Jump to content

Jimi Hendrix


Axl_morris

Recommended Posts

Yeah, no doubt the most influential guitarist of all time, and no-one was doing what he was at the time, but meh, listening to him doesn't do that much for me nowadays. There have been much better guitarists in the 36(?) years since his death. He has been put on a pedestal due to his death.

not really dude, however long he'd've lived, even if he'd gone totally downhill after his achievements prior to that would still have been as good as groundbreaking as cool as they are/were. i do agree that "better" (whatever that word means) guitarists have come since. i mean certainly in terms of range, bucket has proved he's better.

Oh, I don't mean that his death makes his contributions to music any less important. Whether he'd have died or not, he'd still be a groundbreaking musician. I just think that his talents and achievements are sometimes blown out of proportion because of his death. It happens with every musician; Cobain, Sid Vicious, etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, no doubt the most influential guitarist of all time, and no-one was doing what he was at the time, but meh, listening to him doesn't do that much for me nowadays. There have been much better guitarists in the 36(?) years since his death. He has been put on a pedestal due to his death.

Better guitarists? Who? In terms of technique, perhaps some virtuosos, but no way as groundbreaking and passionate as Hendrix. That guy was so way ahead of his time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, no doubt the most influential guitarist of all time, and no-one was doing what he was at the time, but meh, listening to him doesn't do that much for me nowadays. There have been much better guitarists in the 36(?) years since his death. He has been put on a pedestal due to his death.

Better guitarists? Who? In terms of technique, perhaps some virtuosos, but no way as groundbreaking and passionate as Hendrix. That guy was so way ahead of his time.

yeah, in terms of technique and range, bucket is better but then you have to take into account that Hendrix laid a lot of the groundwork for people like bucket to build on. he's not as groundbreaking, agreed :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, no doubt the most influential guitarist of all time, and no-one was doing what he was at the time, but meh, listening to him doesn't do that much for me nowadays. There have been much better guitarists in the 36(?) years since his death. He has been put on a pedestal due to his death.

Better guitarists? Who? In terms of technique, perhaps some virtuosos, but no way as groundbreaking and passionate as Hendrix. That guy was so way ahead of his time.

yeah, in terms of technique and range, bucket is better but then you have to take into account that Hendrix laid a lot of the groundwork for people like bucket to build on. he's not as groundbreaking, agreed :)

Jimi's almost as good at Guitar as Ricky Hatton is at boxing!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, no doubt the most influential guitarist of all time, and no-one was doing what he was at the time, but meh, listening to him doesn't do that much for me nowadays. There have been much better guitarists in the 36(?) years since his death. He has been put on a pedestal due to his death.

Better guitarists? Who? In terms of technique, perhaps some virtuosos, but no way as groundbreaking and passionate as Hendrix. That guy was so way ahead of his time.

yeah, in terms of technique and range, bucket is better but then you have to take into account that Hendrix laid a lot of the groundwork for people like bucket to build on. he's not as groundbreaking, agreed :)

Jimi's almost as good at Guitar as Ricky Hatton is at boxing!

i wouldnt call Jimi hendrix style-less and 2 dimensional :P:lol: Jimi's more like the muhammad ali of guitar playing B)

Edited by ffrankwhite
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, no doubt the most influential guitarist of all time, and no-one was doing what he was at the time, but meh, listening to him doesn't do that much for me nowadays. There have been much better guitarists in the 36(?) years since his death. He has been put on a pedestal due to his death.

Better guitarists? Who? In terms of technique, perhaps some virtuosos, but no way as groundbreaking and passionate as Hendrix. That guy was so way ahead of his time.

i totally agree with that he was a head of his time

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, no doubt the most influential guitarist of all time, and no-one was doing what he was at the time, but meh, listening to him doesn't do that much for me nowadays. There have been much better guitarists in the 36(?) years since his death. He has been put on a pedestal due to his death.

Better guitarists? Who? In terms of technique, perhaps some virtuosos, but no way as groundbreaking and passionate as Hendrix. That guy was so way ahead of his time.

Well better is subjective of course, there's no point getting into an argument about that. Although if you want my opinion, Eddie Van Halen, Randy Rhoads, David Gilmour, Brian May and several others are/were better than Hendrix.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, no doubt the most influential guitarist of all time, and no-one was doing what he was at the time, but meh, listening to him doesn't do that much for me nowadays. There have been much better guitarists in the 36(?) years since his death. He has been put on a pedestal due to his death.

Better guitarists? Who? In terms of technique, perhaps some virtuosos, but no way as groundbreaking and passionate as Hendrix. That guy was so way ahead of his time.

Well better is subjective of course, there's no point getting into an argument about that. Although if you want my opinion, Eddie Van Halen, Randy Rhoads, David Gilmour, Brian May and several others are/were better than Hendrix.

Better in what terms? Technique? Some of them, perhaps. Influence? Passion? No.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Ohdistortedsmile1789

It's not even about technique, or influence, or even passion. No one could play the guitar like Jimi Hendrix. Nothing will ever equal the kind of phrasing, the perfection of something like "All Along the Watchtower". Speed and proficiency and the like mean nothing, it's about the notes and the spaces between them.

He was the messiah of pre-war blues. He brought the country blues styles up to Rock N' Roll speed, and then added some of his own, very unique magic. I don't consider Jimi Hendrix to be a rock artist. He dabbled in pop quite a bit, but songs like "Purple Haze", "Manic Depression", and so many others are simply his own blues.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, no doubt the most influential guitarist of all time, and no-one was doing what he was at the time, but meh, listening to him doesn't do that much for me nowadays. There have been much better guitarists in the 36(?) years since his death. He has been put on a pedestal due to his death.

