Jump to content

GNR Top 30


the rush

Recommended Posts

1. Below are the songs that made it to the final top 30 (7 AFD songs, 3 Lies songs, 6 UYI1 and 5 UYI2 songs, 5 TSI songs and 4 CD songs)

2. Rank them from best to worst

3. This poll will be active a little longer than previous ones

4. You can copy the songs from my list and just rearrange them to fit your preference

5. Do not add songs that are not on the list

6. Include all these songs in your list

7. please write numbers in front of the songs

My List:

01. November Rain

02. Sweet Child o' Mine

03. You Could Be Mine

04. Civil War

05. Nightrain

06. Welcome to the Jungle

07. Estranged

08. Paradise City

09. It's So Easy

10. Don't Cry

11. Better

12. Prostitute

13. Coma

14. Shackler's Revenge

15. Locomotive

16. Yesterdays

17. One in a Million

18. There Was a Time

19. Rocket Queen

20. Mr Brownstone

21. You're Crazy (GNR Lies)

22. Don't Damn Me

23. Dust N' Bones

24. Down on the Farm

25. Patience

26. Dead Horse

27. Hair of the Dog

28. Black Leather

29. Human Being

30. Ain't It Fun

Edited by the rush
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 78
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

01. There Was A Time

02. Locomotive

03. Welcome to the Jungle

04. Don't Damn Me

05. Sweet Child O' Mine

06. It's So Easy

07. Better

08. Nightrain

09. Estranged

10. Mr. Brownstone

11. Patience

12. You Could Be Mine

13. Paradise City

14. Rocket Queen

15. One In A Million

16. You're Crazy (GNR Lies)

17. Shackler's Revenge

18. Coma

19. Don't Cry

20. Civil War

21. Dust N' Bones

22. Down On The Farm

23. November Rain

24. Yesterdays

25. Dead Horse

26. Prostitute

27. Ain't It Fun

28. Human Being

29. Hair of the Dog

30. Black Leather

HARD!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Nightrain

2. Estranged

3. November Rain

4. There Was a Time

5. Rocket Queen

6. Locomotive

7. You're Crazy (Lies)

8. Coma

9. Sweet Child O' Mine

10. You Could Be Mine

11. Paradise City

12. One in a Million

13. Civil War

14. Better

15. Welcome to the Jungle

16. Don't Damn Me

17. Dust N' Bones

18. Mr. Brownstone

19. Yesterdays

20. Patience

21. Shackler's Revenge

22. Don't Cry

23. It's So Easy

24. Dead Horse

25. Down on the Farm

26. Prostitute

27. Human Being

28. Ain't It Fun

29. Black Leather

30. Hair of the Dog

can't believe 4 terrible songs from TSI made it while 14 years didn't

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1) Welcome to the Jungle

2) Estranged

3) Rocket Queen

4) Paradise City

5) Nightrain

6) Better

7) TWAT

8) Don't Cry

9) It's so Easy

10) Sweet Child O' Mine

11) Civil War

12) November Rain

13) You Could be Mine

14) Prostitute

15) You're Crazy (Lies)

