What songs has vocals after 1999

[GoForJMark]

10 hours ago, Pele said:

I'm referring to anyone expecting completed vocals for anything other than Atlas, Perhaps, OMG or The General.

back at it huh? 

My guess is you don't know jackshit.

My guess is know one here, myself included really knows shit.

None of you "insiders", "I'm not an insider, but here's what they'll do" and "trolls (I'm not saying pele, but it's pele" guessed that Absurd was coming until a setlist leaked, which most of you called BS. 

[jamillos]

2 hours ago, GoForJMark said:

back at it huh? 

My guess is you don't know jackshit.

My guess is know one here, myself included really knows shit.

None of you "insiders", "I'm not an insider, but here's what they'll do" and "trolls (I'm not saying pele, but it's pele" guessed that Absurd was coming until a setlist leaked, which most of you called BS. 

Exactly, had anyone predicted Silkworms, they'd have some credibility now; otherwise, it's just guesswork and claims, i.e. business as usual. 

[Pele]

14 hours ago, GoForJMark said:

back at it huh? 

My guess is you don't know jackshit.

My guess is know one here, myself included really knows shit.

None of you "insiders", "I'm not an insider, but here's what they'll do" and "trolls (I'm not saying pele, but it's pele" guessed that Absurd was coming until a setlist leaked, which most of you called BS. 

Don't 'insiders' usually claim they've heard unreleased songs?

I haven't.  Because I'm not.

[GoForJMark]

1 hour ago, Pele said:

Don't 'insiders' usually claim they've heard unreleased songs?

I haven't.  Because I'm not.

Read which category I put your name in

[Pele]

3 hours ago, GoForJMark said:

Read which category I put your name in

Questions.  

Do you think there will be a new album?  What do you think will be on it?  When do you think it might come out?

[GoForJMark]

1 hour ago, Pele said:

Questions.  

Do you think there will be a new album?  What do you think will be on it?  When do you think it might come out?

Had you asked me a year back I'd answer with an essay.

so...

I don't care. Who knows what the fuck will be on it. Probably never.

happy?

[Pele]

13 minutes ago, GoForJMark said:

Had you asked me a year back I'd answer with an essay.

so...

I don't care. Who knows what the fuck will be on it. Probably never.

happy?

Don't care really, never heard of you before today.

[GoForJMark]

21 minutes ago, Pele said:

Don't care really, never heard of you before today.

Ladies and Gents Mr Vocals 99 

 

EDIT: Guys I think I broke Pele 

Edited December 14, 2021 by GoForJMark

[GNFNRUK]

On 9/26/2021 at 9:01 PM, Lies They Tell said:

You might be right about that, but I wouldn't be the one who chickens out of it. If you think we should lower the bet or something, I'm fine with that.

I see what you're saying and we can refine the bet for sure. Blood in the Water was a weird remix of the song Prostitute. We can agree that new versions of previously released songs don't count and cover songs don't count either.

So how does this bet sound:

If GNR releases a song other than Atlas Shrugged, Perhaps, The General, Soulmonster/Monstrosity or Tonto that has full vocals by Axl recorded after 1999 and is not a cover or a new version of a previously released song, then you will to pay me 5000$. If no such song will be released within the next ten years, I'll pay you 5000$.

How does that bet sound like?

Why does your bet have a time frame of ten years?! 🤣

You’re obviously not THAT confident about Axl releasing any ‘new’ material any time soon yourself!

Edited December 14, 2021 by GNFNRUK

[Pele]

6 hours ago, GNFNRUK said:

Why does your bet have a time frame of ten years?! 🤣

You’re obviously not THAT confident about Axl releasing any ‘new’ material any time soon yourself!

I know!

Imagine thinking you're winning an argument against a guy who doesn't think Axl is writing/recording songs when your winning terms are 'he needs to release something in a DECADE from now'!

Bare in mind, he hasn't released anything for 12 years (not counting the EP as his work was already done).

I say he's done nothing since the release of Chinese Democracy, and this guy wants a 22 year window to prove me wrong!

Edited December 14, 2021 by Pele

[Lies They Tell]

8 hours ago, GNFNRUK said:

Why does your bet have a time frame of ten years?! 🤣

You’re obviously not THAT confident about Axl releasing any ‘new’ material any time soon yourself!

I'm confident that GNR will release new material in the next ten years. I never said that I'm confident that they will release new material soon.

This is not complicated. What I say is what I mean. There's nothing else to it. 🥱

[Lies They Tell]

2 hours ago, Pele said:

I know!

