Roger is better as Gilmour.. or not?

[Postal Dude]

I personaly think that Roger is a much better artist if we look at his skills for making an album, look at his solo project such as Amused to Death and compare this with Division Bell. I think Gilmour is only very good at wcomposing music. What is you're opinion???

[highvoltage]

You're username's second account, aren't you?

[johnezz]

Roger is much more talented than Gilmour in songwriting terms, but of course, Gilmour is much more amazing guitar player.

[Postal Dude]

You're username's second account, aren't you?  

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

No man this is not username's second acount...

[highvoltage]

You're username's second account, aren't you?  

Actualy no.

I'm sure Madison or Eric can confirm this.

(I was joking)

EDIT: You both took me seriously? Even with the ""?

I said it jokingly because you're both into Floyd and you're both from the same region. No need to get defensive.

Edited November 17, 2005 by highvoltageacdc

[Postal Dude]

You're username's second account, aren't you?  

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Actualy no.

I'm sure Madison or Eric can confirm this.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

(I was joking)

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Yeah sure, but it seems to that username live's in the same state as I am. But ofcourse he want's nothing to do with me since I'm on parole..

Edited November 17, 2005 by Postal Dude

[Chrisi Rokks]

Bit of a grey area...Roger is better at writing songs than gilmour...but Gilmour is the supreme musician of the band. He's a fuckin genious at composing where as Waters is the lyric master

[Postal Dude]

Bit of a grey area...Roger is better at writing songs than gilmour...but Gilmour is the supreme musician of the band. He's a fuckin genious at composing where as Waters is the lyric master

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I doubt that, if you listen to Amused to Death you can hear in what Roger is capable of. Stil my favorite PF/RW/DG albums are Animals and WYWH. Roger and Dave are just a winning theme.

[Yamisonic]

Roger.

[Postal Dude]

Who the fuck voted on Gilmour??

[Postal Dude]

Roger.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Good awnser, you may live!

[stevGNR666]

dave is the better singer/muscian --- by a long shot

roger of course had the visual and creative expression

so null vote...

but to get your panties in a bunch i'm gonna vote for dave

Edited November 18, 2005 by stevGNR666

[kevdo242]

Well I don't know much about what songs were written by who. Who composed Echoes? Whoever did that gets my vote.

[Hyp3rFi3rc3]

Echoes is good. Waters is better composing but Guilmour is a better guitarrist.

[White_Mouse]

Yes he is.

[Guest gnr>everything]

Who the fuck voted on Gilmour?? 

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Why would you make him an option in the poll if you don't want people to vote for him?

[Postal Dude]

Well I don't know much about what songs were written by who.  Who composed Echoes?  Whoever did that gets my vote.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Lyrics: waters

Music: gilmour, wright, waters, mason

[Postal Dude]

Who the fuck voted on Gilmour?? 

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Why would you make him an option in the poll if you don't want people to vote for him?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Just fooling around

[Rumin]

Roger Waters is a better artist. Gilmour is a better musician. Vague poll.

[ChineseDemocracy2004]

Null vote

dave is a great guitarist and roger is a great songwriter