dando

The replacements are hit and miss, same as sixx am, replacements have split a million times and back together again, Stinson's solo albums have been great, better than the replacements new song

Anyone want to see a Nu-GNR reunion?

Robin in for Bumble then yes, frank is a beast and it's impossible to get josh freese 24/7 so ferrer/brain

I'm sure a month ago slash said the opposite of this, something like 'it could happen'

In have Stinson's albums on a bit , bits of sixx am are good, never listened to bumbles solo stuff, bucket is a genius

Last time I checked, Eminem was actually releasing albums.

He is, they're all shit but they're released and Axl's are not

On an ordinary day

Not in an ordinary way

All at once the song I heard

No longer would it play for anybody

Or anyone

That needed comfort from somebody

Needed comfort from

Someone who cared

To be not like you

And unlike me

And then the voices went away

From me

Somehow you set the wheels in motion

It haunts our memories

You were the instrument

You were the one

How a body took a body

You gave that boy a gun

You took our innocence

Beyond our stares

Sometimes the only thing

We counted on

When no one else was there

Catcher is crap, sorry to break it to you like that

From previous hiatus periods at least there was the mystique of an album cooking in the oven (which got burned) but now there's not even the slightest rumour of a whatever album in the making.

I think that FB status from yesterday was a goodbye.

Wow. I don't follow them on Twitter, so I'd say I was a little taken back when I saw this:

"Don't you take it so hard now

And please don't take it so bad

I'll still be thinkin' of you

And the times we had... baby(ies)"

That is a goodbye if I ever heard one.

Or maybe 'don't cry' lyrics......don't read too much into a lyric

What would you have said if it was 'why don't you just fuck off' from ISE ???

That's an ending too isn't it ??

These guys don't capitalize on shit... Going down made a little noise when it leaked what did they do? Nothing. Revolver awards? Nothing. Duff reuniting for some shows? Like it never happened. Axl getting number one on that singe chart thing? Axl talks about giraffes.

Why not release going down as a single when it leaked fuk it it's already out there, put it on iTunes in a quality version with Axl louder. I woulda bought it. And I don't think I've ever bought a song off iTunes

Great point, they've had shit loads of opportunities over ages now. Time with duff, golden gods, the chat show that Axl appeared on, GET SOMETHING DONE

Blatter was like a 'football's hitler' , a twat that's ruined the greatest sport on earth, much like a band that was the greatest band in the world, it's gone tits up

Axl rose and kimi raikkonen,two guys dont give a fuck what people saying or think about them.

Not one fuck given between them , kimi is actually funny but doesn't give a shit

That video is hardly a fight, seen worse in local pubs

A lot has been made out of nothing , it's made worse by people cos it's DJ

Can't imagine Axl been able to use a phone or anything really

Why? Do you think he's retarded or something?

Do you really think Axl runs his own twitter account? Come on he has someone wiping his ass every day , can't imagine Axl sitting down and using twitter on his phone

Same as normal though eh, you're always right , everyone else's opinion is wrong

He'll have never used his own twitter , he'll have one of team Brazil or some tool running it for him. Can't imagine Axl been able to use a phone or anything really

The UYI tour was solid? They've done 194 shows in 3 years (of course the ticket sales were better so the term solid applied here)

You're not understanding what he meant. It's not about ticket sales, it's about consecutive, extensive, non-stop touring. The fallacy and fantasy is: "Axl deserves a break because he has been touring solidly for years." Truth is, he hasn't.

Who's said the band or Axl 'deserve' a break ?

You need one yeah if you're going to play 'newer stuff' (shacklers for example)

Could DJ and Fortus do there was a time and estranged ?

Sensible thing is robin finck but he's a bit hit n miss live

Axl was worth 150 million dollars in 2013. I doubt he's having cash flow issues. He does whatever he wants to do as a result. I hope he's putting the final touches of the next record and prepping it for release soon though...

What you're worth and what you have in the bank is completely different, Axl owns the GNR name, what's the band worth as a brand

My opinion on this should be filed under "I Would LOVE To Be Wrong" but I've been thinking we've seen his last performance for a little while now.

I don't think they'll tour til the middle of next year, sixx am doing a world tour , dead daisies on the road and so are the replacements , so that's a lot of gunners doing other stuff

You kidding? If Axl has as big an ego as people say why would he go out without actually telling anyone? And what's he going to do now? He's done solid touring since 2009, he's probably taking a break. Not to mention they need some time to either replace Bumble or rearrange songs/parts.

Agree totally, you can't lose bumble then go 'ok back on stage'. Who plays what or get finck back in or whoever takes time. Solid touring for ages, give them a break n see which Axl turns up , the one who gives a shit or one that doesn't wanna be there.

Still can't believe people think a reunion will ever happen, it won't , move on it ain't 1992 anymore

I can name 14 very bad GNR songs. You might not consider them GnR songs though.

Do you seriously think all of them are bad?

Bad songs on CD , scraped, catcher and riad

People who are stuck in 1991 can't see that parts of chinese would easily fit onto the illusions albums

It's not the best show they did but it's pretty decent representation of the show they have and people do enjoy it. I don't have a problem with rough vocals. Its rock music.

No, it isn't. The current band has had better shows in the last years. The one released is shit. I don't have a problem with rough vocals either, I do have a problem with a lazy frontman cash-grabbing the shit out of the legacy of the band I love.

That's what I said its not the best show. But it's a good show. It's a bit more of a pop rock show than those epic classic rock shows for the UYI tour.

The cash grab thing is irrelevant now. If you can't get over that Axl uses the name then sure. But it's just a band not some sacred legacy thing.

Its all about you I guess. The band you love doesn't exist anymore and they can't even be friends enough to Chat let alone a reunion. So how sacred is it to the band. That wonderful time when we all hated each other and made great music.

I'd love a reunion but I'm not interested in this bitterness at all. There's a ton of stuff to hate in the world more important than Axls band you know?

Well said

AFD is better than U2's boring DVD, but the AC/DC river plate DVD is miles better

How can silkworms be listed ? We've never heard the finished studio track

Least fav 10 are

Right next door to hell

Catcher

Shotgun blues

Garden of Eden

Scraped

I don't care about you (worst song on TSI)

14 years

Dust n bones

So fine

And I'll get hammered for this but , coma......I can't be arsed to listen to it all

It's weird the Chilis peppers label paid millions for them to play. Why?

Didn't they have a new album coming out? Or just came out?

The chilli peppers didn't even play live ! It was all pre recorded, anyway the Super Bowl is just really not my thing, just yanks in padding throwing an egg around. Fuck that GNR just need to do a bloody album !

Who are they ?

Like it or not, any future GNR album will probably have DJ playing on it a hell of a lot , reunion I'll never happen so if u want a new album this is what you'll get

The ultimate line up to play a CD show.

Axl, Brain, Frank, Tommy, Dizzy, Pitman, Tobias, Finck, Fortus, Bucket, Bumble.

One show to rule the world.

Ditch Frank & Tobias and I'm on board.

Axl, josh freeze, dizzy, tommy, Fortus & finck / DJ