Imagine thinking you're winning an argument against a guy who doesn't think Axl is writing/recording songs when your winning terms are 'he needs to release something in a DECADE from now'!

Bare in mind, he hasn't released anything for 12 years (not counting the EP as his work was already done).

I say he's done nothing since the release of Chinese Democracy, and this guy wants a 22 year window to prove me wrong!

I wanted to see if you're confident enough in your arguments to make the bet. You agreed to the bet and I respect you for that. The next ten years will show who wins the bet and I don't know why you're acting so bitter about it.

[GNFNRUK]

5 hours ago, Lies They Tell said:

I'm confident that GNR will release new material in the next ten years. I never said that I'm confident that they will release new material soon.

This is not complicated. What I say is what I mean. There's nothing else to it. 🥱

Come on though man, that bet is rather ABSURD. Betting that GNR will put out new material by the year 2031?! Imagine if that was the actual year they put it out too lol. 23 years after ‘Chinese Democracy’ was released 🤦🏼‍♂️
 

I’m with Pele on this one, I don’t think Axl has recorded any new vocals for GNR material since the release of CD in 2008 (at the latest). I really would love to be proven wrong (not enough to make a ten year bet mind you) but I think if anything, we’ll likely see a couple more stand alone singles (Atlas & Perhaps) and this will be the farewell tour. Axl’s voice, sadly, is shot to shit. I can’t see him touring for much longer or getting in a vocal booth at this late stage in his career. All good things come to an end eventually though, nothing lasts forever.

Edited December 14, 2021 by GNFNRUK

[SoulMonster]

9 minutes ago, GNFNRUK said:

Come on though man, that bet is rather ABSURD. Betting that GNR will put out new material by the year 2031?! Imagine if that was the actual year they put it out too lol. 23 years after ‘Chinese Democracy’ was released 🤦🏼‍♂️’m with Pele on this one, I don’t think Axl has recorded any new vocals for GNR material since the release of CD in 2008 (at the latest). 

But that is not Pele's claim. Pele says that Axl hasn't recorded any vocals since 1999 that we haven't heard. All that he has recorded since then either ended up on CD or songs that happen to have been leaked (like the general). 

[GNFNRUK]

1 hour ago, SoulMonster said:

But that is not Pele's claim. Pele says that Axl hasn't recorded any vocals since 1999 that we haven't heard. All that he has recorded since then either ended up on CD or songs that happen to have been leaked (like the general). 

He could be right about that too, we don’t know anything for sure. I certainly don’t think it’s as ridiculous of a claim as some here are making out though. If he had lots of unheard vocal tracks from the 2000’s ready to go, vocals that HADN’T already leaked, one does have to wonder why on earth he’d choose to release ‘Silkworms’ (with the ‘99 vocal) as the ‘reunion comeback single’?! 
 

The fact that this was followed up with the previously leaked ‘Hard Skool’ (again with the ‘99 vocal) does make me question how much ‘unheard Axl’ is actually in the vault and how much is just instrumental. It appears that the other guys in the band were more productive in the studio than Axl was back then, which also seems to be the case now unfortunately.

 

 

[SoulMonster]

8 minutes ago, GNFNRUK said:

He could be right about that too, we don’t know anything for sure. I certainly don’t think it’s as ridiculous of a claim as some here are making out though. If he had lots of unheard vocal tracks from the 2000’s ready to go, vocals that HADN’T already leaked, one does have to wonder why on earth he’d choose to release ‘Silkworms’ (with the ‘99 vocal) as the ‘reunion comeback single’?! 
 

The fact that this was followed up with the previously leaked ‘Hard Skool’ (again with the ‘99 vocal) does make me question how much ‘unheard Axl’ is actually in the vault and how much is just instrumental. It appears that the other guys in the band were more productive in the studio than Axl was back then, which also seems to be the case now unfortunately.

I don't think anyone is arguing he can't be right. Personally, I find it unlikely,but it is theoretically possible. There are people here with crazier opinions than him. Most people's problem with him is not what he is saying, but how he says it and how often. 

[GoForJMark]

1 hour ago, SoulMonster said:

I don't think anyone is arguing he can't be right. Personally, I find it unlikely,but it is theoretically possible. There are people here with crazier opinions than him. Most people's problem with him is not what he is saying, but how he says it and how often. 

That's just Pele's burner account 

[Jw224]

Axl releasing silkworms is not really surprising when you look at how he said he wanted to release silkworms and how it was gonna be on the next album. He's been pretty consistent with that lol. 

