Let's play NuGNR Survivor

[Freddie Mercury's Ghost]

You control NuGNR Island.

One member can come back, and one gets shipped away.

Who do you choose?

[finck6]

bring back robin finck and brain

[Guest Broskirose]

Revive Finck

Kill Ashba

Anyone who votes otherwise is a person.

[Freddie Mercury's Ghost]

I voted against Pitman - I understand Axl brought him in because he has a good background in electronica, but I don't think that's the direction the band will end up going in.

His major contributions in recent years are:

-Illegally sampling the intro of "Riad n' the Bedouins" from another song, getting the band in trouble

-Shitty background vocals

[OkCalculator]

Hah! Funny Idea for a thread.

Voted:

Bring Back: Buckethead

Let go: DJ

[bacardimayne]

Thought this was about MyGNR members and not GNR members.

Revive: Bucket

Kill: Frank

Put Pitman on drums for the live shows. I'm not sure if he can play or not, but he has to be better than Frank. Keep DJ around for SCOM and SCOM only.

Edited July 1, 2012 by bacardimayne

[Jakey Styley]

Pitman has little use anymore but it doesn't hurt to have him, so I kicked off Ashba. Bring back Bucket!

[Haters Gonna Hate]

Why is there no option to kick out Axl?

[Rustycage]

Welcome back Buckethead. Goodbye Ashba.

[Freddie Mercury's Ghost]

Why is there no option to kick out Axl?

Because people would choose him to be clever, but that wouldn't necessarily help us reach a consensus.

[dalsh327]

If you did GNR Big Brother, you prob. could get some of the house guests to play...

[FuddMckagan]

Lol at people saying "kill"

And GnR Big Brother would be a very interesting concept

[DirtyDeeds]

Not to be a dick but I don't want any of those guys back. I'm not saying that against the new band, I just think this current band is pretty decent. Minus Ashba. Boot Ashba. And his schwag.

[luciusfunk]

Revive Finck

Kill Ashba

Anyone who votes otherwise is a person.

Yep, I'm a person.

[Guest Broskirose]

Why is there no option to kick out Axl?

Because people would choose him to be clever, but that wouldn't necessarily help us reach a consensus.

Not really. After DJ, Axl would legit be my next choice.

Put him on the poll.

[SONOFABITCH]

I brought back Buckethead - not that I want him back, but it was the best of the worst. Being shipped is Dizzy Reed. It would be over 20 years over due.

[Guest Gunns]

Bring back bucket

[DirtyDeeds]

I just realized there are three current band members, full-fledged band members, that could be kicked out -- and not replaced, just gone-- and it would make no truly discernible difference in the sound or quality of the band.

That's kinda fucked up. Three completely useless members.

[Kill Devil Hill]

Bring back Bucket x100000000000.

I voted for DJ, but I won't be sad if Pitman or Dizzy get the boot because they're even more useless.

[bran]

ill trade dj,pitman and ill throw in dizzy as well for buckethead

Edited July 1, 2012 by bran

[batman007]

Give me bucket for Frank. And Bucket will sneak in Brain under his yellow coat!

[Johnny Drama]

I wanna get rid of alot of people......Dizzy, Bumble, DJ, Frank, Richard, Chris. Bring back Bucket on lead and Robin on rhythm/lead and Brain.

I actually like Bumble, Richard and Pitman wouldn't be bad in an extra collaborator kinda way but not as a full time band member. So yeah keep those three on in a West Arkeen kinda way, if that makes sense.

Oh and I want Brian Carroll, not some bender in a kabuki mask, a retarded puppet and junk food packaging on his head. K thx bai.

Edited July 1, 2012 by Johnny Drama

[batman007]

I wanna get rid of alot of people......Dizzy, Bumble, DJ, Frank, Richard, Chris. Bring back Bucket on lead and Robin on rhythm/lead and Brain.

I actually like Bumble, Richard and Pitman wouldn't be bad in an extra collaborator kinda way but not as a full time band member. So yeah keep those three on in a West Arkeen kinda way, if that makes sense.

Oh and I want Brian Carroll, not some bender in a kabuki mask, a retarded puppet and junk food packaging on his head. K thx bai.

He has to wear the mask, he has no face!

[Silent Jay]

Buckethead/ASHBA

[Bobbo]

Welcome back Buckethead. Goodbye Ashba.