Young vs Dylan vs Springsteen

[Nightrain_Kid]

Young and Springsteen are both better musicians's but Dylan lyrically cant be touched imo, from the simple heartbreaking honesty of You're a big girl now to the era defining Like a rolling stone to every protest, witty, angry, epic story and lovesong inbetween he's the master who changed music and influenced everyone who you would argue could challenge him as being the greatest. He's constantly changed his sound and the fact his last 3 album's are considered to be amongst his best work say's everything about his amazing consistency

[Estranged Reality]

I think Dylan vs. Young vs. Waits would be a more just comparison.

Springsteen isn't really anything like them in my opinion.

[Midnight Rambler]

I voted for Young, hes my favourite, followed by dylan. I dont have any springtein albums, i like his sngles though.

[Guest Ohdistortedsmile1789]

Young and Springsteen are both better musicians's but Dylan lyrically cant be touched imo, from the simple heartbreaking honesty of You're a big girl now to the era defining Like a rolling stone to every protest, witty, angry, epic story and lovesong inbetween he's the master who changed music and influenced everyone who you would argue could challenge him as being the greatest. He's constantly changed his sound and the fact his last 3 album's are considered to be amongst his best work say's everything about his amazing consistency

Well said.

I'll take Young in his prime over Dylan though, he wrote so many songs that I absolutely love.

[*FiberGlass Doll*]

Bob Dylan.

Where's Stompin' Tom?? He deserves to be on the list. Canada rocks!

Why yes it does!