[rumandraisin]

21 hours ago, Pele said:

I know!

Imagine thinking you're winning an argument against a guy who doesn't think Axl is writing/recording songs when your winning terms are 'he needs to release something in a DECADE from now'!

Bare in mind, he hasn't released anything for 12 years (not counting the EP as his work was already done).

I say he's done nothing since the release of Chinese Democracy, and this guy wants a 22 year window to prove me wrong!

Do you actually have a life Pele? Do you talk about 1999 to your friends and family?

[CubanSkies Dummy]

Aagghh, @Pele I see you coming, boy!

This is My personal take of what was going on during those "Chinese Democracy" years. Look at me, pal. You won't forget me again.

_______________________________________________

1998:

"The Robin Finck/Josh Freese/Tommy Stinson/Billy Howerdel/Dizzy Reed version of the album that existed in 1998 was pretty incredible. It still sounded like GNR but there were elements of Zeppelin, Nine Inch Nails and Pink Floyd mixed in." (James Barber, Poptones, 10/16/05)

Songs with vocals:

• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"

Finished songs in instrumental form:

• "Chinese Democracy"
• "T.W.A.T."
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Rhiad"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "The Blues"
• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac 13"
• "State Of Grace"
• "Oklahoma"
• "IRS"
• "Hard School"
• "Dummy"
• "Me & My Elvis"
• "Ides Of March"
• "D Tune"
• "Curly Shuffle"
• "Thyme"

_______________________________________________

1999:

A - Tier Songs with vocals:

• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"
• "T.W.A.T."
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Rhiad"
• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "The Blues"
• "Silkworms"
• "If The World"
• "State Of Grace"
• "IRS"
• "Hard School"
• "Oh My God"

B - Tier Songs with vocals:

• "Eye On You"
• "Quick Song"
• "Nothing"
• "This I Love"

A - Tier instrumentals:

• "P.R.L."
• "Moustache"
• "Zodiac 13"
• "Tonto"
• "I'm Sorry"
• "Oklahoma"
• "Dummy"
• "Me & My Elvis"
• "Circus Maximus" renamed after "Ides Of March"
• "D Tune"
• "Curly Shuffle"
• "Thyme"

B - Tier instrumentals:

• "Real Doll"
• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "Billionaire"
• "Dub Suplex"
• "Devious Bastard"
• "As It Began"

 

_______________________________________________

2000:

Finished songs:

• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"
• "T.W.A.T."
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins" renamed after "Rhiad"
• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "The Blues"
• "Silkworms"
• "If The World"
• "State Of Grace"
• "IRS"
• "Hard School"
• "Thyme"
• "Oh My God"

A - Tier instrumentals:

• "I'm Sorry"
• "Oklahoma"
• "Dummy"
• "Me & My Elvis"
• "Circus Maximus"
• "D Tune"
• "Curly Shuffle"

B - Tier instrumentals:

• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac 13"
• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "Dub Suplex"

Most likely abandoned songs:

• "PRL"
• "Eye On You"
• "Moustache"
• "Tonto"
• "Real Doll"
• "Devious Bastard"
• "Nothing"
• "As It Began"
• "This I Love"

 

_______________________________________________

2001:

Finished songs:

• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "The Blues"
• "Silkworms"
• "If The World"
• "State Of Grace"
• "IRS"
• "Hard School"
• "Thyme"
• "Oh My God"
• "Oklahoma" [Vocals added]
• "Going Down"

A - Tier instrumentals:

• "Sorry For You" renamed after "I'm Sorry"
• "100 Cuban Skies" renamed after "Dummy"
• "Leave Me Alone" renamed after "Me & My Elvis"
• "Circus Maximus"
• "D Tune"
• "Curly Shuffle"
• "Three Dollar Pyramid"
• "Prom Violence"

B - Tier instrumentals:

• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac 13"
• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "Dub Suplex"

Most likely abandoned songs:

• "Inside Out"
• Tommy Home Demo

 

_______________________________________________

2002 - MAJOR "RESET" OF THE ALBUM:

Finished songs ready to master:

• "Chinese Democracy" [Soft remake; plus BH solo]
• "Better" renamed after "Three Dollar Pyramid" [Vocals added]
• "The Blues" [Soft remake; orchestra]
• "If The World"
• "There Was a Time" renamed after "T.W.A.T." [Soft remake; plus BH solo; orchestra]
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "IRS"
• "Madagascar" [orchestra]
• "Prostitute" [orchestra]
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Silkworms" [Remake]
• "State Of Grace"
• "Oklahoma"
• "Hard School"
• "100 Cuban Skies" [Vocals added]
• "Thyme" [Orchestra]
• "Oh My God"
• "Going Down" [Remake]

Demos began to circulate.

