Who was the best singer in their prime, Axl Rose or Sebastian Bach?

[Towelie]

Bach's the better at ballads, but nothing can beat Axl's rasp on the rockers!

[DizzyReedsexmachine]

AXL>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Bach

[Rovim]

Voted Axl. Bach was pretty good, but that fucking vibrato can be annoying at times. Axl's voice is still my favorite. Plus it's very versatile.

[Zeppelin]

Bach. Love Axl's voice, but Bach gets my vote.

[The Sandman]

Man, that's tough!

[username]

Axl by a million miles.

[Chinaski]

Axl by a million miles.

[Ragnar]

Axl not even close wider range, better tone, timbre, pitch, phrasing, more versatility in his voice, more rasp and grittiness, better songwriitng skills

[bran]

i like them both, but i give it to axl.

[Powerage5]

Axl. Love both, but Axl is definitely a more versatile vocalist.

[dalsh327]

Baz's voice served him well on Broadway, but I think the GNR songs themselves are hard for anyone to sing, and you can hear when they've done "My Michelle" that Sebastian's not getting it quite right. There's probably people who could go toe to toe with Axl, but very very few.

[Jakey Styley]

Worst poll ever.

[ZoSoRose]

LOLaxl

love bach though. he was still awesome live too when i saw him in 2010 (although axl was even better at that note)

[Zint]

Bach's the better at ballads, but nothing can beat Axl's rasp on the rockers!

It comes to this, really.

But I voted Axl.

[izzygirl]

Bon Scott.

[MB.]

Bon Scott.

He isn't in the poll, now choose again!

[izzygirl]

Bon Scott.

He isn't in the poll, now choose again!

Boo... I choose Axl. Bach makes me nervous.

[The Real McCoy]

Axl. Not even close.

[Zeppelin]

Bach's the better at ballads, but nothing can beat Axl's rasp on the rockers!

I prefer Bach's voice on rockers. Monkey Business, Livin' On A Chain Gang, Midnight/Tornado, etc. Love it. But Axl still kicks ass on rockers.

[Powerage5]

Bon Scott.

He isn't in the poll, now choose again!

Boo... I choose Axl. Bach makes me nervous.

Bach makes me nervous too...every time he swings his mic out 15 feet over his head, I'm always worried he'll conk someone in the front row in the head with it

[jman2000]

Definitely Mr. William f'n Axl Rose.

[Ragnar]

Bon Scott.

Axl > > > > Bon

[Dariablue]

Axl by a million miles.

This.

Lol people who said Bach was better at ballads.

[Nosaj Thing]

There's no comparison. Bach was damn good but Axl was unique.

Bon Scott.

Axl > > > > Bon

This,

[Tyler Drama]

Bon Scott.

He isn't in the poll, now choose again!

Boo... I choose Axl. Bach makes me nervous.

Bach makes me nervous too...every time he swings his mic out 15 feet over his head, I'm always worried he'll conk someone in the front row in the head with it

This! I get scared every time I always think he's gonna hit a band member. I guess he uses a wired microphone just to swing it like that.