16) Mr. Brownstone

17) Patience

18) One in a Million

19) Coma

20) Shackler's Revenge

21) Yesterday

22) Dead Horse

23) Dust N' Bones

24) Don't Damn Me

25) Locomotive

26) Down on the Farm

27) Ain't It Fun

28) Black Leather

29) Human Being

30) Hair of the Dog

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Satanisk_Slakt

1. Sweet Child O' Mine

2. Civil War

3. It's So Easy

4. Estranged

5. Mr Brownstone

6. Dust N' Bones

7. Black Leather

8. Nightrain

9. You Could Be Mine

10. One In A Million

11. Dead Horse

12. You're Crazy (Lies)

13. Ain't It Fun

14. Rocket Queen

15. Welcome To The Jungle

16. Don't Cry (Original)

17. Down On The Farm

18. Human Being

19. Locomotive

20. Don't Damn Me

21. Patience

22. Coma

23. Paradise City

24. November Rain

25. Better

26. Hair Of The Dog

27. Yesterdays

28. There Was A Time

29. Prostitute

30. Shackler's Revenge

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1.Better

2.Nightrain

3.Estranged

4.Shackler's Revenge

5.You Could Be Mine

6.Don't Cry

7.Patience

8.Dead Horse

9.November Rain

10.Civil War

11.Black Leather

12.Don't Damn Me

13.Mr. Brownstone

14.It's So Easy

15.Welcome To The Jungle

16.Sweet Child O' Mine

17.Ain't It Fun

18.Dust N' Bones

19.Hair Of The Dog

20.Prostitute

21.Paradise City

22.Rocket Queen

23.You're Crazy (Lies)

24.One In A Million

25.Yesterdays

26.There Was A Time

27.Coma

28.Locomotive

29.Human Being

30.Down On The Farm

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Locomotive

2. Coma

3. Civil War

4. Welcome To The Jungle

5. Estranged

6. November Rain

7. Nightrain

8. Don't Cry (Original)

9. Mr. Brownstone

10. Dead Horse

11. Rocket Queen

12. Paradise City

13. Dust N' Bones

14. You Could Be Mine

15. It's So Easy

16. Don't Damn Me

17. Yesterdays

18. Patience

19. Sweet Child O' Mine

20. One In A Million

21. You're Crazy (Lies)

22. Down On The Farm

23. Black Leather

24. Human Being

25. Ain't It Fun

26. Hair Of The Dog

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

27. Better

28. There Was A Time

29. Prostitute

30. Shackler's Revenge

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Estranged

2. Paradise City

3. Welcome To The Jungle

4. November Rain

5. You Could Be Mine

6. Rocket Queen

7. Nightrain

8. Mr. Brownstone

9. Better

10. Shackler's Revenge

11. There Was A Time

12. Sweet Child O' Mine

13. Civil War

14. Prostitute

15. It's So Easy

16. Don't Cry

17. Patience

18. Locomotive

19. Dust N' Bones

20. Coma

21. Ain't It Fun

22. Yesterdays

23. One In A Million

24. Down On The Farm

25. Don't Damn Me

26. Hair Of The Dog

27. You're Crazy (Lies)

28. Dead Horse

29. Black Leather

30. Human Being

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Estranged

2. Sweet Child o' Mine

3. There Was a Time

4. Better

5. Welcome to the jungle

6. Rocket Queen

7. One in a million

8. Ain't it fun

9. Prostitute

10. Don't cry

11. Coma

12. You're crazy, lies

13. November Rain

14. Don't damn me

15. It's so easy

16. Mr Brownstone

17. You could be mine

18. Shackler's revenge

19. Civil war

20. Paradise city

21. Down on the farm

22. Dead horse

23. Patience

24. Nightrain

25. Locomotive

26. Yesterdays

27. Dust N' Bones

28. Black Leather

29. Human Being

30. Hair of the dog

Edited by The.mad.hatter.99
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1.Paradise City

