Jump to content

GNR Discography - rank the songs from best to worst

the rush

By the rush
in 2012

 Share

Recommended Posts

the rush Full

the rush

Posted
  • Author
Posted

UYI I poll is active for another 24 hours

Standings after 11 votes:

01. November Rain - 3,9

02. Coma - 4,09

03. Don't Cry - 5,27

04. Don't Damn Me - 5,63

05. Dead Horse - 6,27

06. Dust N' Bones - 7,45

07. Perfect Crime - 7,54

08. Bad Obsession - 8,45

09. The Garden - 9,09

10. Right Next Door to Hell - 9,45

11. Double Talkin' Jive - 9,54

12. Garden of Eden - 10,45

13. Back Off Bitch - 11,09

14. Live and Let Die - 11,63

15. Bad Apples - 11,72

16. You Ain't the First - 14,36

  • Replies 94
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Cosmo FRONTMAN

Cosmo

Posted
Posted

1- November Rain

2- Coma

3- Don't Cry

4- Double Talkin Jive

5- Back Off Bitch

6- Don't Damn Me

7- Dead Horse

8- Live and Let Die

9- Dust N' Bones

10- You Ain't The First

11- Bad Apples

12- Bad Obsession

13- Perfect Crime

14- Garden Of Eden

15- Right Next Door To Hell

16- The Garden

ll_tj1 Full

ll_tj1

Posted
Posted

1- Coma

2- Don't Damn Me

3- Bad Apples

4- Dust N' Bones

5- Bad Obsession

6- Don't Cry

7- Dead Horse

8- November Rain

9- Perfect Crime

10- Double Talkin Jive

11- Garden Of Eden

12- Back Off Bitch

13- The Garden

14- Right Next Door To Hell

15- You Ain't The First

16- Live and Let Die

AxlUlrich Newbie

AxlUlrich

Posted
Posted

1. Don't Damn Me

2. Don't Cry

3. Garden of Eden

4. Back Off Bitch

5. Perfect Crime

6. Bad Obsession

7. Coma

8. Double Talkin Jive

9. Dust N' Bones

10. The Garden

11. November Rain

12. You Ain't the First

13. Dead Horse

14. Right Next Door to Hell

15. Live and Let Die

16. Bad Apples

the rush Full

the rush

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

END: UYI I

total votes: 15

result:

01. Coma - 3,73

02. November Rain - 4,53

03. Don't Cry - 5,46

04. Don't Damn Me - 5,53

05. Dead Horse - 6,66

06. Dust N' Bones - 7,06

07. Perfect Crime - 8,33

08. Bad Obsession - 8,46

09. Double Talkin Jive - 8,93

10. The Garden - 9,66

11. Garden of Eden - 9,73

12. Right Next Door to Hell - 10,33

13. Back Off BItch - 10,6

14. Bad Apples - 11,2

15. Live and Let Die - 11,8

16. You Ain't the First - 13,93

WE'LL COUNTINUE WITH GNR LIES IN THIS SAME THREAD AS SOON AS THE DUST RAISED BY BETTER VIDEO SETTLES DOWN

EDIT: to reduce the number of songs for the final round (as 40 is a bit too much) I found a new logic for the cutoff point. Average ranking of a song must be lower than half the album

Example: UYI 2 has 14 songs - song with the average of 7 and above doesn't maket the cut and song with the average of 7 and below does

20 songs that made the cut so far (CD, TSI, UYI1, UYI2):

Ain't It Fun

Better

Black Leather

Civil War

Coma

Dead Horse

Don't Cry org

Don't Damn Me

Down on the Farm

Dust N' Bones

Estranged

Hair of the Dog

Human Being

Locomotive

November Rain

Prostitute

Shackler's Revenge

There Was a Time

Yesterdays

You Could Be Mine

Edited by the rush
the rush Full

the rush

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

ROUND 5: GNR LIES (+ SYMPATHY FOR THE DEVIL + OH MY GOD)

it seems that Better video didn't raise as much dust as I thought it would so we might as well continue

rank sthe songs from best to worst. My apologies for forgetting these two additional songs and I know they're kind of odd men out here but still I believe we can manage

New rule for the cut-off point is: we're rankin 10 songs in round 5 so every song that has 5 and above average ranking does not go through to the final round

My list:

01. One in a Million

02. Oh My God

03. Move to the City

04. Patience

05. You're Crazy

06. Reckless Life

07. Used to love her

08. Mama Kin

09. Sympathy for the Devil

10. Nice Boys

proceed

Edited by the rush
EvH SUPER GOD

EvH

Posted
Posted

1- Sympathy For The Devil

2- You're Crazy

3- Patience

4- One In A Million

5- Used To Love Her

6- Oh My God

7- Nice Boys

8- Reckless Life

9- Move To The City

10- Mama Kin

Cosmo FRONTMAN

Cosmo

Posted
Posted

1- You're Crazy

2- Used To Love Her

3- Oh My God

4- One In A Million

5- Sympathy For The Devil

6- Nice Boys

7- Patience

8- Reckless Life

9- Mama Kin

10- Move To The City

Guest Satanisk_Slakt

Guest Satanisk_Slakt

Posted
Posted

1. One In A Million

2. You're Crazy

3. Move To The City

4. Patience

5. Nice Boys

6. Mama Kin

7. Sympathy For The Devil

8. Used To Love Her

9. Reckless Life

10. Oh My God

netcord Junior

netcord

Posted
Posted

1. You're Crazy

2. Sympathy for the Devil

3. Patience

4. One in a Million

5. Used to love her

6. Nice Boys

7. Mama Kin

8. Oh my God

9. Move to the City

10. Reckless Life

MB. OH MY GOD

MB.

Posted
Posted (edited)

1. One In A Million

2. You're crazy

3. Move to the city

4. Patience

5. Mama Kin

6. Used to love her

7. Sympathy For The Devil

8. Reckless life

9. Nice boys

10. Oh My God

Edited by MBRose
axlsalinger GOD

axlsalinger

Posted
Posted

1. Patience

2. You're Crazy (acoustic)

3. One in a Million

4. Oh My God

5. Sympathy For the Devil

6. Used to Love Her

7. Mama Kin

8. Nice Boys

9. Reckless Life

10. Move to the City

the rush Full

the rush

Posted
  • Author
Posted

standings after 11 votes:

01. You're Crazy - 2,63

02. One in a Million - 2,72

03. Patience - 3,09

04. Sympathy for the Devil - 5,18

05. Used to Love Her - 5,72

06. Mama Kin - 6,63

07. Oh My God - 7,18

08. Nice Boys - 7,18

09. Reckless Life - 7,27

10. Move to the City - 7,36

GivenToFly FRONTMAN

GivenToFly

Posted
Posted

1. Nice Boys

2. Patience

3. Oh My God

4. One in a Million

5. Reckless Life

6. Used to Love Her

7. Move to the City

8. You're Crazy

9. Mama Kin

10. Sympathy for the Devil

Eppe Newbie

Eppe

Posted
Posted

1. Reckless Life

2. Nice Boys

3. Patience

4. One in a Million

5. Used to Love Her

6. Oh My God

7. Mama Kin

8. You're Crazy

9. Move to the City

10 Sympathy for the Devil

Apollo LEGEND

Apollo

Posted
Posted

1. You're Crazy

2. One in a Million

3. Patience

4. Used to Love Her

5. Nice Boys

6. Mama Kin

7. Reckless Life

8. Move to the City

9 Sympathy for the Devil

10. Oh My God

the rush Full

the rush

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

END: GNR LIES + OMG + SFTD

total votes: 15 (it seems 15 votes has become a rule. in our heyday we got 33 for CD and 32 for UYI2, everything else 15 :)

01. One in a Million - 2,68

02. Patience - 3,06

03. You're Crazy - 3,06

04. Used to Love Her - 5,5

05. Nice Boys - 6,31

06. Sympathy for the Devil - 6,37

07. Oh My God - 6,68

08. Reckless Life - 6,93

09. Mama Kin - 7,06

10. Move to the City - 7,31

AFD and final to go

edit: bacardimayne, I included your late vote just because you're a regular voter :)

Edited by the rush
the rush Full

the rush

Posted
  • Author
Posted

ROUND 6: APPETITE FOR DESTRUCTION

songs with avarege ranking above six won't make it

01. Sweet Child o' Mine

02. Welcome to the Jungle

03. Paradise City

04. Nightrain

05. It's So Easy

06. Rocket Queen

07. Out ta Get Me

08. Mr Brownstone

09. Anything Goes

10. Think about You

11. My Michelle

12. You're Crazy

SoulMonster LEGEND

SoulMonster

Posted
Posted

01. Welcome to the Jungle

02. Nightrain

03. Sweet Child O'Mine

04. It's So Easy

05. Rocket Queen

06. Mr. Brownstone

07. You're Crazy

08. Paradise City

09. My Michelle

10. Think About You

11. Out Ta Get Me

12. Anything Goes

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...