Better guitarists? Who? In terms of technique, perhaps some virtuosos, but no way as groundbreaking and passionate as Hendrix. That guy was so way ahead of his time.

Well better is subjective of course, there's no point getting into an argument about that. Although if you want my opinion, Eddie Van Halen, Randy Rhoads, David Gilmour, Brian May and several others are/were better than Hendrix.

Better in what terms? Technique? Some of them, perhaps. Influence? Passion? No.

Not technique, everyone knows that judging a guitarist on technique is stupid. Influence doesn't mean someone is a good guitarist, Ace Frehley probably influenced a lot more people than Kevin Shields, doesn't make him better does it? As for passion, that's a very ambiguous term. Different pieces evoke different passions with different people, how does one song have more passion than another? And how is passion a criterion for assessing how good a guitarist is? Eddie Van Halen's work isn't particularly moving or soulful but that doesn't mean he's not a great guitarist.

The mark of a good guitarist is if they can write good riffs and solos, right? Personally, I prefer the work of Rhoads, Gilmour etc. to Hendrix. I'm sorry for disagreeing with you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The mark of a good guitarist is if they can write good riffs and solos, right?

What, Hendrix didn't write good riffs and solos? What about Voodo Chile (Slight Return), Machine Gun, Purple Haze, Foxy Lady, Little Wing, Red House? They've got all the ingredients of good riffs and solos.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The mark of a good guitarist is if they can write good riffs and solos, right?

What, Hendrix didn't write good riffs and solos? What about Voodo Chile (Slight Return), Machine Gun, Purple Haze, Foxy Lady, Little Wing, Red House? They've got all the ingredients of good riffs and solos.

To me, Hendrix was the best at playing chordish rhythm leads like in Little Wing and Castles Made of Sand. It wasn't necessarily rhythm because he would add licks and slurs to his chords to make it sounds like lead soloing. it was just a good understanding of rhythm and music in general. he didn't have to play a solo; his overall playing was great.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The mark of a good guitarist is if they can write good riffs and solos, right?

What, Hendrix didn't write good riffs and solos? What about Voodo Chile (Slight Return), Machine Gun, Purple Haze, Foxy Lady, Little Wing, Red House? They've got all the ingredients of good riffs and solos.

To me, Hendrix was the best at playing chordish rhythm leads like in Little Wing and Castles Made of Sand. It wasn't necessarily rhythm because he would add licks and slurs to his chords to make it sounds like lead soloing. it was just a good understanding of rhythm and music in general. he didn't have to play a solo; his overall playing was great.

spot on!! cuz he was so versed in rhythm playing the sideman on the chitlin circuit for so long.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Ohdistortedsmile1789
The mark of a good guitarist is if they can write good riffs and solos, right? Personally, I prefer the work of Rhoads, Gilmour etc. to Hendrix. I'm sorry for disagreeing with you.

Being a good guitarist doesn't have shit to do with writing, that's another department entirely. If you think Hendrix or even Gilmour wrote out all of their solos, you'd be playing the fool.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The mark of a good guitarist is if they can write good riffs and solos, right?

What, Hendrix didn't write good riffs and solos? What about Voodo Chile (Slight Return), Machine Gun, Purple Haze, Foxy Lady, Little Wing, Red House? They've got all the ingredients of good riffs and solos.

I've never said Hendrix wasn't great, just that I prefer others.

The mark of a good guitarist is if they can write good riffs and solos, right? Personally, I prefer the work of Rhoads, Gilmour etc. to Hendrix. I'm sorry for disagreeing with you.

Being a good guitarist doesn't have shit to do with writing, that's another department entirely. If you think Hendrix or even Gilmour wrote out all of their solos, you'd be playing the fool.

Perhaps write wasn't the correct word. Create would probably be more apt. But it's not true that being a good guitarist has nothing to do with writing. It's naive to believe that Gilmour's and Hendrix's solos were completely improvised. Usually what happens is they figure out a basic pattern and a couple of licks, and improvise over that structure.

Edited by sabre
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not even about technique, or influence, or even passion. No one could play the guitar like Jimi Hendrix. Nothing will ever equal the kind of phrasing, the perfection of something like "All Along the Watchtower". Speed and proficiency and the like mean nothing, it's about the notes and the spaces between them.

He was the messiah of pre-war blues. He brought the country blues styles up to Rock N' Roll speed, and then added some of his own, very unique magic. I don't consider Jimi Hendrix to be a rock artist. He dabbled in pop quite a bit, but songs like "Purple Haze", "Manic Depression", and so many others are simply his own blues.

YEAH case closed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Ohdistortedsmile1789
The mark of a good guitarist is if they can write good riffs and solos, right?

What, Hendrix didn't write good riffs and solos? What about Voodo Chile (Slight Return), Machine Gun, Purple Haze, Foxy Lady, Little Wing, Red House? They've got all the ingredients of good riffs and solos.

I've never said Hendrix wasn't great, just that I prefer others.

The mark of a good guitarist is if they can write good riffs and solos, right? Personally, I prefer the work of Rhoads, Gilmour etc. to Hendrix. I'm sorry for disagreeing with you.

Being a good guitarist doesn't have shit to do with writing, that's another department entirely. If you think Hendrix or even Gilmour wrote out all of their solos, you'd be playing the fool.

Perhaps write wasn't the correct word. Create would probably be more apt. But it's not true that being a good guitarist has nothing to do with writing. It's naive to believe that Gilmour's and Hendrix's solos were completely improvised. Usually what happens is they figure out a basic pattern and a couple of licks, and improvise over that structure.

Agreed, an absolute on either end would be incorrect.

Needless to say, David Gilmour or Randy Rhoads' works could very well move you more than Hendrix's. Each guitarist is an individual, and so are you and I, so there's always going to be someone more appealing to your tastes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...