Jump to content

GN'R Survivor: Music Videos - RESULTS


Blackstar

Recommended Posts

And the winner is... November Rain!

Thanks everyone for participating!

I have included screenshots of the results in each round (in spoilers) for those who can't see them in the respective threads:

Round 1 - Bad Apples (1991/1993). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su10.jpg

Round 2 - Better (2008) [UNRELEASED]. See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su11.jpg

Round 3 - I Don't Care About You (1994) [UNRELEASED]. See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su12.jpg

Round 4 - My Michelle (1991) [UNRELEASED]. See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su16.jpg

Round 5 - Mr. Brownstone (1991) [UNRELEASED]. See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su17.jpg

Round 6 - It's So Easy - Live Era version (1999). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su18.jpg

Round 7 - Welcome To The Jungle - Live Era version (1999). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su19.jpg

Round 8 - Since I Don't Have You (1994). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su20.jpg

Round 9 - It's So Easy [alternate/original edit] (1989) [UNRELEASED]. See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su21.jpg

Round 10 - Garden Of Eden (1992). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su22.jpg

Round 11 - The Garden (1993). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su23.jpg

Round 12 - Sweet Child O' Mine [black & white version] (1988). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su24.jpg

Round 13 - Dead Horse (1993). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su25.jpg

Round 14 - It's So Easy (1989) [released 2018 w/ the L&L box set]. See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su26.jpg

Round 15 - Live And Let Die (1991). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su27.jpg

Round 16 - Yesterdays (1992). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su28.jpg

Round 17 - Patience (1989). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su29.jpg

Round 18 - Sweet Child O' Mine [alternate/classic version] (1988). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su30.jpg

Round 19 - Welcome To The Jungle (1987). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su31.jpg

Round 20 - You Could Be Mine (1991). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su32.jpg

Round 21 - Paradise City (1988). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su33.jpg

Round 22 - Estranged (1993). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su34.jpg

Round 23 (Final) - Don't Cry (1991). See votes: 

Spoiler

gnr_su35.jpg

*

Note: When a round ended in a tie,  the votes in the other rounds were taken into account and the song with the bigger sum of votes was the one that got eliminated (it happened three times, in rounds 8, 10 and 14).

* I didn't include the three versions of Garden Of Eden separately, because the differences are insignificant and it's basically the same video.

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, BangoSkank said:

Thanks so much for doing these, @Blackstar. Very fun coming into these threads, debating the music among fans, etc. 

Also, "The Garden" was robbed.

I agree. Much healthier than talking about Team Brazil or arguing with those who believe GNR shows in 2022 is better than ever before.

And yes, The Garden deserved better.

Edited by ©GnrPersia
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

best Line Up?
best Axl look?
best live opener which happend? (Reckless Life, Welcome To The Jungle, It's So Easy, Nightrain, Pretty Tied Up, Perfect Crime, Right Next Door To Hell, You Could Be Mine, Coma, Chinese Democracy...) 
best concert?
worst concert? (Bridge School 12, Berlin 18, Rock In Rio 11..... )
best video bootleg? (Saskatoon 93, Ritz 88... )
best stage?
best official You're Crazy release (Sound City Demo, Acoustic Sound City demo, GN'R lies cut, Appetite For Destruction, GN'R lies, Live Era or Hard Skool EP)

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/5/2022 at 5:03 PM, Blackstar said:

I won't do another survivor poll (at least for a while), but if anyone else wants to start one, AXL/DC is an idea.

I imagine it's a lot of commitment doing one of those. Fair play to you and thankyou for doing them

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

A bit too late, but I just realized that there was a video for the Days of Thunder version of KOHD with scenes from the movie and from the SCOM video. I don't think it was an official release by the band, but it was apparently shown on MTV (it can be found on youtube). Does anyone remember seeing it on MTV back then?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Blackstar said:

A bit too late, but I just realized that there was a video for the Days of Thunder version of KOHD with scenes from the movie and from the SCOM video. I don't think it was an official release by the band, but it was apparently shown on MTV (it can be found on youtube). Does anyone remember seeing it on MTV back then?

No but I remember vividly they often played Civil War from Tokyo on MTV, as if it was a normal official video. Plus KOHD, but don't remember which version and it wasn't as frequent. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...