2.You could be mine

3.Dont cry

4.November rain

5.Civil war

6.COMA

7.Welcome to the jungle

8.Sweet child o mine

9.Its so easy

10.Nightrain

11.Locomotive

12.Patience

13.Mr Brownstone

14.Rocket Queen

15.Dead horse

16.Dont damn me

17.Estrenged

18.Dust N Bones

19.One in a million

20.You are crazy

21.Yesterdays

22.Black Leather

23.Ain it fun

24.Down on the farm

25.Hair of the dog

26.Human being

27.Better

28.There was a time

29.Prostitute

30.Shacklers revenge

Link to comment
Share on other sites

01. Nightrain

02. Paradise City

03. Rocket Queen

04. Don't Cry

05. You Could Be Mine

06. Patience

07. Dead Horse

08. November Rain

09. Sweet Child o' Mine

10. Welcome to the Jungle

11. Coma

12. Yesterdays

13. Estranged

14. It's So Easy

15. Dust N' Bones

16. One in a Million

17. Locomotive

18. Mr Brownstone

19. You're Crazy (GNR Lies)

20. Civil War

21. There Was a Time

22. Don't Damn Me

23. Down on the Farm

24. Shackler's Revenge

25. Hair of the Dog

26. Prostitute

27. Black Leather

28. Better

29. Ain't It Fun

30. Human Being

Link to comment
Share on other sites

01. Paradise City

02. Welcome to the Jungle

03. November Rain

04. Civil War

05. Sweet Child o' Mine

06. Estranged

07. Don't Cry

08. Mr Brownstone

09. Patience

10. Don't Damn Me

11. You Could Be Mine

12. Better

13. Rocket Queen

14. Yesterdays

15. It's So Easy

16. Dead Horse

17. There Was a Time

18. One in a Million

19. Shackler's Revenge

20. You're Crazy (GNR Lies)

21. Nightrain

22. Dust N' Bones

23. Coma

24. Down on the Farm

25. Prostitute

26. Ain't It Fun

27. Locomotive

28. Hair of the Dog

29. Black Leather

30. Human Being

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1) Estranged

2) There was a time

3) Coma

4) Welcome to the jungle

5) Civil War

6) Don't cry

7) Nightrain

8) Rocket Queen

9) One in a million

10) You're crazy (Lies)

11) Locomotive

12) Prostitute

13) Dead horse

14) Patience

15) Don't damn me

16) You could be mine

17) Mr brownstone

18) It's so easy

19) Better

20) Shackler's revenge

21) Human being

22) Ain't it fun

23) Dust n' bones

24) Down on the farm

25) Sweet child o'mine

26) Yesterdays

27) Human being

28) November rain

29) Black leather

30) Hair of the dog

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. November Rain

2. Estranged

3. Nightrain

4. Civil War

5. Shackler’s Revenge

6. Rocket Queen

7. Better

8. Welcome to the Jungle

9. There Was a Time

10. Sweet Child of Mine

11. Coma

12. It’s So Easy

13. Mr. Brownstone

14. Don’t Cry

15. Prostitute

16. Dust N' Bones

17. Don't Damn Me

18. You Could Be Mine

19. Paradise City

20. Locomotive

21. Yesterdays

22. One in a Million

23. You're Crazy (GNR Lies)

24. Down on the Farm

25. Dead Horse

26. Human Being

27. Patience

28. Ain’t It Fun

29. Hair of the Dog

30. Black Leather

Edited by The Sandman
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Estranged

2. Welcome to the Jungle

3. Rocket Queen

4. Don't Damn Me

5. Civil War

6. November Rain

7. Sweet Child o' Mine

8. Paradise City

9. There Was a Time

10. Locomotive

11. You Could Be Mine

12. Patience

13. You're Crazy (GNR Lies)

14. Mr. Brownstone

15. Prostitute

16. Don't Cry

17. Better

18. Coma

19. Nightrain

20. Yesterdays

21. Shackler's Revenge

22. One in a Million

23. Human Being

24. It's So Easy

25. Dust n' Bones

26. Down on the Farm

27. Dead Horse

28. Hair of the Dog

29. Ain't it Fun

30. Black Leather

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. There Was a Time

2. Prostitute

3. Better

4. Paradise City

5. Sweet Child o' Mine

6. Welcome to the Jungle

7. Nightrain

8. You Could Be Mine

9. Rocket Queen

10. It's So Easy

11. Estranged

12. Shackler's Revenge

13. November Rain

14. Don't Cry

15. Dead Horse

16. Patience

17. One in a Million

18. Coma

19. Civil War

20. Don't Damn Me

21. Mr Brownstone

22. You're Crazy (GNR Lies)

23. Down on the Farm

24. Yesterdays

25. Locomotive

26. Black Leather

27. Human Being

28. Ain't It Fun

29. Dust N' Bones

30. Hair of the Dog

Link to comment
Share on other sites

standings after 11 votes:

