Neanderpaul

Spoke to Interscope Records today.

Was told that there is no decision on what the next single will be.

This may be a legit promo for the European, or another country, but the U.S. has no 3rd single confirmed. This, according directly to the label.

For some reason, certain people want to start their own personal threads to express an opinion about an existing topic that's currently being discussed in another thread. When this happens, we merge the threads. Simple as that.

This applies to topics that are started by both Slash supporters and by Axl supporters. It seems that ever since Axl started posting here, people want to start their own personal threads - I'm guessing so that Axl will see their particular point of view. In some cases, it's cupcakes hoping that if they're controversial and annoying enough, Axl will call them out on the forum. On the flip side, we get the Axl supporters who think that if they trash Slash on the forum, they'll somehow score points with Axl. *shakes head* Both strategies are pointless and annoying to long-time forum members.

The reason we have threads is for everybody to post their opinions on a particular subject. Your personal opinion on a topic is no more - and no less - important than anybody else's. So, please post in the existing threads!

As for the cupcakes - we don't allow them.

We allow constructive criticism - which generally involves making positive and negative comments. But there's a difference between constructive criticism and pointless bashing in post after post in every thread. If you have no interest in Axl's current lineup and album, then stay out of the main section. This section is for fans who want to talk with other fans about the band and its music, and it's unfair for cupcakes to come in and hijack every thread to spew their hate. We have the GNR Early Days, Reunion and VR sections specifically for people to discuss the original lineup.

If you have further questions or if there's something you don't understand, send me a pm. But starting a topic like this in the main GNR discussion section is another example of how you ignore forum rules. If you don't like the forum rules, you're certainly free to find another forum where you do like the rules.

I appreciate the information. I do have an additional question. Can you please show me the forum rule that this thread violates?

My question related to what "GnR Discussion" is allowed. Would that not be related to the forum? When discussing GnR, a literal guideline as to what's allowed seems to be in order.

What one person sees as a legitimate criticism of Axl, can, and often is interpreted as trolling for trouble. And again, I'm not attempting to start shit, I'm simply wondering what criteria is considered "allowable" criticism vs. "slandering/inflaming" commentary?

And is Axl's presence in this forum dicating moderation policy? If so...it would be nice to know up front. So, that whomever chooses to post, at least realizes they're out of bounds.

Again, thanks to you for at least discussing the question. Lots of mods would've deleted and ignored.

I'm guessing it's already been "locked" or "deleted" huh?

I went through the rules for posting, and you have to admit...they're not being followed

So...

This forum alleges to be the GnR Discussion and News section. And multiple threads discussing certain issues related to the band, some painting some members in unflattering light, get deleted by mods. Actual relative debate related to the future of this "band" and the potential reasons why people would be turned off by GnR...appear to be out-of-bounds.

And yet...the most obtuse, teen-magazine-esque, goofy threads pertaining to Axl whistling, or song requests are allowed to flourish.

My question, and we'll see if the mods allow it, is where's the line? Are you moderating with the purpose of not offending a band member? Do you think fi they come here and read potentially negative content that they'll never show up again.

Should that matter?

I'm being honest, and not trolling for trouble. I'd just like to see a stated reason why certain critical posts get deleted. And yet others are allowed to remain. Where's the line? Sure the FAQ is somewhat of a guideline. But, even the mods (were they to be honest) would admit, that there's selective enforcement, and subjective interpretation being employed.

Thanks In Advance,

My guess is that there aren't many of them...but I have a CD single of Oh My God. I'm searching the net to see if I can even find a picture of it.

I know it was never released for sale..but I have it from when I worked in New Orleans in '99

Might b e interested in trading for something if anyone is interested. My guess is it's probably a nice piece for a collector

Whic one of these is it:

http://www.gnrevolution.com/viewtopic.php?pid=66944

The top one.

I have both "Chinese Democracy" & "Better" promo singles if anyone wants to put together a trade.

I don't believe in selling them...But I'll trade with a fan for something. I believe that's what being fans is all about.

PM me and we'll set something up.

My guess is that there aren't many of them...but I have a CD single of Oh My God. I'm searching the net to see if I can even find a picture of it.

I know it was never released for sale..but I have it from when I worked in New Orleans in '99

Might b e interested in trading for something if anyone is interested. My guess is it's probably a nice piece for a collector

Shoot me a PM if anyone knows of one they might want to swing a deal for.

I have an old Adler stick somewhere from when GnR played the Orpheum in Boston 5/11/88.

Caught it and broke it in half to share with a chick who had her hands on it. The alternative was to beat her senseless to get it

I have the stamped business end, and she got "just the tip"