Jump to content

t-p-d-a

Club Members
  • Posts

    2,180
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Posts posted by t-p-d-a

  1. 11 minutes ago, allwaystired said:

    What are the differences between these and the ones on the AFD Super Deluxe? Is there anything really discernible? 

    unmastered and some takes were not included in a AFD Box like Rocket Queen Take 2, Nice Boys Take 2 and 3, Cornshucker and Don't Cry

    For me it's sad that Jumpin Jack Flash Take 2 was not included because it's my favourite version because Axl sings...

    Slash was drowned (...)
    Steven looked frowned (...)
    Duff fell down (...)
    Izzy was crowned (...)

    He doesn't sing it on the version on the AFD Box.. i think only two names but not all four names

    But these version (except Cornshucker) were already on the internet. I remember a YouTube Channel in 2008 or so, where a guy uploads tons of Appetite and Illusion Takes and Demos, including Sound City and Mystic Studio.. it's already blocked years ago but i download it all but bad quality. And there were three Don't Cry Version. One Mystic Studio '85 and one from the Sound City Studio '86 and another take.
     

  2. 3 hours ago, Caedo said:

    Surely this doesn't change anything if the working theory was that Monsters was going to be a hidden track and therefore wouldn't be listed on the tracklist regardless?

    Yes. I'm pretty sure the leak came from the vinyl with the wrong mix, with "Monsters" as a hidden track. For me "The General" sounds less finished than "Monsters". Maybe this is the issue for the delay.

    So the vinyl might have the hidden track but the CD? That's the question. If they do a album at the end anyway with all "new" tracks later, maybe the hidden track it's only avaible on vinyl for now.

  3. 35 minutes ago, slash23579 said:

    come on there is no way it’s just one song, i don’t care how it’s registered. both songs have a full verse/chorus/verse/chorus/bridge/chorus structure with an intro and outro and with different tones and tempos and nothing that connects the two. i do not think it is meant to be viewed as one 9 minute song at all. i also think the vinyl will only have The General, not Monsters, and that these leaks came from a different source 

    one song: no
    hidden track on vinyl: yes

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...