Jump to content

GNR Survivor: Drummers- results


Recommended Posts

the results are in and Steven Adler is the best drummer according to this fourm

Round 1 Frank Ferrer

Round 2 Rob Gardner

Round 3 Don Henley

Round 4 Fred Coury

Round 5 Josh Freese

Round 6 Brain

Round 7 Matt Sorum

Round 8 Steven Adler

 

thanks to everyone who voted

what next?

Rareites

Undderatted songs

Unrealsed songs

Guitars

or something else?

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • GNFNR 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Steven deserved to win, but Brain and Frank were both voted out too early.

 

If you do Rarities it could be split into 2 survivors: live and studio.

Crash Diet
Just Another Sunday
Bring It Back Home
Too Much Too Soon
Sentimental Movie
Sweet Child O' Mine 1999
Under My Wheels w/ Alice Cooper
Anxious Disease

and maybe there's some stuff I'm forgetting? Maybe demos like 14 Years with the long outro or Don't Damn Me with the alt vocal take could be included?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, Gordon Comstock said:

Steven deserved to win, but Brain and Frank were both voted out too early.

 

If you do Rarities it could be split into 2 survivors: live and studio.

Crash Diet
Just Another Sunday
Bring It Back Home
Too Much Too Soon
Sentimental Movie
Sweet Child O' Mine 1999
Under My Wheels w/ Alice Cooper
Anxious Disease

and maybe there's some stuff I'm forgetting? Maybe demos like 14 Years with the long outro or Don't Damn Me with the alt vocal take could be included?

1 minute ago, ssiscool said:

How about covers? Every cover gnr has done. Granted be a long list.. ..

I've thought about a "live only covers" survivor, meaning covers that there's no proper studio version of (so it excludes KOHD, LALD, Mama Kin, Nice Boys and TSI), like this:

Heartbreak Hotel [Elvis Presley cover] (1985-1986) *

Jumping Jack Flash [The Rolling Stones cover] (1985-1986) *

Whole Lotta Rosie [AC/DC cover] (1987-2018)

Dead Flowers [The Rolling Stones cover] (1993)

It’s Alright [Black Sabbath cover] (1993)

Dust In The Wind [Todd Rundgren cover] (1993)

Sailing [The Sutherland Brothers/Rod Stewart cover] (2006)

Sway [The Rolling Stones cover] (2006 – performed with Izzy)

You Gotta Move [Mississippi Fred McDowell/The Rolling Stones cover] (2006 – performed with Izzy)

Back In The USSR/”Back In The Fuckin’ UK” [The Beatles cover] (2006 – performed with Izzy)

Liquor and Whores [Trailer Park Boys cover] (2006-2011)

My Generation [The Who cover] (2009-2011 – Tommy Stinson’s solo spot)

Sonic Reducer [The Dead Boys cover] (2009-2011 – Tommy Stinson’s solo spot)

Riff Raff [AC/DC cover] (2011-2017)

Don't Let It Bring You Down [Neil Young cover] (2012)

The Seeker [The Who cover] (2012-2021)

Marseilles [The Angels cover] (2014)

Holidays In The Sun [The Sex Pistols cover] (2014 – Tommy Stinson’s solo spot)

Black Hole Sun [Soundgarden cover] (2017-)

I Got You (I Feel Good) [James Brown cover] (2017)

Wichita Lineman [Glen Campbell cover] (2017-)

I Wanna Be Your Dog [The Stooges cover] (2021 – Duff’s solo spot)

Walk All Over You [AC/DC cover] (2022)

Back In Black [AC/DC cover] (2022)

* I think these could be included here, too, since the studio versions are demos and not proper recordings.

On the other hand, I don't think Slither should be included, because, although technically a cover, it's "too close to home", essentially a song by a GnR offshoot.

Or, maybe, it could be live-only songs, so it would also include 2-3 original songs: Goodnight Tonight (1986), It Tastes Good.... (1988) and Cornshucker (1988).

  • Like 1
  • GNFNR 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

53 minutes ago, Blackstar said:

I've thought about a "live only covers" survivor, meaning covers that there's no proper studio version of (so it excludes KOHD, LALD, Mama Kin, Nice Boys and TSI), like this:

Heartbreak Hotel [Elvis Presley cover] (1985-1986) *

Jumping Jack Flash [The Rolling Stones cover] (1985-1986) *

Whole Lotta Rosie [AC/DC cover] (1987-2018)

Dead Flowers [The Rolling Stones cover] (1993)

It’s Alright [Black Sabbath cover] (1993)

Dust In The Wind [Todd Rundgren cover] (1993)

Sailing [The Sutherland Brothers/Rod Stewart cover] (2006)

Sway [The Rolling Stones cover] (2006 – performed with Izzy)

You Gotta Move [Mississippi Fred McDowell/The Rolling Stones cover] (2006 – performed with Izzy)

Back In The USSR/”Back In The Fuckin’ UK” [The Beatles cover] (2006 – performed with Izzy)

Liquor and Whores [Trailer Park Boys cover] (2006-2011)

My Generation [The Who cover] (2009-2011 – Tommy Stinson’s solo spot)

Sonic Reducer [The Dead Boys cover] (2009-2011 – Tommy Stinson’s solo spot)

Riff Raff [AC/DC cover] (2011-2017)

Don't Let It Bring You Down [Neil Young cover] (2012)

The Seeker [The Who cover] (2012-2021)

Marseilles [The Angels cover] (2014)

Holidays In The Sun [The Sex Pistols cover] (2014 – Tommy Stinson’s solo spot)

Black Hole Sun [Soundgarden cover] (2017-)

I Got You (I Feel Good) [James Brown cover] (2017)

Wichita Lineman [Glen Campbell cover] (2017-)

I Wanna Be Your Dog [The Stooges cover] (2021 – Duff’s solo spot)

Walk All Over You [AC/DC cover] (2022)

Back In Black [AC/DC cover] (2022)

* I think these could be included here, too, since the studio versions are demos and not proper recordings.

On the other hand, I don't think Slither should be included, because, although technically a cover, it's "too close to home", essentially a song by a GnR offshoot.

Or, maybe, it could be live-only songs, so it would also include 2-3 original songs: Goodnight Tonight (1986), It Tastes Good.... (1988) and Cornshucker (1988).

 

Sailing was also with Izzy, and they did Marseilles in 88/89 too.

They also did We Will Rock You and Tie Your Mother Down with Brian May in '92, Train Kept A Rollin in '92, Axl did Everything as a NR intro in '93... I'm sure there's more we're forgetting.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...