shjtjustgotreal Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 (edited) lel http://ultimateclassicrock.com/guns-n-roses-songs-ranked/ Edited December 10, 2015 by shjtjustgotreal
Sprite Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 (edited) Bad Apples better than Prostitute? New Rose better than Yesterdays?Really? Edited December 10, 2015 by Sprite
RussTCB Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 I love CD and all but not on this planet or any other does IRS rank above Coma. 2
Sixes Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 Not a horrible list overall...a few oddities like so fine being where it is but really it's about a good a list as i've seen
shjtjustgotreal Posted December 10, 2015 Author Posted December 10, 2015 I love CD and all but not on this planet or any other does IRS rank above Coma.coma is so far down below man, it's just wrong...
EvH Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 Ultimateclassicrock:1- has like the stupidest name ever. I mean more stupid than Hookers And Blow.2- is boring and predictable.3- Loves to constantly make polls/articles/lists about the same bands.TL;DR it's a shitty website.
Lies They Tell Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 Interesting list for sure and I agree with a lot of it. Coma, Yesterdays and Prostitute are way too low though IMO. Kinda disagree with their opinion about the Spaghetti Incident too. Black Leather and Down On The Farm are my favorites from that album.
RussTCB Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 Ultimateclassicrock:1- has like the stupidest name ever. I mean more stupid than Hookers And Blow.2- is boring and predictable.3- Loves to constantly make polls/articles/lists about the same bands.TL;DR it's a shitty website.I like that you did a TL;DR for a 3 point post 1
Rodzilla72 Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 Not that I've picked up on any patterns in my years of lurking here, but this is one of those threads that usually pops up when people realize all the imminent huge news they've been waiting for may not materialize as "soon" as originally expected.
Silent Jay Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 (edited) 81 songs and too many covers. I would put If The World in top 40. One In A Million in top 10.Altough Down On The Farm was played in 2006. Edited December 10, 2015 by Silent Jay
Guest Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 Why is it that in every single "Best GN'R songs" list, "Welcome To The Jungle" is number one? I'm pissed that "My World" wasn't number 1...
Dean Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 I dunno why the casual listeners find This I Love and Sorry as two of the better tracks on Chinese Democracy. Street of Dreams should never have been below those two. 2
Lies They Tell Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 I dunno why the casual listeners find This I Love and Sorry as two of the better tracks on Chinese Democracy. Street of Dreams should never have been below those two.I guess one problem with Street Of Dreams is that it's too similar to November Rain and Estranged, but not nearly as good. It's kinda like a poor mans Estranged.Don't get me wrong I love SOD. But I guess TIL and Sorry are so different compared to other GNR stuff so that they stand out.
-W.A.R- Posted December 10, 2015 Posted December 10, 2015 that is a casual fan list if i ever saw one
Haters Gonna Hate Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 Why is Anything Goes in the top 20??
sanity_lost Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 It'd be impossible for me rank all their songs in a list like that. I would be constantly changing my mind and shuffling songs all over the place. Songs would dropping then rising 10-20 spots at time. The only song that would always rank somewhere in the top five is Mr. Brownstone. 1
Download Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 I dunno why the casual listeners find This I Love and Sorry as two of the better tracks on Chinese Democracy. Street of Dreams should never have been below those two.I guess one problem with Street Of Dreams is that it's too similar to November Rain and Estranged, but not nearly as good. It's kinda like a poor mans Estranged.Don't get me wrong I love SOD. But I guess TIL and Sorry are so different compared to other GNR stuff so that they stand out.I don't see the song as an November Rain or Estranged knock-off, just the absolute worst ballad Axl Rose ever wrote. Street of Dreams is garbage 1
Trin9498 Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 81 songs and too many covers. I would put If The World in top 40. One In A Million in top 10.Altough Down On The Farm was played in 2006.Agreed. No idea how One in a Million doesn't make top 10. 1
Apollo Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 You can't say somebody's opinion on song ratings is wrong. You can say you don't agree with it. Imagine saying that Pizza is your favorite food. Then steak. Then seafood. And then somebody says "you are wrong. I don't agree with your list."It just isn't logical. 81 songs and too many covers. I would put If The World in top 40. One In A Million in top 10.Altough Down On The Farm was played in 2006.Agreed. No idea how One in a Million doesn't make top 10.Because the guy making the list doesn't personally like it as much as you do?GnR has been my favorite band since 1987. One in a Million isn't in my top ten. When I was 20 I thought the lyrics were cool and edgy. Today - the lyrics kill the song. They are a bit embarrassing. 2
wasted Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 Sorry and This I Love are kind of like Don't Cry and Nov Rain. A power ballad and romantic piano and strings song. Simple lyrics with clear vocals. SOD is a bit wordy and overwrought? If the World is also simple and catchy. But not really as rock.
Apollo Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 I dunno why the casual listeners find This I Love and Sorry as two of the better tracks on Chinese Democracy. Street of Dreams should never have been below those two.I guess one problem with Street Of Dreams is that it's too similar to November Rain and Estranged, but not nearly as good. It's kinda like a poor mans Estranged.Don't get me wrong I love SOD. But I guess TIL and Sorry are so different compared to other GNR stuff so that they stand out. I don't see the song as an November Rain or Estranged knock-off, just the absolute worst ballad Axl Rose ever wrote. Street of Dreams is garbageLol. Yet,,,,,,,it's my favorite song off of CD. And to me it is the song that sounds the most like could have been on the Illusions. 1
Tom-Ass Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 ummm... One In a Million is the bottom 10????????
sanity_lost Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 (edited) You can't say somebody's opinion on song ratings is wrong.You can say you don't agree with it.Imagine saying that Pizza is your favorite food. Then steak. Then seafood. And then somebody says "you are wrong. I don't agree with your list."It just isn't logical.I complete agree with this. But it is fun to argue and debate if you have strong feelings over it. Edited December 11, 2015 by sanity_lost 1
Tom-Ass Posted December 11, 2015 Posted December 11, 2015 I feel like the voted on the top 10 or so and then just randomly picked the rest out of a hat...Makes you remember how many fucking good songs this band had though.
Recommended Posts