Rindmelon

It's true there was a Q&A thing but no evidence of the comments were ever shown. He could of just seen it was happening and thought "here's my chance to make shit up" If he is telling the truth perhaps he can tell us more.

They easily had another album at least, vocals and all

Yeah we all need to re think things we thought we knew i suspect. Earlier on GNRevo we were talking about when Stinson mentioned recording a little interlude thing for CD in i think 2006. I had completely forgotten that was even a thing, i think there has been far more done than most people believe.

You can't receive PM's.

I received the same takedown notice on SoundCloud weeks ago when I remastered the 2006 tour intro. Given that some of those string parts in that 2006 intro are in monsters i'm not surprised monsters was flagged as the general. Because it seems to be legally classed as being the same track, we know now that it isn't, but I didn't know that at the time of course when i uploaded it. I can't quite write it in a way that makes sense but it seems like defensive trademarking based off of assumptions the fanbase made.

Good man sir, well done for showing the initiative to get the info from the horses mouth

Oh god maybe two month's ago? There was a post on his FB page about it. If I remember right someone (I a think a woman ) posted that she was his manager and that people should submit questions or something. I knew it was happening but forgot all about it until someone mentioned the D tune thing.

It was a facebook chat thing that he did. As others have said there are no screen shots of him saying anything. But he certainly did do the chat as I remember his manager posting on his facebook channel about it before it happened.

Absurd: 4 works far better live Hard Skool: 4 (locker version 8) works far worse live Perhaps: 7 The General: 8 Monsters: 9

Tobias

If you listen to The General with headphones at 2.50 does anyone else hear errr.... frogs ribbiting?

He barely played on the album according to Slash

I deleted it, had a lot of shit going on at the time, but yes I am shacklermyrye

I don't think there is any guitar work on these two songs that aren't Slash or Fortus. Any shredding is probably Fortus

Yeah you have a version of the Piano Moving Jam up there. Here is a version of it i cleaned up They played it a few times in 06/07, i'm pretty sure it probably is a song

I went to a video site and looked up "TWAT" as well.... But it wasn't youtube

I had my reasons for leaving. I did not know that it would lead to Wendi leaving and I apologise to you if you have found it hard, was not my intention at all. As Jan mentioned she may come back.

Thriller style

Walker, jim and people desperate to be on the inside looking for brownie points

Tommy should release it himself, and probably will i think if any potential issues are resolved. It would be nice of Axl to throw him a bone and let him use his backing vocal track on it too. Would probably lead to a few more sales.

Ampex 456 Dats. Very fragile, if you don't bake them before you try to play them they can tear them selves apart. That DAT was dated 18 of April 95, that's one day before the Oklahoma bombing that inspired another song.

Recorded with Slash I believe (sorry sweersa)

oh 2023 about 20 years after this stuff was recorded. What's the A side then? Atlas?

More than most. This could explain why the Perhaps single does not advertise Monsters at all.

Piano Moving Jam?