AFD Survivor Round 4

[kozydogg]

Fun topic, but AFD is a bit predictable.  When this is over how about a survivor round for ChiDem?  Feel like that album would offer less "unanimous" opinions.

[Tom2112]

17 minutes ago, kozydogg said:

Fun topic, but AFD is a bit predictable.  When this is over how about a survivor round for ChiDem?  Feel like that album would offer less "unanimous" opinions.

I wouldn't have predicted how many people prefer TAY to My Michelle etc. I think AFD is interesting so far and it gets everybody interested whereas Chinese is a bit more niche, even on this forum. Chinese will be hilarious though I'm sure some people would all 14 off in one go if they could🤣

[CAFC Nick]

OTGM.

Will not be voting in any more after this as it’s too tough 

[themadcaplaughs]

I am even surprised myself that I voted for "Nightrain", but I would actually rank it beneath "My Michelle" and "Out ta Get Me". 

[History2010]

2 hours ago, kozydogg said:

Fun topic, but AFD is a bit predictable.  When this is over how about a survivor round for ChiDem?  Feel like that album would offer less "unanimous" opinions.

I can do a poll asking people what album they want to see done next once AFD is finished.

[History2010]

The results are so tight right now! My Michelle is just barely ahead. Hopefully the gap widens a bit before the night is over. 

[smokingarthur]

Ironically I love My Michelle and Think About You. Fuck, every song is killer on Appetite. SCOM I don’t listen to cause it just sounds “too commercial” for my tastes and doesn’t have the same 1980’s Hollywood booze-parlor sound. But I can’t say it’s not a great song for what it is. I just think I’ve heard it enough to want to hear it again. 

[Gordon Comstock]

4 hours ago, Stay.Of.Execution said:

He said he didn't like the intro back then but has come to like it over the years

 

Not really. A year or two before the reunion he said "we were a hard rock band, and that song was an uptempo ballad - one of the gayest things you can write."

[Ratam]

Also Slash not loved much Nnovember Rain, apparently Slash not like ballads.

[alfierose]

1 hour ago, History2010 said:

The results are so tight right now! My Michelle is just barely ahead. Hopefully the gap widens a bit before the night is over. 

Fucks sake. It's in 2nd place now. Am I really going to have to vote for it a 4th time?  

[jamillos]

4 hours ago, kozydogg said:

Fun topic, but AFD is a bit predictable.  When this is over how about a survivor round for ChiDem?  Feel like that album would offer less "unanimous" opinions.

 

1 hour ago, History2010 said:

I can do a poll asking people what album they want to see done next once AFD is finished.

ALL albums, chronologically. I thought that was a given.

[jamillos]

2 hours ago, jamillos said:

 

ALL albums, chronologically. I thought that was a given.

But one by one, not all at the same time. I especially wonder how has perception of CD changed over the years, now with the leaks and singles and whatnot...