A - Tier instrumentals:

• "Leave Me Alone" [Orchestra]
• "The General" [Orchestra]
• "Seven" [Orchestra; possible mix between "Circus Maximus" / "D Tune" / "Curly Shuffle"]

B - Tier instrumentals:

• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac" renamed after "Zodiac 13"
• "Shackler's Revenge" [Remake; possible mix between "Shackler's Revenge" / "Dub Suplex" / "Prom Violence"]

_______________________________________________

Late 2004 - Early 2005:

Finished songs:

• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Better"
• "The Blues"
• "If The World"
• "There Was a Time"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "Sorry For You" [Vocals added]
• "IRS"
• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"
• "Thyme"
• "Elvis Presley & The Monster Of Soul" renamed after "Leave Me Alone" [Vocals added]
• "The General" [Vocals added]
• "Seven" [Vocals added]

B - Tier finished songs:

• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Silkworms"
• "Berlin" renamed after "Oklahoma"
• "Oh My God"
• "Going Down"
• "Jackie Chan" renamed after "Hard School"
• "Cuban Skies" renamed after "100 Cuban Skies"

A - Tier instrumental songs:

• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "This I Love" [Previously abandoned]
• "Lies They Tell"

Most likely abandoned songs:

• "Perhaps"
• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac"
• "State Of Grace"

_______________________________________________

2005 / EARLY 2006- "ANTIQUIET" / FINISHED UNRELEASED ALBUM:

Finished mastered album:

• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Shackler's Revenge" [Vocals added; 2007 incident nothing to do with this song, only a reminder by Rose]
• "Better"
• "The Blues"
• "If The World"
• "There Was a Time"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "Lies They Tell" [Vocals added]
• "Sorry For You"
• "IRS"
• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"

Mastered and finished songs not to be included:

• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "This I Love" [Vocals added]
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Berlin"
• "Seven"
• "The General"
• "Elvis Presley & The Monster Of Soul"
• "Thyme"
• "Oh My God"
• "Silkworms"
• "Cuban Skies"
• "Jackie Chan"
• "Going Down"

Instrumentals leftovers:

• "Light My Fire" [previously abandoned; renamed after "Moustache"]
• "Tonto" [previously abandoned]
• "Monstrosity"

 

_______________________________________________

2007 - FINISHED:

Finished album - Release in 2008:

• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "Better"
• "Street Of Dreams" renamed after "Stardust" renamed after "The Blues"
• "If The World"
• "There Was a Time"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "Scraped" renamed after "Lies They Tell"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "Sorry" renamed after "Sorry For You"
• "IRS"
• "Madagascar"
• "This I Love"
• "Prostitute"

Finished songs - released in 2021:

• "Absurd!" renamed after "Silkworms"
• "HardSkool" renamed after "Jackie Chan"

Finished unreleased songs:

• "Oh My God"
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Berlin"
• "7" renamed after "Seven"
• "The General"
• "Soul Monster" renamed after "Monster Of Soul" renamed after "Elvis Preslery & The Monster Of Soul"
• "Thyme"
• "Cuban Skies"
• "Going Down"
• "Tonto" [Vocals added]
• "Light My Fire" [Vocals added]
• "Monstrosity" [Vocals added]

___________________

 

So, @Pele what do you think?

 

[kingcanyon]

1 hour ago, CubanSkies Dummy said:

Aagghh, @Pele I see you coming, boy!

This is My personal take of what was going on during those "Chinese Democracy" years. Look at me, pal. You won't forget me again.

_______________________________________________

1998:

"The Robin Finck/Josh Freese/Tommy Stinson/Billy Howerdel/Dizzy Reed version of the album that existed in 1998 was pretty incredible. It still sounded like GNR but there were elements of Zeppelin, Nine Inch Nails and Pink Floyd mixed in." (James Barber, Poptones, 10/16/05)

Songs with vocals:

• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"

Finished songs in instrumental form:

• "Chinese Democracy"
• "T.W.A.T."
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Rhiad"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "The Blues"
• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac 13"
• "State Of Grace"
• "Oklahoma"
• "IRS"
• "Hard School"
• "Dummy"
• "Me & My Elvis"
• "Ides Of March"
• "D Tune"
• "Curly Shuffle"
• "Thyme"

