Piano Man VS Estranged

[Ace Nova]

[Georgy Zhukov]

Stop.

[Ace Nova]

Stop.

You know you love it.....

[luciusfunk]

Piano Man vs Piano Man

[ohlovelyrita]

Estranged but I like Piano Man. I surely didn't as a kid.

Maybe compare Piano Man to Rocket Man. I see the

latter in another comparison.

Compare Estranged to Behind Blue Eyes.

[Ace Nova]

I voted Piano Man....no other song will get a crowd of strangers singing together....in harmony.....and that's what music is about......

[Chewbacca]

Estranged.

[Jakey Styley]

Piano Man is just annoying.

[Broskirose]

Estranged. But it's a dumb comparison.

[Shooting Star]

Estranged, of course.

[dalsh327]

Billy said put him down for Estranged, he hates Piano Man.

[OmarBradley]

Estranged. Always thought Piano Man was a bit overrated, and a lot overplayed.

Edited December 13, 2013 by OmarBradley

[RussTCB]

I like about 3 Joel songs and Piano Man isn't one of them.

[pestilence]

estranged....

but estranged would have lost to this

[Estranged Reality]

i know it's 'cool' to hate on billy joel and chuck klosterman wrote a whole essay about it.

but fuck, i really do hate billy joel. few songs raise my ire more than 'piano man.'

[Iron MikeyJ]

Oh come on guys, Piano man is one of the best songs of the 20th Century. I love Estranged, but Piano Man is up there with anything Lennon/McCartney or Dylan ever wrote. Estranged is not in the same league.

Lyrically Piano Man OWNS Estranged, but musically I do like Estranged better.