rebeldhipi

2 minutes ago, Bucketdude_666 said:

i guess not, the mix is from March 27th ...

2 minutes ago, Bucketdude_666 said:

i guess not, the mix is from March 27th ...

November 7th actually, same as silkworm

This is huge!

Isint Bucket on this Riad tho?

Chinese Democracy (2019-08-28 leak as Chinese Stew)  is actually Drums & Guitar at regular level from New Brain Drums 3rd time

The Blues leak from (2019-08-28 ) is not the new brain drums version. Its instead the the old Josh drums version or the rough mix 6/1/01 version which i think are the same but mastered differently

1 hour ago, Creed said:

holy fuck. this sounds like a GnR Christmas song. Thats exactly why Slash is above Bonamassa, Eric and mamy more. You can feel his emotions. Its like Slash is singing with his guitar.

its most probably a song...the question is: what does 'GF' stands for on the set list?

Twat has so many leaks

1999 one that leaked in 06

2000 from the lockers

2001 from the lockers

2001 that leaked last year (sounds just like the 2000 one but is like 20 secs longer)

2006 short

2006 long 

2008 antiquet 

2008 album version.

Album version is superior. 

Would have been great if Tommy would done these at least once in a while in 2009-2014 instead of My Generation/Sonic Reducer/ Holiday In The Sun

4 minutes ago, kever20 said:

Maybe that is the newer Slash version.

There is a great possibility that it could be another recording or mix done between 2002 and 2019... Think about it: if 20 discs of various tracks and mixes exists from 1999 to 2001, there have got to be even more in the subsequent years. Probably a lot of repeats, ala CD tracks with Brain and Bucket, but also with Ron and Frank and Richard. Cross those fingers!

I never thought about it being outside those locker cds.

I like your thinking.

That said the tone of that extra guitar has more like a Brian May wibe than a Slash wibe.

At that quality it could be anything

The drums on the Atlas we got couple days ago from the rough mix full cd it has different drums from the older leak from a month ago.

New Brain drums match the old Atlas.

So im pretty sure Atlas from the Rough Mix disc has Josh Freese on drums.

The.mystery is that we still dont have a full version from the original snippet  with the extra guitar

3 minutes ago, Sweersa said:

I do not believe the intent was for Brain to copy Josh's drumming, they are simply Brain's take on the song. Axl wanted Brain's "feel" and that really can't be achieved by copying the work of someone else like so. Of course it was beneficial for Brain to hear Josh's drums to know what direction he wanted to take the drums for a particular track, or 32 in his case.

In interviews Brain has said that he was asked first to play exactly what Josh did and later when that was done to play what he wants.

Thats why on cd Riad Twat and Prostitute have drum arragement by Josh Freese in the credits cause they used those Brain playing what Josh played takes.

If we take Riad as an example Old Josh drums has the same fills as the 2008 record but with a different sound. 

New brain drums has some different fills.

What is interesting is that on Maddy original Brain, new Brain and Old Josh have all different drum fills

So. The question is.

Are "old Josh drums" the Josh Freese takes from 1998-1999 or are they the Brain copied what Josh played takes from 2000-2001?

New Brain drums sound nothing like the old Josh ones so it cannot be Brain playin note by note what Josh Played. 

My gues is that since the drum sound is very different "old Josh " takes are with actually Josh Freese. That means that we are missing 

Brain copying Josh takes.

Im confused i think i have 2 different versions of me and my elvis

This is hard to keep up with

9 minutes ago, ToonGuns said:

On Rhiad - people may not like the song, but the drumming is among the most complex on a GnR record

Same with Oh My God

2 hours ago, rumandraisin said:

This is the oldest CD era stuff we'll ever hear. These are 99 recordings of robin, Paul, Freese,Tommy and dizzy working on the Appetite rerecording. These pre date a lot of the CD work. They're from late 98 early 99. Justine rhythm guitar and the closest we got to hearing Freese on drums live. 

Afd 1999 hasent leaked. This is from 2001

How does Atlas Twat ect.

Differ from the leaks last month?

3 hours ago, lukepowell1988 said:

Who's the mac daddy!?

Would be funny if people make banners with ''Who's the mac daddy!?'' for the coming shows

6 minutes ago, rocknroll41 said:

Really? Where?

Worcester MA.

I think there used to be a vid on youtube but i cant find it anymore unsurprisingly

Scraped was played once in 2011

4 hours ago, username05 said:

 

damn! Can you recomend best performances for each of those?
The original CD lineup never played Catcher live! and I'd trade all the leaks to have heard Finck play Catcher live

 

lol... just listening Slash's solo on TWAT... Buckethead really made it impossible to compete Awsome Buckethead When even slash struggles with  it
got to admit it... finck kicked ass at Sorry solo.

Axl really had a powerhouse of musicians by his side 2 bad for bad luck... its amazing how much buckethead contributed within first year of being in the band (judging by the leaks). 2 bad he stayed for such a short while

For prostitute id recommend Houston 2017

This band is weird

Holy shit this song is good.

What a monster of a song. Im sure that it will grow to be even bigger for me.

I feel a bit foolish saying the snippet was fake

Every new leak (song)so far has been amazing.

This one hasent grown on me yet as much as the others have. But still a very strong track.

I love it. Very beautiful. Better demo is also interesting