Which NIN CD should i get?

[Painkiller545]

I dont have enough money for both, its one or the other. So which one is the best one to get?

[FunkyMonk]

With Teeth out of those two.

...but that's only if you have Pretty Hate Machine or Downward Spiral. Get them first.

Edited January 22, 2007 by FunkyMonk

[M_B]

the fragile

songs like starfuckers, the wretched, we're in this together now are awesome. the whole album is an experience really.

[mr.b]

The Fragile in my opinion, is an album for fans, so unless your already a fan, With Teeth is the album for you. With Teeth will convert anyone...

[Morten..]

The Fragile

[Ace Spade]

You don't need money to get music.

You have the internet

[*ParadiseCityGirl*]

With Teeth...and Broken

Those are my favorites anyway.

[EccoTides]

With Teeth, definitely - Despite my apathy toward Trent's lyrics on WT, it's really accessible, well-produced, and concise. And it rocks, too.

The Fragile is the kind of thing you want to save for last, since it's easily the most dense and difficult album in the NIN catalogue. I personally feel that it's a mediocre album, as the awesome first disc is weighed down considerably by the terrible 2nd disc.

[Guest Ohdistortedsmile1789]

It doesn't matter very much.

[Scrubs]

I'd go with The Fragile.

But you should really start out with the Broken EP first. (The Fragile is what got me into NIN, but Broken is just perfect...almost )

[Rebel Yell]

Buy both of them.

[Nefertiti]

Go to the music store and get a fast listen to both CDs, then buy that you liked most...don't ask other ppl to make decision instead of you

[Mr MacPhisto]

Had to go with with teeth!

[JDRM]

Ive got them all (Uncle's a fan) and IMO they are all pretty shitty...

[kevdo242]

Ive got them all (Uncle's a fan) and IMO they are all pretty shitty...

How dare you have a different opinion to me!

[westcoast struttin']

But you should really start out with the Broken EP first. (The Fragile is what got me into NIN, but Broken is just perfect...almost )

broken for sure!

i'd say do broken and then work your way out to downward spiral and pretty hate machine from there. with teeth started to bore me after the first month or so, although i do like it better than the fragile for the most part. i stood in line at midnight to buy the fragile and never could really dig on it, even after a long ass time spent with it.....the songs on it just arent that great to me. the sounds are really cool and there's some great technical studio work, but all of his other records have better tunes to me at least, although there are a few pretty great ones scattered throughout the fragile.

[Axingn'r]

With Teeth-

[DesireFinck]

easy one... out of those two.. you should get The Fragile.. the best trent ever made next to the downward spiral and Broken

[vulgar]

neither if i were you i would get broken unless u already have it.

[madison]

With Teeth out of those two.

...but that's only if you have Pretty Hate Machine or Downward Spiral. Get them first.

Agreed.

Pretty Hate Machine is the best - followed closely by Downward Spiral.

If you're not used to the music and want to be "eased" into NIN, then get "With Teeth" - because it's the most "mainstream" album Trent's ever made. But if you're looking for lots of emotional angst and deep lyrics - then PHM -- If you're looking for raw, layered industrial rock that blows your mind, then Downward Spiral or the Fragile.