But we all know you'd change your mind if Bucket rejoined anyway!

I don't want Bucket back in the band.

[Dazey]

I don't want Bucket back in the band.

I'm not saying you do, I'm saying that if he did come back and Ron left you'd suddenly change your mind about who was the better of the two!

[volcano62]

I don't want Bucket back in the band.

I'm not saying you do, I'm saying that if he did come back and Ron left you'd suddenly change your mind about who was the better of the two!

Nah not really. Bumble will always be the better guitar player and better suited for GNR. Obviously I'm not taking anything away from Bucket but I am more comfortable with Ron's style.

[OJones90]

Poor choices in that vote. And is this just meant to be from nu guns n roses then, or duff/izzy who have performed with them?

Axl

DJ Ashba

Fortus OR Izzy (depending)

Bumble

Duff (if possible)

Ferrer

[Dazey]

Nah not really. Bumble will always be the better guitar player and better suited for GNR. Obviously I'm not taking anything away from Bucket but I am more comfortable with Ron's style.

Only bustin' your stones buddy! You're wrong but you're entitled to your opinion!

[volcano62]

Nah not really. Bumble will always be the better guitar player and better suited for GNR. Obviously I'm not taking anything away from Bucket but I am more comfortable with Ron's style.

Only bustin' your stones buddy! You're wrong but you're entitled to your opinion!

Fuck it lets have both of them in GNR...what a clusterfuck that would be

[Black Roses]

Axl

Brain

4tus/Ashba

Bucket

Ron

Dizzy

Chris

I hate Robin because of his hair :xmassrudolph:

[Desperado]

Frank because he is cooler

Ron because he is the best guitarist ever in the band (if you think Buckethead playes better okej I love him too but technically he's not.... at all.... in the same league as Ron)

and Fortus because he's got a nice sound, style and he playes great. He's also a much much much better lead guitarist then DJ.

My ultimate guitarist list for nu-guns would be Ron, Bucket and Fortus

[The Archer]

If it came to choosing, I would rather have Ron over DJ, Bucket or Robin in the band. Ron leaving would be a major catastrophe.

[Dazey]

If it came to choosing, I would rather have Ron over DJ, Bucket or Robin in the band. Ron leaving would be a major catastrophe.

I was just waking up and I read the above as:

If it came to choosing, I would rather Run over DJ, Bucket or Robin but Ron leaving would be a major catastrophe.

:shocked:

[RocketQueenGNR]

Axl

Bumble

Richard

Tommy

Frank

Dizzy

Chris

[volcano62]

Ron leaving would be a major catastrophe.

Only Bucket could fill his shoes and he is never going to come back.

Ron leaving = end of GNR.

[bacardimayne]

Ron leaving would be bad because they'd probably replace him with someone horrible like Nick Sterling.

[Desperado]

Ron leaving would be a major catastrophe.

Only Bucket could fill his shoes and he is never going to come back.

Ron leaving = end of GNR.

Bucket wouldn't be able to play Rons guitar parts like Ron could play Buckets.

[DizzyReedsexmachine]

I dont like all of them but ...AXL,Buckethead,Fortus,Stinson,Brain,Dizzy :krider:

[Bruno P.]

Ron leaving would be a major catastrophe.

Only Bucket could fill his shoes and he is never going to come back.

Ron leaving = end of GNR.

Kind of, because he couldnt pull off the fretless stuff. Scraped, Chinese and Shacklers would sound really different live. I wonder what they'd have done if Ron couldnt do this tour. Unless they bring Govan in I cant see anyone doing Ron's fretless stuff.

Regarding the thread - Ron, Bucket, Robin/Fortus.

[bacardimayne]

Ron leaving would be a major catastrophe.

Only Bucket could fill his shoes and he is never going to come back.

Ron leaving = end of GNR.

Bucket wouldn't be able to play Rons guitar parts like Ron could play Buckets.

As of right now, nothing Ron has played on a GNR release is worthy of being played by Buckethead anyway.

[Desperado]

Ron leaving would be a major catastrophe.

Only Bucket could fill his shoes and he is never going to come back.

Ron leaving = end of GNR.

Bucket wouldn't be able to play Rons guitar parts like Ron could play Buckets.

As of right now, nothing Ron has played on a GNR release is worthy of being played by Buckethead anyway.

lol bucket isn't worthy to play them because he wouldn't be able to do it I love Bucket but he is no way near as good as Ron.

Edited June 7, 2012 by Desperado