What is worse? Indiana Jones 4 or Phantom Menace?

[Vincent Vega]

Which do you think was the worst film--Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, or Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace?

[Use Your Delusion 1]

star wars

probably the worst movie ever.

[Dan H.]

The Phantom Menace

[Johnny Drama]

Really? Nuking the fridge don't count no more?

[Tater Totts]

I would say Indy 4, Episode 1 is better than Episode 2 by far.

[Use Your Delusion 1]

ja ja binks.

that is all.

[Johnny Drama]

Jar Jar Binks was the greatest character of all time.

[TeeJay410]

I'll go indy 4, because Phantom Menace wasn't even the worst one of the franchise. Darth Maul was an awesome character in an awful movie. Just about every frame of indiana jones 4 is unforgivable.

[GivenToFly]

You know, I wanted to make this thread. Well sort of. I wanted to do: Star Wars prequels / Indiana Jones 4 / Matrix sequels / Alien 3 and 4 / Terminator 3 and 4.

Either way it's Star Wars. The drop in quality from the originals gives me vertigo.

[31illusions]

Episode 1. At least Indy 4 had a few throwbacks in it to remind you of the better films.

[Rovim]

I'll go indy 4, because Phantom Menace wasn't even the worst one of the franchise. Darth Maul was an awesome character in an awful movie. Just about every frame of indiana jones 4 is unforgivable.

This.

[Angelica]

Phantom Menace, because it's so immeasurably tedious. Crystal Gophers is deeply and consistently terrible, but it's not dull.

Edited September 16, 2012 by Angelica

[PappyTron]

You know, I wanted to make this thread. Well sort of. I wanted to do: Star Wars prequels / Indiana Jones 4 / Matrix sequels / Alien 3 and 4 / Terminator 3 and 4.

Either way it's Star Wars. The drop in quality from the originals gives me vertigo.

Alien 3 is a brilliant film.

[Angelica]

You know, I wanted to make this thread. Well sort of. I wanted to do: Star Wars prequels / Indiana Jones 4 / Matrix sequels / Alien 3 and 4 / Terminator 3 and 4.

Either way it's Star Wars. The drop in quality from the originals gives me vertigo.

Alien 3 is a brilliant film.

I think I've gotten into more arguments over Alien 3 than any other film! It is brilliant and the 'assembled cut' is even more so. If Fincher's ego ever recovers from the experience, and cuts the version he originally intended, it would presumably be a flat out masterpiece.

[Johnny Drama]

[bacardimayne]

Indy 4. I actually enjoyed TPM and in retrospect, I consider it the best of the prequels. Never been a big Indiana Jones fan, but the 1st and 3rd ones are good.

Edited September 16, 2012 by bacardimayne

[Nosaj Thing]

You know, I wanted to make this thread. Well sort of. I wanted to do: Star Wars prequels / Indiana Jones 4 / Matrix sequels / Alien 3 and 4 / Terminator 3 and 4.

Either way it's Star Wars. The drop in quality from the originals gives me vertigo.

Alien 3 is a brilliant film.

I think I've gotten into more arguments over Alien 3 than any other film! It is brilliant and the 'assembled cut' is even more so. If Fincher's ego ever recovers from the experience, and cuts the version he originally intended, it would presumably be a flat out masterpiece.

I had no idea that there was an "assembly cut" of Alien 3.

[Angelica]

You know, I wanted to make this thread. Well sort of. I wanted to do: Star Wars prequels / Indiana Jones 4 / Matrix sequels / Alien 3 and 4 / Terminator 3 and 4.

Either way it's Star Wars. The drop in quality from the originals gives me vertigo.

Alien 3 is a brilliant film.

I think I've gotten into more arguments over Alien 3 than any other film! It is brilliant and the 'assembled cut' is even more so. If Fincher's ego ever recovers from the experience, and cuts the version he originally intended, it would presumably be a flat out masterpiece.

I had no idea that there was an "assembly cut" of Alien 3.

On that Quadrilody box set that came out about five years ago.

[izzygirl]

I didn't watch Indiana Jones 4, but Phantom Menace was a big waste of time, so I voted for it.

[Tater Totts]

You know, I wanted to make this thread. Well sort of. I wanted to do: Star Wars prequels / Indiana Jones 4 / Matrix sequels / Alien 3 and 4 / Terminator 3 and 4.

Either way it's Star Wars. The drop in quality from the originals gives me vertigo.

Alien 3 is a brilliant film.

I think I've gotten into more arguments over Alien 3 than any other film! It is brilliant and the 'assembled cut' is even more so. If Fincher's ego ever recovers from the experience, and cuts the version he originally intended, it would presumably be a flat out masterpiece.

I had no idea that there was an "assembly cut" of Alien 3.

On that Quadrilody box set that came out about five years ago.

The Alien 3 assembly cut is awesome! Always choose to watch it over the theatrical one.

[Georgy Zhukov]

I liked Indiana Jones 4. Spielberg forgot how to make a fun movie since he's done Schindler's List but it was a hell of a lot better than Phantom Menace.

[Death Star]

As an Indy fan why do most people hate film 4? I thought the fridge nuke thing was genius. Sort of reminded me of something James Bond would do. As a SW fan I think Phantom is no where near as good as II or III.

[Getizzyback]

I think the Phantom Menace is the overall better film....but I was more disappointed with it than the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull.

My expectations were far higher with PM, because it had the Star Wars tag to live up to.

Indiana Jones had no pressure, it is just a fun franchise. Kinda surprised Harrison Ford made it.

[Graeme]

You know, I wanted to make this thread. Well sort of. I wanted to do: Star Wars prequels / Indiana Jones 4 / Matrix sequels / Alien 3 and 4 / Terminator 3 and 4.

Either way it's Star Wars. The drop in quality from the originals gives me vertigo.

Alien 3 is a brilliant film.

I think I've gotten into more arguments over Alien 3 than any other film! It is brilliant and the 'assembled cut' is even more so. If Fincher's ego ever recovers from the experience, and cuts the version he originally intended, it would presumably be a flat out masterpiece.

I had no idea that there was an "assembly cut" of Alien 3.

On that Quadrilody box set that came out about five years ago.

The Alien 3 assembly cut is awesome! Always choose to watch it over the theatrical one.

Tried watching both, in both instances I got halfway through and was enjoying what I saw so little that I turned the film off... I physically cannot finish watching Alien 3 it would seem. I have never enjoyed a film less. If I could actually write that film out of history, I would not hesitate.