Finck2006

2 minutes ago, nico-ferro said:

hey, just read on another site that the full 20 cds JUST leaked minutes ago. is there any truth to that?

If people are not discussing it.

Dont think so

Just now, CoBrA2168 said:

Can someone post a list of what exactly has leaked since yesterday? I realize Hard School leaked over the weekend, and then there was a ~1 min clip of snippets from various songs, but it sounds like a bunch more came out yesterday??

Twat

2 versions of Prostitute

The blues

Chinese democracy

Going down

IRS

Catcher in the Rye

Hardschool

Riad

19 minutes ago, Requiem16 said:

I think that it`s up to Axl to show us tracks in 2008. He tried to find a "Perfect" mix for each song. And it killed CD. That`s why it`s a soap songs in 2008. Songs can`t be and mustn`t be perfect. They must be alive and powerful. Axl fucked up right in that moment.

Well the main problem was to have everyone on the mix...you cant have 2 drummers and 5 guitar players on the same song

Still no old Silkworms,Atlas arent out?

25 minutes ago, dido__k said:

So, may we suggest that this is the album intended for a 2000 release? Was 2000 intentions wrongly cited ( it couldhave been 2000 intention, meaning it was intwnded for release in year 2000)?

It was intended to be released in 1999 before 2000.

And yes the name was 2000 Intentions

The list completed of the leaks tonight are?

19 minutes ago, WAR41 said:

Lol I think you're confusing 'obsessing' with 'curiosity'.  I am curious to know who leaked the tracks.  If any of you say you aren't the least bit curious I'd be surprised.  I'm not going on a tirade to find out.  I think the story behind these leaks is likely to be fascinating.  

Try to not encourage your curiosity before the leaks comes.

Rumours and talk about the leakers are not good for the leaks.

U understand that?

31 minutes ago, WAR41 said:

I mean.... I do 

The only thing you will have  to try to know the source and let everybody knows whos behind ..is cut the leak..

You want that?

12 minutes ago, default_ said:

In other forums people are saying that rick is the one doing it and he is thinking about leaking the whole thing in the next days. But who knows, I know nothing.

Dont look to find to know whos behind that.

Why you want to know? This is public and everybody can read including TB

17 minutes ago, default_ said:

Anyways... It looks like the whole 99 album is circulating in some form, the files are labeled numerically, Atlas is 2, Carcher is 6, TWAT is 8 and so on. 

What?????

Im curious to hear Chinese Democracy from that era

Also the unheard sure..

39 minutes ago, DeperilsofrockNRollDekednz said:

Missed some of the pithy wisdom offered here. Does anyone recall Axl’s message board 2008 interview where he mentioned Robin Finck’s valuable contribution to Jackie Chan, which supposedly is part of of CD2 and also known as Hardschool? 

He didnt said that

11 minutes ago, ronartest2004 said:

They are being discussed on other gnr forums, but I think for the mass public it’s not going to mean much unless something with axl and slash comes out.

Better for us less noise.

Leakers are more safe

Just now, zombux said:

fuck, you are right. I got confused by other line of thoughts in my head

I dont know why me too

10 minutes ago, zombux said:

so a big part of the song is made from old guitar tracks (because Robin left more than half a year before this was mixed), and the rest was made by absolutely fresh addition to the band (because Buckethead joined very early 2000, and this song was supposed to be mixed on 27th March 2000).

Paul Huge on rhytm guitar I guess and Josh Freese on drums for sure I guess.

The picture says 8 november 2000

24 minutes ago, Stoymatic said:

Just thought of this...does anyone know how the full version leaked? 

Most of us know where the most recent snippet of this song came from, so it is the same person/people who put out the full version?

Dont tell dont ask

6 minutes ago, rebeldhipi said:

Josh freese instead of Brain.

If iremember correctly Brain didnt start recording his drum parts until after Rock in Rio. 

Im sure that he said in an interview that it took months even for him to get the musical sheet music of what Josh played. So i think its highly unlikely that Brain had all the drums done by August 2000

Well the recordings are dated November 2000.

57 minutes ago, Ralphelmo said:

I don't get the excitement, this song is really 'generic' as some would say. Who was included in that recording? First solo is probably the worst I've heard in GNR history.

The first solo I bet Paul Tobias and right after Robin .

The line up should be Ax Tommy Robin Paul Bucket Brain Pitman Reed

13 minutes ago, DieselDaisy said:

See. People say, ''nobody cares about new material'', and that ''people will just whine about new material if it was released as they're stuck in nostalgia mode'', yet one leaked song proves this is untrue. One ''unfinished'' leaked song has generated a tremendous amount of active users and replies here - look below - and generally has been well received with one or two exceptions.

In part youre right, but think about it we're a very small part of the stadiums that GNR are playing.

Some facebook pages didnt mentioned it yet

3 minutes ago, Gibsonfender2323 said:

Anyone else get a vr vibe?

No way

2 minutes ago, Lies They Tell said:

Maybe not but it's honestly weird that everything except the parts that leaked earlier sounds bad. And listen to the "all in good faith" -part. Axl's voice changes there suddenly to a much more autotuned voice. It's just very weird to me that as soon as the earlier leaked demo ends, Axl's voice changes so drastically to autotune. Why would they do that? It just screams fake, but I don't know. If it's fake it's very well made that's for sure.

 Also the "what we had" part on verse 2 sounds exactly like the "what we had"-part in verse 1, like it's copy pasted. All in all there's not that much new vocals here and the new vocals sound more edited than the vocals from the earlier leaks. At some parts it sounds like an evader remix honestly. Instrumentally it's absolutely terrible, except the parts that had leaked earlier.

The parts that leaked earlier sound like one of the best GNR songs ever and all the new parts here sound like the worst GNR song ever honestly. And because the new vocals sound so edited and copy pasted it makes me sceptical. But it could very well be a rough demo. I don't really care. All I know is that the only parts that sound any good to me are the parts that had leaked earlier. 

I can't believe I dislike this more than DieselDaisy. What's going on in this world? 

You are still with the doubt?

You call yourself fan of this band?

2 minutes ago, Gianluca87 said:

WHat is the lineup? 1999 era?

November 2000.

Just before Rio 

You think Atlas is next?

Would be perfect

2 minutes ago, CernakA said:

did not Mantia rerecord all Freese stuff after he joined GNR ? And Bucket joined after Mantia ... so it should maybe have Mantia drums ? 

I think Buck joined before mantia

Just now, CernakA said:

nope ...

I own a lot of Bucket stuff I know his style and its obvious hes on the mix