Jump to content

Tommy Stinson OUT ? (new interview)


Recommended Posts

His bass playing on Chinese Democracy is a hidden gem.

Is it?

It honestly really isn't. There's nothing special about his bass playing. It's great for the Mats: boring, uninspired, bland, extremely non technical.

There is nothing hidden or gemlike about Tommys bass on ChiDem.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well there ya go, that is him directly saying he left. Sources now would be himself :)

kind of, still I feel he's being evasive.

"Cause we've all left, we've left on friendly terms it not like a bad thing."

That isn't good enough right? I swear sometimes we are creating our own issues here. Not everyone is going to release a signed letter like Ashba did. Tommy is out, there is no spin.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

His bass playing on Chinese Democracy is a hidden gem.

Is it?

It honestly really isn't. There's nothing special about his bass playing. It's great for the Mats: boring, uninspired, bland, extremely non technical.

There is nothing hidden or gemlike about Tommys bass on ChiDem.

He has a great sound, something which Guns needed after Duff left. Tommy was a great fit for the band during the Buckethead era, especially considering the early performances of the Chinese Democracy songs had more of a punk feel to it. It's all about what you're into and what sounds good to your ears, but much like the album itself, Tommy's bass is really under-appreciated on the album.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tommy's bass sound is like linoleum...you hear him for that second or two in The Blues/Street Of Dreams and that's it.

Duff's bass lines and sound in GNR were and are unmistakable in just about every song- Tommy could hold the bass player spot for 50 years and still not hold a candle to Duff in that role (not particularly trying to shit on Tommy, but it's true)

The most you can say about Stinson is that he did a long stretch, musically there is next to fuck all to show for it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

His bass playing on Chinese Democracy is a hidden gem.

Is it?

It honestly really isn't. There's nothing special about his bass playing. It's great for the Mats: boring, uninspired, bland, extremely non technical.

There is nothing hidden or gemlike about Tommys bass on ChiDem.

He has a great sound, something which Guns needed after Duff left. Tommy was a great fit for the band during the Buckethead era, especially considering the early performances of the Chinese Democracy songs had more of a punk feel to it. It's all about what you're into and what sounds good to your ears, but much like the album itself, Tommy's bass is really under-appreciated on the album.

rhiad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...