rebeldhipi

I wonder if old Josh drums means Josh Freeses original tracks or Brains copy version and new Brain version are the ones where he could create his own drum versions

2 minutes ago, Blackstar said:

Nice.

2 minutes ago, Homefuck said:

Ok, so I've browsed through this thread to see what the fuzz is about to no avail. Can someone please give me a quick recap? 

3 second clip of atlas leaked. 

Probably real. Not 100% sure

Gilby is formerly from GNR but Matt is not?😀

2 minutes ago, RussTCB said:

See below.

Like ZoSo said, the stuff in question is all from 99 - 2000. As the worlds premier Robin Finck fan, I am absolutely interested in hearing anything with his involvement!

Robin left mid 99 - late 00

Josh Freese left early 00.

So id think these are from 97-99 and mixed in 00

The drum fill at 5:25 is very different plus the tempo is alot slower on the Tokyo dvd. So even a drum overdub is not really an option.

In Live Era Axl dosent sing the ''just a little patience'' part, which he did on most shows. He does in Tokyo, but that could be a studio trick. Anyways that dosent explain the different tempo and drum fills

1 hour ago, zombux said:

no, actually the strikes did the opposite and it spread to fans all around the world like a wildfire - just thanks to the attention the strikes attracted.

Very true.

I  just wish too see it again someday, i was late to the party. (im not asking for any links here)

One of the worst victims of the strikes was the Idont Care About You video

Its still a mystery where the second part of Patience is from ( the electric part) Matt does a drum fill that dosent match any of the suggested ones online.

My guess is that its from a 1992 stadium show. Prehaps Houston??

Also Welcome is a mystery, ive seen online it being marked as Argentina 1992 the second show.

For what its worth im a drummer too and i like Frank.

Matt was my favourite, 

After that Josh Freese, Frank, Brain, Steven. 

1 hour ago, ZoSoRose said:

The reunion killed the online community tbh

well it brought at lot of parasites into the mix and they are successfully killing it.

6 hours ago, Lio said:

How very frustrating. I agree with jan, how is this even possible? I was on the NIghtrain before, but haven't renewed, so I've been off it for some time now. To me, it was a place where you always had to be very careful with what you said and how you worded it, because even the least bit of criticism was met with long replies about how little you knew about everything, by him and by his supporters. It was all very tiring and not conducive at all to healthy discussion. It felt like a dictatorship.

Anyway, everyone should boycott the thing. I don't even think they'd (whoever runs NT) mind. I think the only one who would mind would be him, because without an audience, he's nothing, of course.

Very sorry to hear this despicable behaviour is ongoing with no repercussion at all.

 

Yes! This was my experience too. I was also a member around 2017 but didnt renew.

I remember posting something positive aboout Bumblefoot and that mofo got all sensitive for some reason. apparently its not cool to be interested in some ex-members there.

I think since the 2016 reunion. gnr online community has turned sour big time. Even in 2015 htgt was way more active than its been the past couple years. with hc fans talking about cool things like comparing everyones favourite live performances of certain songs ect.

Today in 2019 gnr online community is insults, backstabbing, jealousy, and news. 

This is disgusting.

Hard to understand how things got this fuckedup

I could see it happen.  They agreed to do it in 1989 and 2006. Why not 2019? Would be a killer show.

Has any old vids been removed lately or only 16-18 era vids?

In Tallinn last year i saw the head of GNR security telling a guy holding a camera to stop filming (camera, not smarphone) His filming annoyed me cause it was disturbing my view. 

Probably pretty standard practice, but i remember it being a bit odd in 2018.

My take on it is that Axl wasen't ready to tour in mid 91 and he was forced to tour which made Axl's life difficult. Getting ready to do great shows (if they shows are medicore, the band wouldnt have made it this far) So he had huge pressure, mixed with mental health stuff which led to starting shows late, and letting the band go to a uncomfortable situation that eventually made Izzy quit.

And looking back i think Axl knows that if the Illusion tour would have started in lets say late 91. Izzy could have stayed longer and the band would have had a different path. Or not. It all worked out in the end.