TOP HALF = TOP 15: AFD 7/7, Lies 1/3, UYI1 2/6, UYI2 4/5, TSI 0/5, CD 1/4

01. Estranged - 6,27

02. Nightrain - 6,81

03. Welcome to the Jungle - 7,36

04. You Could Be Mine - 8,09

05. Sweet Child o' Mine - 8,72

06. November Rain - 8,81

07. Paradise City - 8,9

08. Civil War - 9,54

09. Don't Cry - 10,81

10. Rocket Queen - 11,27

11. It's So Easy - 12

12. Mr. Brownstone - 12,54

13. Patience - 14,81

14. Better - 15,18

15. Locomotive - 15,36

16. Coma - 15,36

17. Don't Damn Me - 17

18. There Was a Time - 17,18

19. Dead Horse - 17,45

20. One in a Million - 17,45

21. Dust N' Bones - 17,72

22. You're Crazy (lies) - 18,27

23. Yesterdays - 19,81

24. Shackler's Revenge - 19,9

25. Prostitute - 22,72

26. Down on the Farm - 23,72

27. Black Leather - 23,9

28. Ain't It Fun - 24,18

29. Hair of the Dog - 26,45

30. Human Being - 27,27

Where should we cut it people? Top 10? Top 15? Top 20?

All of TSI songs are at the bottom of the pile for now. Four cd songs in top 25, two in the top 20, one in top 15, none in top 10

All of AFD in the top 15:

1. AFD 100%

2. UYI2 80%

3. UYI1 33%

4. LIES 33%

5. CD 25%

6. TSI 0%

Edited by the rush
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Estranged

2. Rocket Queen

3. Nightrain

4. Better

5. Coma

6. Paradise City

7. Shackler's Revenge

8. Civil War

9. You Could Be Mine

10. It's So Easy

11. Don't Cry

12. Sweet Child O' Mine

13. There Was A Time

14. Patience

15. Welcome To The Jungle

16. Prostitute

17. You're Crazy

18. November Rain

19. Mr. Brownstone

20. One In A Million

21. Down On The Farm

22. Yesterdays

23. Dust N' Bones

24. Dead Horse

25. Locomotive

26. Don't Damn Me

27. Hair Of The Dog

28. Black Leather

29. Ain't It Fun

30. Human Being

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why are there so many TSI songs on it? How did you calculate it?

List will follow, it's difficult

Each album was ranked individually and the songs that got through are those that had the average ranking in the top half of the album. for example: TSI has 13 songs. half of 13 is 6,5 so every song with an average ranking below 6,5 made it. CD has the least amount of songs because votes were not so typically spread = some songs got both low and high rankings but the point was to separate those songs that are "universally" liked from those that are not which means that better twat shackler and prostitute are the most universally liked while the likes of madagascar and til got many good rankings but also as many bad rankings

In the end, it doesn't matter because as you can see, all Spaghetti songs are from 25-30 on the list which makes it worst GNR album beyond a shadow of doubt and you can effectively look at it as being either a top 20, top 15 or top whatever list

Edited by the rush
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 Estranged

2 Welcome to the Jungle

3 There Was a Time

4 Mr Brownstone

5 Nightrain

6 Yesterdays

7 It's So Easy

8 You Could Be Mine

9 Rocket Queen

10 Civil War

11 Shackler's Revenge

12 Sweet Child o' Mine

13 Hair of the Dog

14 Don't Cry

15 Dust N' Bones

16 Locomotive

17 November Rain

18 Patience

19 You're Crazy (GNR Lies)

20 Coma

21 Better

22 Paradise City

23 Dead Horse

24 Don't Damn Me

25 Prostitute

26 One in a Million

27 Down on the Farm

28 Black Leather

29 Human Being

30 Ain't It Fun

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Estranged

2. Nightrain

3. Coma

4. Cival War

5. Rocket Queen

6. One in a Million

7. Dead Horse

8. SCOM

9. NR

10. Mr. Brownstone

11. It's so easy

12. You could be mine

13. Don't cry

14. Don't damn me

15. WTTJ

16. Yesterdays

17. Dust 'n Bones

18. Locomotive

19. You're crazy

20. Paradise City

21. There was a time

22. Patience

23. Better

24. Ain't it fun

25. Shacklers

26. Prostitute

27. Down on the farm

28. Black leather

29. Hair of the dog

30. Human Being

Edited by MBRose
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



×
×
  • Create New...