_______________________________________________

1999:

A - Tier Songs with vocals:

• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"
• "T.W.A.T."
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Rhiad"
• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "The Blues"
• "Silkworms"
• "If The World"
• "State Of Grace"
• "IRS"
• "Hard School"
• "Oh My God"

B - Tier Songs with vocals:

• "Eye On You"
• "Quick Song"
• "Nothing"
• "This I Love"

A - Tier instrumentals:

• "P.R.L."
• "Moustache"
• "Zodiac 13"
• "Tonto"
• "I'm Sorry"
• "Oklahoma"
• "Dummy"
• "Me & My Elvis"
• "Circus Maximus" renamed after "Ides Of March"
• "D Tune"
• "Curly Shuffle"
• "Thyme"

B - Tier instrumentals:

• "Real Doll"
• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "Billionaire"
• "Dub Suplex"
• "Devious Bastard"
• "As It Began"

 

_______________________________________________

2000:

Finished songs:

• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"
• "T.W.A.T."
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins" renamed after "Rhiad"
• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "The Blues"
• "Silkworms"
• "If The World"
• "State Of Grace"
• "IRS"
• "Hard School"
• "Thyme"
• "Oh My God"

A - Tier instrumentals:

• "I'm Sorry"
• "Oklahoma"
• "Dummy"
• "Me & My Elvis"
• "Circus Maximus"
• "D Tune"
• "Curly Shuffle"

B - Tier instrumentals:

• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac 13"
• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "Dub Suplex"

Most likely abandoned songs:

• "PRL"
• "Eye On You"
• "Moustache"
• "Tonto"
• "Real Doll"
• "Devious Bastard"
• "Nothing"
• "As It Began"
• "This I Love"

 

_______________________________________________

2001:

Finished songs:

• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "The Blues"
• "Silkworms"
• "If The World"
• "State Of Grace"
• "IRS"
• "Hard School"
• "Thyme"
• "Oh My God"
• "Oklahoma" [Vocals added]
• "Going Down"

A - Tier instrumentals:

• "Sorry For You" renamed after "I'm Sorry"
• "100 Cuban Skies" renamed after "Dummy"
• "Leave Me Alone" renamed after "Me & My Elvis"
• "Circus Maximus"
• "D Tune"
• "Curly Shuffle"
• "Three Dollar Pyramid"
• "Prom Violence"

B - Tier instrumentals:

• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac 13"
• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "Dub Suplex"

Most likely abandoned songs:

• "Inside Out"
• Tommy Home Demo

 

_______________________________________________

2002 - MAJOR "RESET" OF THE ALBUM:

Finished songs ready to master:

• "Chinese Democracy" [Soft remake; plus BH solo]
• "Better" renamed after "Three Dollar Pyramid" [Vocals added]
• "The Blues" [Soft remake; orchestra]
• "If The World"
• "There Was a Time" renamed after "T.W.A.T." [Soft remake; plus BH solo; orchestra]
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "IRS"
• "Madagascar" [orchestra]
• "Prostitute" [orchestra]
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Perhaps"
• "Silkworms" [Remake]
• "State Of Grace"
• "Oklahoma"
• "Hard School"
• "100 Cuban Skies" [Vocals added]
• "Thyme" [Orchestra]
• "Oh My God"
• "Going Down" [Remake]

Demos began to circulate.

A - Tier instrumentals:

• "Leave Me Alone" [Orchestra]
• "The General" [Orchestra]
• "Seven" [Orchestra; possible mix between "Circus Maximus" / "D Tune" / "Curly Shuffle"]

B - Tier instrumentals:

• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac" renamed after "Zodiac 13"
• "Shackler's Revenge" [Remake; possible mix between "Shackler's Revenge" / "Dub Suplex" / "Prom Violence"]

_______________________________________________

Late 2004 - Early 2005:

Finished songs:

• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Better"
• "The Blues"
• "If The World"
• "There Was a Time"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "Sorry For You" [Vocals added]
• "IRS"
• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"
• "Thyme"
• "Elvis Presley & The Monster Of Soul" renamed after "Leave Me Alone" [Vocals added]
• "The General" [Vocals added]
• "Seven" [Vocals added]

B - Tier finished songs:

• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Silkworms"
• "Berlin" renamed after "Oklahoma"
• "Oh My God"
• "Going Down"
• "Jackie Chan" renamed after "Hard School"
• "Cuban Skies" renamed after "100 Cuban Skies"

