THELINESMAN

2 hours ago, Arnuld said:

Would have been a bit easier had he gone and done a run through at least once. Just saying 

Yeah the time to not project properly because you are finding your way through a song is in rehearsal 😂

2 minutes ago, cooker said:

He also crucified the dead. 

You cannot crucify the dead

An outro Slash solo like on that YouTube video would have given the song better momentum towards the end rather than just repeated chorus, everyone would have loved it. What was Slash thinking 😂

22 minutes ago, Gibbo said:

 

Wish this was in the actual song 😩 I expected an epic face melter like this from Slash 

4 minutes ago, ShadowOfTheWave said:

Some of the people (though not all) insisting it's Fortus seem to be desperate to believe that Slash would not "allow" an ex-member to stay on a new song. Which is absurd for multiple reasons.

I think both Slash and Axl have grown up a lot since the Sympathy for the Devil don’t touch my solo shenanigans 

2 hours ago, TrixAreForKids said:

My only knock on the song. Was expecting a wicked Slash solo, not sure what happened 🤷‍♂️

Same

1 minute ago, Trin9498 said:

Song sounds better than demo. I love the layered piano. Agree with others though….solo is low spot. 

How can solo be a low spot on a GNR song 😱 FFS Slash should milk the solo through to the last verse/chorus 

They’re selling a Perhaps Magic 8 Ball…I love it tbh 😂🎱https://uk.gnrmerch.com/products/perhaps-magic-8-ball?pr_prod_strat=collection_fallback&pr_rec_id=6431eec81&pr_rec_pid=8503001121076&pr_ref_pid=8502751297844&pr_seq=uniform

21 minutes ago, Martin Riggs said:

Yeah it appears their idea of great promotion (and probably why it was delayed a week) was to give Audacy rock stations in the USA the song exclusively to play one day before it officially came out. It also seems based on Audacy’s description of the song that they may be trying to mislead people that this is a new song that Axl/Slash/Duff wrote together…

https://www.audacy.com/national/music/world-premiere-guns-n-roses-perhaps

 

According to an official release, "Perhaps" was "written and recorded by Axl Rose, Slash, and Duff McKagan this year," and is their "first collective new composition and recording together in thirty years since 1993’s 'The Spaghetti Incident?'"

Check out the band's brand new single "Perhaps" all day Thursday, August 17, beginning at 12AM ET on your favorite Audacy Rock stations.

"first collective new composition and recording together in thirty years since 1993’s 'The Spaghetti Incident?'"
 

Interesting. Could Perhaps be from 1994-1995?

1 minute ago, GNFNRUK said:

I agree with Jarring, it also seems completely unnecessary to leave it in. I’m not a huge fan of the Slash solo here but it would have worked better if it went straight into it WITHOUT the bend. It really does sound like a mixing error, even though I’m sure (for whatever reason) it was intentional…

The bend being left in just makes me wish Slash played the original solo ☹️

Showed it to a few casual fan friends. There is consensus. They want less piano and more Slash riff driven rockers 

Axl’s new vocals on this are great 🔥

Lyrics are good 🤘

Piano is good 🎹

Raspy bits of chorus now buried in mix presumably because he can’t sing them live anymore ☹️

Slash solo is a shocking turd compared to original solo 😬

5-6/10. Looking forward to the other reworked Chinese leftovers and eventual collation of a new EP/Album - Appetite For Chinese Leftovers 

Snippets of radio recordings here https://blabbermouth.net/news/new-guns-n-roses-single-perhaps-has-been-officially-released

Anybody manage to rip audio of this from radio?

5 minutes ago, betterman said:

How would you feel if the General is almost like Evaders version?

Shit

14 minutes ago, General2112 said:

Oh lol I should’ve read your post better. Yeah I’m sure they’ll soundcheck it. I can’t wait to see what he has to say about it leaking 

Jukeboxing Motherfuckers 

5 minutes ago, lost un the jungle said:

Other good one was when he san "out ta bite me", related to a dude that bit him in a sort of fight (circa 2007)

Is there a clip of out ta bite me? 😂

14 minutes ago, General2112 said:

I’d also like to know why people think we’re getting Atlas. It hasn’t been on any setlist yet or soundchecked that I know of. 

Richard had a sitar style guitar pedal on his social medial and someone commented it was for PTU and Richard replied something like ‘yeah, and for something you don’t know about’ and we. Concluded Atlas. Pretty sure I remember seeing Atlas on old ALT lists too but might be mistaken.

Is it just a recording of a jukebox playing out loud that we have? Nobody able to rip the audio directly from the tunes thing or something?

Anyway, I’ve heard the jukebox recording. I like Axl’s vocals and lyrics but what is that Slash solo 👀 Could have had a soulful face melter on this one, building up to something epic, instead it sounds unfinished and not like Slash ☹️ 

New thread title 

Just now, Nick85 said:

Same here dude. We don’t get much as GNR fans so having these small breadcrumbs pulled away just isn’t cool.

Yep 

What the hell is going on 

Yes. With proper vocal coaching. I hope it happens because if it does it will be glorious. 

6 hours ago, bmus1 said:

 

Dead lmfao

More rasp in this bad boy than we’re gonna get live. Well done Dustin Bones!