Use Your Illusion I Survivor - Round 14

[History2010]

We've been around this track a couple o' times, but now the dust is startin' to clear!

Dead Horse....is gone!

Which song will be next to go?

Round 1 - Bad Apples
Round 2 - You Ain't The First
Round 3 - Back Off Bitch
Round 4 - Bad Obsession
Round 5 - Live And Let Die
Round 6 - Garden Of Eden
Round 7 - The Garden
Round 8 - Dust N' Bones
Round 9 - Perfect Crime
Round 10 - Right Next Door To Hell
Round 11 - Double Talkin' Jive
Round 12 - Don't Damn Me
Round 13 - Dead Horse
Round 14 - ???
Round 15 - ???
Round 16 - ???

HOW IT WORKS: Each round, you vote for your LEAST FAVORITE of the options. The option with the most votes gets eliminated in the next round, and so on, until only one song remains.

[slash23579]

It kind of hurt voting for Don’t Cry honestly, but this is the round it needs to go

[SoulMonster]

November Rain. I would have wanted it out much earlier but I've been stuck in voting for Dead Horse limbo.

[SoundOfAGun]

Nothing lasts forever (although it may make one more round), November Rain for me!

[alfierose]

So bored of voting November Rain now. It's probably going to win.  

[Free Bird]

Ok, first of all I wanna say there are a lot of great songs voted out already but at the end I think I'm ok with these as top 3, although my personal choice would be different. 

As long as Dead Horse was alive it was an easy choice, now it's really difficult. If I'm honest to myself I have to vote for ... I think I have to vote for Coma because, as brilliant as the last few minutes are (from the 7:40min mark), I have to be in the right mood for wanna listening to this monster of a song. And I really dislike what Axl added to it... the paramedics, the defibrillator and all this shit. 

 

[BrayWyatt]

While Coma is a good song, the other 2 are classics.

 

[jamillos]

Surprisingly balanced so far in this round. Gotta go with DC. Not happy about it. 

[janrichmond]

Nov Rain, obvs

[Euchre]

One song I've never managed to listen to the whole way through.

Another I haven't listened to in 25 years and never want to hear again

And one that if I were going to listen to again, I'd listen to the demo well before the album version.....

[Stay.Of.Execution]

1 hour ago, Euchre said:

One song I've never managed to listen to the whole way through.

Another I haven't listened to in 25 years and never want to hear again

And one that if I were going to listen to again, I'd listen to the demo well before the album version.....

GNR has some weird fans.

[We love Axl Rose]

'Cause nothin' lasts forever, even cold November rain.

[SoundOfAGun]

3 hours ago, Euchre said:

One song I've never managed to listen to the whole way through.

Another I haven't listened to in 25 years and never want to hear again

And one that if I were going to listen to again, I'd listen to the demo well before the album version.....

You post on a fan forum but haven't listened to a song on UYI I all the way through?

[downzy]

Don’t Cry, it’s time.

Great song, but for me the UYI albums are all about epicness. And both songs are far more epic.  The chord progression of November Rain’s outro tops anything else in the album. 

[martinb33]

I have to go for the Stradlin/Rose duo this time. Plus I prefer the alt version.

[Zeppelin]

As a fan of longer songs, I have to give the boot to Don't Cry here. NR is a classic and Coma is a chaotic beast. They both deserve to stay and go head-to-head.

[Tom2112]

So conflicted... nah! Coma AGAIN!!! 🤣

[Ratam]

Coma.

[Ratam]

Now. Coma vs NR, neck and neck

 

 

 

 

[StrangerInThisTown]

Nothing lasts forever, except for me voting November Rain apparently

[lilacmess]

November Rain. 

[drbunnig]

It's a travesty that Coma has made it this far.

[Rovim]

Don't Cry. I like the song, but for me, it doesn't compare in quality to NR and Coma.

[Sweersa]

21 minutes ago, drbunnig said:

It's a travesty that Coma has made it this far.

For years I paid no attention to that song. Then, after hearing it live in 2016, I loved it. It was like a late blooming song for me, at least for my interests. November Rain is the clear popular favorite on this album, but Coma is also special, most casuals never heard of it, or even heard it. 

I love both songs, but NR was one of my first loves with GN'R, and overall I like it a tad more than Coma. 

[Lio]

Went for Don't Cry. Difficult choice, because it was my favourite for a long time. I always found november rain overrated, but since a few years I've started appreciating the Outro much more. It moved me to tears on one show I went to and that's the only time I've had that.

I always credited Slash for that, but after hearing the piano version on afd, Axl has to be credited for it as well. Just an amazing piece of music.