Apollo Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 Bbf and Axl shouldn't be the only ones who get to celebrate slash's amazing musical legacy. They get to make a living playing his amazing music, but fans aren't allowed to talk about it? Only in bizarro nugnr world.Exactly.Guys like Volcano don't understand this. He thinks that Axl wrote and played all of Slash's guitar parts on the old albums.You gotta remember, this is a guy who said "I came instantly in my pants" when he heard that Axl was coming to Canada earlier this year. And thinks that DJ plays Slash's guitar parts better than Slash did.So that's what you are dealing with.
wfuckinga Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 Bucket and Robin play Slash's stuff better than he ever did. Bbf does a great job as well, as does Dj.
Bruno P. Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 It was ok. The trolling didnt bother him and it was light. It was the spamming that fucked up everything. I tried to tell him that we could hear his voice better when he was in front of the camera but all he could read was "when are you coming back to argentina?" and "Brazil loves ya <3". Fkn morons. 1
SoulMonster Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 this is a guy who said "I came instantly in my pants" when he heard that Axl was coming to CanadaDo you think he actually DID come in his pants? Because if not, what's your point in labouring on an expression which just means he was excited about it?And the discussion you are all getting so riled up about is just silly. No one is saying we can't talk about Bumblefoot playing Slash's music. Just chill.
wfuckinga Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 It was ok. The trolling didnt bother him and it was light. It was the spamming that fucked up everything. I tried to tell him that we could hear his voice better when he was in front of the camera but all he could read was "when are you coming back to argentina?" and "Brazil loves ya <3". Fkn morons.Don't forget the ever popularPlease come to brasil
ARBeast Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 It should not be a fans job to support the band blindly like a sheep. They should be able to criticise things which are bad, and praise things which are good.Exactly. Things aren't great at all right now. And we should act like it is?Who says you should?Other than Jarmo hopefully no one..So it is a moot issue.Lol don't you have music to go leak with msl somewhere?this is a guy who said "I came instantly in my pants" when he heard that Axl was coming to CanadaDo you think he actually DID come in his pants? Because if not, what's your point in labouring on an expression which just means he was excited about it?And the discussion you are all getting so riled up about is just silly. No one is saying we can't talk about Bumblefoot playing Slash's music. Just chill.Well, I do. Moot points aside. But I was told privately in a recent time period he did that!!!!
SoulMonster Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 It should not be a fans job to support the band blindly like a sheep. They should be able to criticise things which are bad, and praise things which are good.Exactly. Things aren't great at all right now. And we should act like it is?Who says you should?Other than Jarmo hopefully no one..So it is a moot issue.Lol don't you have music to go leak with msl somewhere?Err, what? 1
Bruno P. Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 (edited) It was ok. The trolling didnt bother him and it was light. It was the spamming that fucked up everything. I tried to tell him that we could hear his voice better when he was in front of the camera but all he could read was "when are you coming back to argentina?" and "Brazil loves ya <3". Fkn morons.Don't forget the ever popularPlease come to brasilHahahahahaha there was this one guy that didnt stop asking "you will come back to south america this year, but doing solo tours. How do you feel about that?" Edited October 29, 2013 by Bruno P.
ARBeast Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 Hehe You know how hard i've been trying to find those!!!! and i cant!!! my life sucks!!!!
SoulMonster Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 Hehe You know how hard i've been trying to find those!!!! and i cant!!! my life sucks!!!!No, I have no idea how hard you have been trying to find...anything. Nor do I have an idea how that puzzling statement serves as an appropriate reply to me laughing of the South Americans spamming.
Nick85 Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 So...to recap...he said nothing about GNR's upcoming plans, be it touring or otherwise. Correct?
SoulMonster Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 So...to recap...he said nothing about GNR's upcoming plans, be it touring or otherwise. Correct?Yes.
Apollo Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 (edited) So the GnR "team" screwed up again............big surprise.BBF seems like the coolest member of the band and the one who actually cares about his fans. But it is sad that a guy who has been in a band for 7 years can't answer specific band related questions? He should be able to tell us about specific songs, when they hope to release a new album, info about the DVD, the next tour, etc. Volcano and Wf*ck continue to show what "real" fans they are by worshipping the current band's every move and by insulting Slash at every opportunity possible. Because insulting Slash means you are TRUE Axl fan.Barcadi is deeply offended by anybody over the age of 25.People were pretending to be other posters in the chat...........which was funny the first time people were doing that about six months ago, but now seems kind of silly and not very creative.A band member gives his time to chat with fans, why would people want to cupcake or harass him? All that is going to do is make him and other band members NOT do it anymore.And by trolling I mean pretending to be other forum members and asking stupid question. I don't consider asking Slash or replacement questions as trolling, as those are things that are on people's minds. Look how easy it is to answer those questions "I admire and respect Slash's work as a guitar player and am honored to add my touch to the songs he helped make famous. What guitar player wouldn't want to play GnR songs and Slash riffs"........"You can call me a replacement player, but I get to travel the world, am well paid, and I get to play great songs with great musicians every show. I'm living the dream. And I get to meet thousands of great GnR fans."See how easy that was to respond to "how does it feel to be a replacement player" questions? Edited October 29, 2013 by Groghan 1
wfuckinga Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 It was ok. The trolling didnt bother him and it was light. It was the spamming that fucked up everything. I tried to tell him that we could hear his voice better when he was in front of the camera but all he could read was "when are you coming back to argentina?" and "Brazil loves ya <3". Fkn morons.Don't forget the ever popularPlease come to brasilHahahahahaha there was this one guy that didnt stop asking "you will come back to south america this year, but doing solo tours. How do you feel about that?" Must be frustrating as hell. Didn't they spam his twitter to the point of him saying he'll make sure GNR never goes back to Argentina?
