What do you like more? November Rain or Estranged?

[The Macaroni Incident?]

Lean "Estranged" overall, but Slash's NR solos make it a contest.

[DeadSlash]

Depends on my mood, usually Estranged though.

[Kittiara]

Estranged. I love November Rain as well, but Estranged just speaks to me on a deeper level.

[shjtjustgotreal]

i voted estranged just cuz i probly listened to nr 5 times as much as estranged, becomes pale over time

however tho, i can only enjoy nr when im super high/drunk

[wasted]

November Rain is more fun.

I like the outro restart part marching band and that final solo. It kind of rocks out.

Hardly listen to either. RNDTH, Dust n bones, Live and Let Die and out.

[Caught_in_a_Coma]

Estranged, no contest. It's a masterpiece.

Of course, but I feel November Rain is as well.

[IZZYISGNR]

November Rain is a better song.

Estranged has probably deeper lyrics, but musically I find it too long and kind of boring (too repetitive, kind of empty).

Edited September 6, 2015 by IZZYISGNR

[wasted]

Nov Rain is more fun, with marching band outro and solo being epic.

[Tom-Ass]

Tough call... Probably Estranged only because it isn't as played out.. Can't vote though

[GNRmello77]

For me it's estranged, and thats based on personal level as well as concidering it as my all time favorite song, I love everything about it and the music video really makes the effect stronger. Not that i would bring november Rain down cuz it's a masterpiece as well, but estranged has everything for me, i love it pure and when i saw gnr doing it live i cried.

[-W.A.R-]

Nov Rain is more fun, with marching band outro and solo being epic.

are you getting so wasted you forget what threads you already posted in?

[BangoSkank]

November Rain, I gotta say.

As good of a song as Estranged is I have never been able to like the hushed whisper Axl uses in the opening verses. The song doesn't really kick in for me until "When I find all of the reasons..."

Slash's first few solos are repetitive too, but after the bridge he starts really ripping it.

November Rain is pretty consistent, for me, the whole way through and I'll always love the last few minutes of it.

[Caught_in_a_Coma]

It's insanse how good the solos in November Rain are. Same goes for Estranged as well. And the lyrics to both songs. Axl and Slash made history

[TheDemocracyRose]

I cant choose. Both are unique.

[wasted]

Nov Rain is more fun, with marching band outro and solo being epic.

are you getting so wasted you forget what threads you already posted in?

say my name bitch you know who I am.

[stella]

Estranged by a long shot, for every reason -- music, lyrics, overall energy. Same with the videos - I much prefer Estranged to the sappy wedding in November Rain.

[Kater]

Tough call... Probably Estranged only because it isn't as played out.. Can't vote though

Agree, but I voted.

[Nosaj Thing]

November Rain for that masterful outro.

[GN'R Lies]

NR

[DR DOOM]

Both are great songs and right up there, but I voted for November Rain.

[Ana_1991]

ESTRANGED!

[LyndaRose]

Estranged

[Gibson87]

Estranged. I had to deal with a lot of shit a few years ago and it spoke to me.

[Tourettes2400]

Like someone else said Estranged but I love the solos of NR

[BetterDay7]

November Rain, I gotta say.

As good of a song as Estranged is I have never been able to like the hushed whisper Axl uses in the opening verses. The song doesn't really kick in for me until "When I find all of the reasons..."

Slash's first few solos are repetitive too, but after the bridge he starts really ripping it.

November Rain is pretty consistent, for me, the whole way through and I'll always love the last few minutes of it.

I voted Estranged but I have to agree about those opening whispers! A bit too tortured soul for me but I love it as it progresses. And, yes, the outro to NR is amazing.