Who would you rather have back... Bucket or Slash?

[GUNSNROSES513]

The twist is, they'd only be playing new GNR songs.... Kinda a silly question but would you rather have the guy who made GNR what is/was or the guy who helped create all those songs on CD and would probably fit them more appropriately.

[Cdlove]

Come on dude....it's me. Bucket all the way.

[bacardimayne]

The twist is, they'd only be playing new GNR songs....

lol?

bucket all day

[RisingTides]

I'd only want Bucket back if he took the stupid fucking Bucket off of his head.

[bacardimayne]

I'd only want Slash back if he took the stupid fucking hat off of his head.

[RisingTides]

I still wouldn't want him back.

[Encore]

weird, i was thinking about this this morning.

[FuddMckagan]

Niether

[Dead Flower]

they'd only be playing new GNR songs

so no one would be in the crowd anyway?

thanks for the stupid question, sped.

slash, btw.

[inthisriver]

Slash can't do NewGNR.

Buckethead 110%

[moreblack]

Slash can't do NewGNR.

that's probably not what he'd be coming back for

[Chewbacca]

Bucket, definetely. I would choose to have the man who wrote Nottingham Lace and Soothsayer as my band's lead guitarrist anyday.

[Guest Satanisk_Slakt]

Null vote. Slash shall only come back if Duff and Izzy comes as well. And hopefully Steven.

[Velvet-Rose]

they'd only be playing new GNR songs

so no one would be in the crowd anyway?

thanks for the stupid question, sped.

slash, btw.

Slash.

I've always wondered how CD would sound with good rock music to match Axl's voice.

CD music is awful. I mean really.

[Bumble's Bridge Pickup]

Slash.

I've always wondered how CD would sound with good rock music to match Axl's voice.

CD music is awful. I mean really.

Come on, just because it's not rock n' roll doesn't mean it sucks.

[batman007]

I love Slash for what he has done, but Bucket is fn amazing! Also Axl looks happy with Bucket. If Slash came back, Axl would just be waiting for the 2hrs to fly by so he could get off the stage with Slash.

[Chewbacca]

Slash.

I've always wondered how CD would sound with good rock music to match Axl's voice.

CD music is awful. I mean really.

Come on, just because it's not rock n' roll doesn't mean it sucks.

You said it all, dude

[Powerage5]

Bucket, regardless of what they'd be playing. They could be doing Appetite front-to-back, and I'd still prefer Bucket.

[Rovim]

Bucket all the way for me. It would be cool to hear him play There Was A Time live, and he's an all around amazing musician.

[The Wicked Hand]

Slash fo sho...

Buckets a better ripper and a technically better guitarist but slash writes better GNR riffs and solos.

[grigori]

I'd like my time spent hoping during the past 10 years back.

[AmyL]

Honestly, neither.

[ThinkAboutYou]

I think Axl hates slash to much to make more beautiful music together

But I believe the Bucket/Axl relationship could be mended and I very much dig Buckethead's work

[Guest gunns5]

Buckethead 100% he is just a better guitarist.

[Becket]