Who would you rather have back... Bucket or Slash?

[MB.]

cuz its nugnr, no one wants slash to be in that tarnished dump. If its was the old material it would be slash all the way

Speak for yourself, I wouldn't mind to see Slash in that tarnished dump, wouldn't bother me. No, in fact I would love that!

Edited May 9, 2011 by MBRose

[Becket]

whats your point???????????

My point is I voted Slash!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Chewbacca]

Most GNR fans would prefer Slash in band any day over Buckethead.

Have you seen the poll results lately?

Edited May 11, 2011 by Chewbacca

[Guest Len B'stard]

Neither.

I think, with Bumble, Axls struck a bit of a balance, Bumbles like somewhere between Bucket and Slash and it's perfect, he's more rock n roll than bucket and more speccy-techey space ace star wars fan than Slash so perfect. It's kinda retaining the ability to put a decent solo to a nice bluesy rock n roll songs and staying out there enough and retaining a wide enough pallette in case Axl ever comes into the studio with a fuckin gameboy and a zelda game going like "i'm looking for THAT sound".

Slash is the better guitarists out of the fuckin lot of em though.

[sweetness]

they'd only be playing new GNR songs

so no one would be in the crowd anyway?

thanks for the stupid question, sped.

slash, btw.

[Talvisota]

In this case Buckethead. He is one hell of a player.