If Axl got a widely known and respected guitarist, do you think people would still complain?

[Vincent Vega]

Let's say BBF quit and Axl somehow got someone like Zakk Wylde or someone like John 5 or Jimmy Page or Brian May or Joe Perry or Mick Taylor, or some other very well known and well respected guitarist to replace him, do you think a certain segment of the fanbase would STILL complain about and bash said guitarist?

Edited July 23, 2012 by Indigo Miser

[saber_]

Well of fuckin course they would!

[The Black]

I think gives the history, a widely known and respected guitarist wouldn't consider the offer.

[TheNightrain]

Yes.

[volcano62]

Yes they would. SOB, bobo, Sleeper, statanisk, groghan, arnold, maynard, rusty etc...would still come on here daily to cupcake and find shit to complain about.

[ZoSoRose]

Jimmy Page in Axl's GNR

Its my dream to see Jimmy, but no, just no rofl

[HisRoyalSweetness]

if he couldn't entice a big name to join him in the mid 90's, what chance do you think he stands now?

[bacardimayne]

Zakk Wylde is my dream replacement for Bumblefoot if Bucket isn't to come back. To think what we could have had if Slash was willing to work with him.

[jmapelian]

Didn't Zakk already quit GnR years ago?

[TeeJay410]

I mean it depends, can Zakk translate the TIL solo live? Because apparently that's like solving a rubik's cube blindfolded.

[Crash Diet]

Yes

[sleeper]

Yes they would. SOB, bobo, Sleeper, statanisk, groghan, arnold, maynard, rusty etc...would still come on here daily to cupcake and find shit to complain about.

Oh hell know I would not complain about Perry or Pagey! And I don't cupcake daily just 3 days a week!

Oh and thanks for putting me in the same catagory as SOB I'm honored!

[volcano62]

Yes they would. SOB, bobo, Sleeper, statanisk, groghan, arnold, maynard, rusty etc...would still come on here daily to cupcake and find shit to complain about.

Oh hell know I would not complain about Perry or Pagey! And I don't cupcake daily just 3 days a week!

Oh and thanks for putting me in the same catagory as SOB I'm honored!

I love you

[Rustycage]

Dunno.

[finck6]

Let's say BBF quit and Axl somehow got someone like Zakk Wylde or someone like John 5 or Jimmy Page or Brian May or Joe Perry or Mick Taylor, or some other very well known and well respected guitarist to replace him, do you think a certain segment of the fanbase would STILL complain about and bash said guitarist?

if big beard quits robin's back in guns n roses. cause robin's written and recorded the songs for the next guns n roses record. songs, big beard doesn't want on the next record. and robin already was a widely known and respected guitarist. a widely known and respected guitarist from NIN

[Jamiey1]

I mean it depends, can Zakk translate the TIL solo live? Because apparently that's like solving a rubik's cube blindfolded.

Depends on if you are happy with all the notes being harmonics?

[Bruno P.]

I mean it depends, can Zakk translate the TIL solo live? Because apparently that's like solving a rubik's cube blindfolded.

Depends on if you are happy with all the notes being harmonics?

haha so true!

[Rafał]

Zakk's style consists of excessive amount of:

- harmonics

- shredding

- spitting

They should just kick DJ out, and find a guitarist that works well with Fortus, who would become a lead guitarist (there would be two lead guitarists).

Edited July 23, 2012 by Rafał

[Vincent Vega]

Zakk's style consists of excessive amount of:

- harmonics

- shredding

- spitting

They should just kick DJ out, and find a guitarist that works well with Fortus, who would become a lead guitarist (there would be two lead guitarists).

Listen to Pride & Glory. Zakk isn't just about harmonics and shredding.

[Jakey Styley]

I get no enjoyment from listening to Zakk Wylde but he'd be a worthy replacement for Bumble.

[sailaway]

Yes they would. SOB, bobo, Sleeper, statanisk, groghan, arnold, maynard, rusty etc...would still come on here daily to cupcake and find shit to complain about.

So right you are,some people would bitch and moan if he got David Gilmour, Satriani,Vai and Malmsteen,Paul Gilbert,and ressurected Randy Rhodes from the great gig in the sky.

Nice little bitch list u have going there

[finck6]

for the record, there's only 1 widely known and respected guitarist who can nail TIL live with axl rose. it's not DJ. not zakk. it's Robin Finck

[Rustycage]

widely known and respected guitarist

Robin Finck

Those two things do not belong in a sentence together.

or even a paragraph.

[sailaway]

Let's say BBF quit and Axl somehow got someone like Zakk Wylde or someone like John 5 or Jimmy Page or Brian May or Joe Perry or Mick Taylor, or some other very well known and well respected guitarist to replace him, do you think a certain segment of the fanbase would STILL complain about and bash said guitarist?

People complain because so many guitarist have come and gone. The bad has no identity half the guys now playing contributed very little to nothin on CD. At this point it's too late to change it. Maybe 10 years ago

No,some complain just to complain,they put on a hell of a show.Caught one lately?

[volcano62]

Yes they would. SOB, bobo, Sleeper, statanisk, groghan, arnold, maynard, rusty etc...would still come on here daily to cupcake and find shit to complain about.

So right you are,some people would bitch and moan if he got David Gilmour, Satriani,Vai and Malmsteen,Paul Gilbert,and ressurected Randy Rhodes from the great gig in the sky.

Nice little bitch list u have going there

Thank you sir