Nick85 Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 So...to recap...he said nothing about GNR's upcoming plans, be it touring or otherwise. Correct?Yes.Yeesh.
Bono Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 We all know I'm not a fan of slash but I would never go to a chat and insult him. that's the difference between me and the bitter ex-fans.Oh STFU. How can you to claim to be a Guns N' Roses fan and then say you aren't a fan of Slash. What the fuck are you a fan of then? All the amazing guitar riffs and solos that Axl wrote? GnR fans get dumber by the second. Most pathetic fan base of all time.Maybe because Slah is a self serving compulsive liar? And maybe he, like myself, is more of a fan of the new amazing riffs/solos (the CD era ones)Hahahahaha! Riiiight. Nut meet Swinger
niceguy Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 Bucket and Robin play Slash's stuff better than he ever did. Bbf does a great job as well, as does Dj.Agreed. And Celine Dion sings Axl's parts far better than he ever could.Doesn't mean I wanna hear AFD sung by Celine Dion.
DR DOOM Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 Wow, this thread is just dripping with irony considering who started it...pot, say hello to kettle
liers Posted October 29, 2013 Posted October 29, 2013 (edited) There weren't many cupcakes, which is good....I think Ron and all the new members get a lot of crap for nothing. If you were good enough at guitar and were asked to join GnR, would you really say no? The money, the fame, the legend....If someone you liked at your job got fired, would you hate their replacement? If the local store fired your favorite cashier, would you take it out on their replacement? Edited October 29, 2013 by liers
Mastodonny Posted October 30, 2013 Posted October 30, 2013 Lolcano knows all about shame and embarrassment.
Apollo Posted October 30, 2013 Posted October 30, 2013 There weren't many cupcakes, which is good....I think Ron and all the new members get a lot of crap for nothing. If you were good enough at guitar and were asked to join GnR, would you really say no? The money, the fame, the legend....If someone you liked at your job got fired, would you hate their replacement? If the local store fired your favorite cashier, would you take it out on their replacement?People aren't mad at Ron for joining the band.They are disappointed that a guy who has been in a band for 7 years CANT talk about the future of the band or what the band's plans are.They are disappointed that he and DJ haven't written any material for the band.They are disappointed that Axl fought so hard to keep the GnR name............only to have a revolving door of musicians and only put out ONE album of material over a 15 year period.I think the majority of people on this forum would LOVE to see Axl give Ron a chance to make his mark on the GnR legacy. For some weird reason, though, Axl and Beta/Fernando don't seem interested in going that route.
jmapelian Posted October 30, 2013 Posted October 30, 2013 I found the SA fans a little annoying... (sorry Manets) They are no better but at least they are not trying to insult Ron No one really trolled Bumblefoot.Replacement and cover band comments were all over the place.People talking about $la$h etc....Wasn't in the chat - bbf seems like a standup guy and seems to want to do the right things - but with that being said - when you're in a band for six years on the strength of other peoples work with nothing of your own, you kind of open yourself up to that sort of thing in that type of setting.
wasted Posted October 30, 2013 Posted October 30, 2013 Ron just wants to do it. I feels he owes the fans something. Whereas the others are more mercenary. Dj next up. They kind of both players. It would be great the whole band drunk in the chat.
Dariablue Posted October 30, 2013 Posted October 30, 2013 But for the record... He is a replacement, right? You guys haven't started arguing that he was always in the band, right? It's rare that I get involved in this shit, but ... Slash replaced Tracii - does that justify calling Slash a replacement? Duff replaced Ole - so should Duff be called a replacement? Sorum replaced Adler, who had replaced Rob - so are both Steve and Matt just replacements? The only one who is a true Replacement is Tommy. I'm getting sick and tired of this argument. Yes, it's technically correct. But Izzy, Steven, Duff and Slash are the guys they blew up with. The first lineup they properly released music with. The lineup that made them go from nothing to something. They, Axl, Slash, Izzy, Duff and Seven, built this band. Not Rob, not Tracii and not Ole. And you annoying people damn well know it. So stop trolling with this annoying bullshit. Everybody in the band right now other than Axl and Dizzy - replacements for the members who made Guns n' Roses.It's a non-argument typically used as a last result for Kool Aid drinkers. Sad really. 2
Recommended Posts