GROHL vs COBAIN

[gin_hotel]

vote

[Guest zipgunboogie]

i prefer cobain

[Slash n' Burn]

Dave grohl hasnt even got the right to be in the same senctance as the legedanry kurt!

Dave can go make his average boring music but Kurts music will always be rememebered!

[Bucketslash]

this is a stupid poll

foo fighters vs. nirvana?

probot vs. mudhoney?

duh...

[Yamisonic]

Dave grohl hasnt even got the right to be in the same senctance as the legedanry kurt!

Dave can go make his average boring music but Kurts music will always be rememebered!

Dude they were in the same fucking band!

I'd go for Kurt.

[Nightrain_Kid]

Foo fighters have been dissapointing of late, the last album was ambitous though i'll give them that, nothing to compare to "there is nothing left to lose" there best album imo but nirvana seemed a bit more consistent so im gonna vote for kurt cobain

[axlslash]

Null. Hate em both.

[Alan Niveen]

Kurt Cobain is already a legend.

Dave Grohl is very talented too, but he will probably be remembered as Nirvana's outstanding drummer...

[supersillyspacemonkey]

i voter grohl just because cobain is so stupidly overrated its not even funny

[metallic ko]

i voter grohl just because cobain is so stupidly overrated its not even funny

Exactly.

I'd rather listen to Foo Fighters then Nirvana aswell.

[byeaxlhiaxl]

cobain, cos grohls stuff just gets a bit samey after a while

[jack99]

Kurt Cobain is already a legend.

Dave Grohl is very talented too, but he will probably be remembered as Nirvana's outstanding drummer...

I think Dave has changed that now, Nirvana is no longer the first and only thing that comes to mind when his named is mentioned. He's proved to everyone that he's not just a good drummer. He can write, sing, play guitar and entertain!

Although I don't the song writing can be compared with Kurt's.

[Dead Flower]

Nirvana is no longer the first and only thing that comes to mind when his named is mentioned.

I always think of this:

[Lithium]

Kurt, easily. I mean, Dave Grohl is a great musician, but he can't even compare to Kurt.

[ScottRose]

AHA! AHAHA! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!

Dave Grohl can go fuck himself. He ain't got nothin' on Kurt. He's a good drummer though.

[matt_barker]

i love grohl.. but cobain over anyone

[Spoon87]

Kurt Cobain... Dave's one cool dude too tho.

[damian 1200]

Have you heard the foos cover of stairway?

grohl literally sings the solo

[Alan Niveen]

Grohl likes Guns N'Roses. Kurt didn't.

[Genesis]

Grohl likes Guns N'Roses. Kurt didn't.

You can't base anything on that.

[Genesis]

Grohl likes Guns N'Roses. Kurt didn't.

You can't base anything on that.

Except that Alan Niveen probably doesn't like Vince Neil or Brett Michaels either.

Who does?

[gin_hotel]

Grohl likes Guns N'Roses. Kurt didn't.

dave was the one doing the whole '' wheres axl, theres axl, hi axl'' stuff at the vma's after kurt and axl fell out. grohl was sarcastic as fuck, he likes slash but not axl

[Alan Niveen]

I've already posted my opinion in the first page of the thread. My last comment came up because I remembered an interview of Dave Grohl in which he said the first appearance of Guns N'Roses on MTV's Headbanger's Ball had a great impact on him.

Edited February 27, 2006 by Alan Niveen

[Nightrain_Kid]

So were now basing who the better songwriter is on who liked guns n' roses more?

[Jmm]

Kobain ,I mean he was one of the best songwriters EVER.....