A - Tier instrumental songs:

• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "This I Love" [Previously abandoned]
• "Lies They Tell"

Most likely abandoned songs:

• "Perhaps"
• "Quick Song"
• "Zodiac"
• "State Of Grace"

_______________________________________________

2005 / EARLY 2006- "ANTIQUIET" / FINISHED UNRELEASED ALBUM:

Finished mastered album:

• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Shackler's Revenge" [Vocals added; 2007 incident nothing to do with this song, only a reminder by Rose]
• "Better"
• "The Blues"
• "If The World"
• "There Was a Time"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "Lies They Tell" [Vocals added]
• "Sorry For You"
• "IRS"
• "Madagascar"
• "Prostitute"

Mastered and finished songs not to be included:

• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "This I Love" [Vocals added]
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Berlin"
• "Seven"
• "The General"
• "Elvis Presley & The Monster Of Soul"
• "Thyme"
• "Oh My God"
• "Silkworms"
• "Cuban Skies"
• "Jackie Chan"
• "Going Down"

Instrumentals leftovers:

• "Light My Fire" [previously abandoned; renamed after "Moustache"]
• "Tonto" [previously abandoned]
• "Monstrosity"

 

_______________________________________________

2007 - FINISHED:

Finished album - Release in 2008:

• "Chinese Democracy"
• "Shackler's Revenge"
• "Better"
• "Street Of Dreams" renamed after "Stardust" renamed after "The Blues"
• "If The World"
• "There Was a Time"
• "Catcher In The Rye"
• "Scraped" renamed after "Lies They Tell"
• "Riad N' The Bedouins"
• "Sorry" renamed after "Sorry For You"
• "IRS"
• "Madagascar"
• "This I Love"
• "Prostitute"

Finished songs - released in 2021:

• "Absurd!" renamed after "Silkworms"
• "HardSkool" renamed after "Jackie Chan"

Finished unreleased songs:

• "Oh My God"
• "Atlas Shrugged"
• "Berlin"
• "7" renamed after "Seven"
• "The General"
• "Soul Monster" renamed after "Monster Of Soul" renamed after "Elvis Preslery & The Monster Of Soul"
• "Thyme"
• "Cuban Skies"
• "Going Down"
• "Tonto" [Vocals added]
• "Light My Fire" [Vocals added]
• "Monstrosity" [Vocals added]

___________________

 

So, @Pele what do you think?

 

where are the songs from the album in 2023/24 you said

[SoulMonster]

@CubanSkies DummyWhy should we believe you? Anyone with too much time on their hands could make up lists like that. 

[StrangerInThisTown]

55 minutes ago, kingcanyon said:

where are the songs from the album in 2023/24 you said

Guy who makes up lists, contradicted by his other own made up list

[CubanSkies Dummy]

On 12/18/2021 at 6:25 PM, StrangerInThisTown said:

Guy who makes up lists, contradicted by his other own made up list

No, pal. I only listed the songs from 1998 - 2008. 

The songs (I believe) that were working after 2008 (and after 2009? 2010?):

• "Roll On 2 You"
• "Feelin' It"
• "CNZ" (Casino Night Zone)
• "Elvis" (Soul Monster)
• "OMG" (Oh My God)
• "Atlas" (Atlas Shrugged)
• "7" (Seven)
• "Absurd!" (Silkworms)
• "El Hermano"
• "Perhaps"
• "General" (The General)
• "Here Today"
• "Riders Out Of Sight"
• "Hard Skool" (Jackie Chan)

Songs discarded after 2009? 2010?:

• "Thyme"
• "Berlin"
• "Cuban Skies"
• "Light My Fire"
• "Ode To Dodoria"
• "Blue Volcano"
• "Tonto"
• "Dragon"
• "Monstrosity"
• "War Schemes"
• "Going Down"
• "Quick Song" (probably abandoned before 2006)
• "Zodiac" (probably abandoned before 2006)
• "State Of Grace" (probably abandoned before 2006)

 

Edited December 20, 2021 by CubanSkies Dummy

[Pele]

On 12/14/2021 at 7:28 PM, SoulMonster said:

But that is not Pele's claim. Pele says that Axl hasn't recorded any vocals since 1999 that we haven't heard. All that he has recorded since then either ended up on CD or songs that happen to have been leaked (like the general). 

I've repeatedly said that not my claim.

I've said over and over that he worked on vocals 05-07, and likely recorded Better, General, Shacklers, Scraped etc.

I couldn't have made it any clearer tbh