Jump to content

PhillyRose

Members
  • Posts

    163
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by PhillyRose

  1. 1 hour ago, History2010 said:

    Wtf is the matter with you? Just let people enjoy something for once in your life please. 

    What's the matter with YOUS ?? It's fuckin' CARTOON for CHILDREN & look at how many pages of comments there are & views .... Do you think it's NORMAL for grown men to act like this over their favorite singer appearing in a CHILDREN'S CARTOON ?? I'm just worried about ya'lls mental health really 

    • Like 1
  2. If I went to a GnR show & this song was played I'd leave & never spend money on the band again ... Are yous guys forreal? You're STILL fawning over this song??? The vocals aren't even that impressive ... as if anyone thought Axl couldn't sing anymore ... We didn't need this to prove that! All the shit talking on Melissa by these older guys yet here those same people are clinically obsessing over a LOONEY TUNES joke song ... Wow! 

     

    *deleted in 3...2...* 

    • Thanks 1
    • Haha 1
  3. 1 hour ago, Live Like a Suicide said:

    No Gilby, no tour. No Matt, no tour. Both were instrumental for their times, and i can't help but think some are not giving proper credit where it is due. That said, i do not think Gilby or Matt should replace Richard or Frank, because both are similarly good players and have contributed to the band in the studio and in concert for many years. Just as Gilby and Matt were perfect for the UYI era, Richard and Frank are perfect for the CD/NITL era.

    Don't get me wrong, I'm not in any way trying to underscore what Gilby contributed to the band, all I'm saying is I don't think it's fair to make Gilby out to be "more important" than Fortus because I think Fortus has done a lot more for the band.

  4. 9 hours ago, Sydney Fan said:

    Because he was, pre nitl period, apart of the band during the highest and commercially successful period of the bands history. He was there to do a job, didnt get involved with izzy stouch and suited the bands style. His solo albums are enjoyable listening. If someone can point me to a fortus solo record happy to hear.....did fortus release a solo album..

    He was there for 2 years ... GnR was commercially successful in '91-'93 because of AXL & SLASH ... No one was going to see GILBY live ... Seriously it's kinda cringey to talk about Gilby the way people do here in relation to GnR ... He may have previously kinda sorta resembled IZZY but he's no IZZY 

    • Like 2
  5. 5 hours ago, Propaganda said:

    I agree with everything except for the part of his recordings on the Spaghetti Incident. That album is extremely underrated. I often find myself listening to Buick McKane, Human Being, Raw Power, Since I don't Have You, Ain't it Fun, New Rose and Down on the farm more than anything on the Original Albums. The production of that album is perfect as well, for a band like Guns N'Roses.

    I guess I secretly wished the band had gone to that Punk Rock direction and recorded something themselves of that kind. It would have been a blast.

    I LOVE Spaghetti .. What I meant by my comment was that Izzy's parts should have been on the record, not Gilby's .. So even though Gilby technically is on a GnR record .. I don't count that as his being a band member due to the circumstances (fateful accident)

  6. 4 hours ago, UsedYourIllusion said:

    So it's weird, I feel like Axl understood that some of the songs might have been a little overproduced. For example, when playing Sorry live, he seemed to sing with his normal singing voice, instead of going a little higher-like on the record (and without the doubling and tripling of his voice. That's what Sorry should sound like on the record, imo, rather than what we got. Is that just me?

    His vocals aren't doubled or tripled on Sorry ... The chorus features Axl singing with a mid-range voice with Sebastian Bach falsetto'ing overtop & even a mixed layer of them both in the middle .. And Bach's high singing is still being played in this live performance BTW 

  7. 4 hours ago, vloors said:

    I don't care about Republicans, Democrats whoever but Axl's tweets make him sound like an idiot the way he types them.

    His all over the place and he types like a 13 year old girl with all abbreviations he uses like the 2 (to) 4 (for), r (are) and the emojis. This is a guy in his 50s.

    Love Axl but he needs to get his shit together.

    Yeah and this is the guy that got it ALL FIGURED OUT about Trump & US politics ... You 40-year olds on here parroting & praising his "politics" are just as bad 

×
×
  • Create New...