gnfnr2k

Sorry's lyrics are so cringe which is too bad bc the music is one of the tracks on the album.

1 hour ago, sofine11 said:

It’d be nice if they dropped something this week, if not, some time soon. As always, I tend to root for GNR despite themselves.

Anything they release will just be a bastardized version of the CD era stuff.  They made absurd and hard school worse.

I still can't believe how bad Axl vox sound on the new hard school, it sounded like he was singing via tin can and string and the guitars sound like it was a midi file.

On 12/8/2022 at 9:49 AM, Karice said:

Garden Of Eden is the worst Guns N'Roses music video I have ever seen, so low budget and it's just them and two random people in the back dancing crazy and this is filmed with only ONE camera. 😁 It's cheesy and I love it.🤣😏😃 Axl's goofy faces in the middle is truly one of the best parts of this. His faces are in this order. 😏😛😁 Slash in the beginning has to be pulled by a stagehand in focus. Duff looks disoriented in a funny way, the whole video is a bad video in a funny and humorous way. 😁

Chris Jericho liked it so much he ripped it off for his music video for the song Judas lol

So another GNR band member working on another project instead of working on making a new album for his band lol 

13 hours ago, Rodzilla72 said:

+100000

Isn't it bizarre reading comments from people claiming to like it? It's ok to admit that there's nothing left in the tank. They made a few iconic records, a handful of undisputed hard rock anthems- and that's it. Nothing wrong with that. 

Absurd was terrible but Silkworms was awesome.  

9 hours ago, DTV88 said:

700-800 songs? I call bullshit 

Why would you call bullshit lol  You have some of the lockerroom discs and see how many verisions of the same song there all.

That is all it would be, something like

Oklahoma V1

Oklahoma Vocals up

Oklahoma vocals down

Oklahoma drums up

Oklahoma drums down

Oklahoma w BH

Oklahoma wout BH

Oklahoma Freese

Oklahoma brain

etc etc

It would just be like 40-50 songs with 10 different versions of each.

You really cant see that.

4 minutes ago, rocknroll41 said:

Both Bumblefoot’s Remix and Evader’s fanmade Remix wipe the fucking floor with this piece of shit. It’s so bad that I’m not even gonna put it on one of my fan compilations. I might even hate it more than Get in the Ring. Just awful. Tho to be fair, I understand it’s just a very early demo that (at least imo) eventually evolved into a semi-decent song.

LMAO the BBF version is garbage. Its just BBF making pointless noodling that does not even fit the song and Axl just saying absurd over and over again. This demo is a million times better.

the best version is still HOF live.

yeah i had that first but somenoe else said it waw this way, so I am changing it back lol

All cautions made
Every chance was given
No effort spared
To save what we had
All in good faith
I would not hesitate
To extend myself
And lend you my hand

But you had to play it cool, had to do it your way
Had to be a fool, had to throw it all away
Too hard school and you thought you were here to stay
If that were true it wouldn't matter anyway

As tempers fade
And lies forgiven
No cause embraced
Could break what we had
In its place
A storm is lived in
I would've thought you could be more of a man

But you  had to play it cool, had to do it your way
Had to play it cool had to throw it all away
Too hard school and you thought you were here to stay
If that were true it wouldn't matter anyway

...i know people were messing around with lyrics earlier

3 hours ago, Blackstar said:

Yeah, he said Axl hadn't done any vocals yet. He probably did have lyrics by then, though. It seems, according to the Beavan interview, that Axl started recording vocals shortly after Robin Finck left.

2 hours ago, Shacklermyrye said:

I saw that too, but I think its BS

This was in 1999 the first time Robin left. He said Axl didnt have many songs done and most were just song ideas without lyrics.

We know in 99 Axl had a handful of songs wiht lyrics becasue he played them for RS.    But yeah Axl started putting more lyrics on stuff in 2000 which is why we probably have all of those locker room CDs. That is probably the first set of vocals Axl put down for most of those songs, and hard school is one of those songs.   It also makes sense why axl sounds similar on Atlas, Hard School and CITR. 

6 minutes ago, Blackstar said:

It's possible that the basic musical composition originates from when Slash was still in the band - probably without his involvement - and the lyrics were written later. Slash, Duff, Zakk Wylde etc have said that Axl hadn't written any lyrics during that time, or at least he hadn't done any vocals. Even Axl himself has said that he had a writer's block then.

Even when Robin left, he said most of Axls songs didnt have lyrics 

2 minutes ago, AlterL said:

you're not great with sarcasm are you?'?

I am great with sarcasm but these are the GNR forums where there are always tons of trolls.  Like the person who I was replying to in the first place.

1 minute ago, Gunner927 said:

Pfft. I bet you believe that House of Blues 2001 proshot myth, too. Everyone knows that never happened and won't see the light of day.

yet the full HOB show was released and a soundboard of it as well. yet you still put your head in the sand.

Are you really going to deny what I said about the name checkmate?

35 minutes ago, DeadSlash said:

Is it really that easy to start a rumor?  Just type up some bullshit and watch people react? Maybe I'll try that one day.  Just type up some stupid shit and see how many PM's I get.

At ay rate, I don't believe you, and I call bullshit.  There is not 15 discs of GnR material floating out there.  15 songs, yes... but it is on one CD,  on said bootleg  Checkmate is called Checkmate not "hard school", there is no song named "Billionaire" and only WTTJ and SCOM from the AFD redux, not the whole album.  The "3rd Brian May song" listed as "Noticia Falsa" has been thoroughly debunked by those in the know, and was simply mislabeled (or purposely misattributed to May) by whoever made the master bootleg  It is obviously DJ.   Zodiac, Atlas Shrugged Oklahoma etc. are on it, yes, but that isn't news, they've been out for over 2 months.  This is nothing new, stop seeking attention.

really dude?  They have pics of the discs and the guys locker was sold, there is even stuff on ebay from that locker.   

And checkmate is called checkmate because the first leaker was just like checkmate because he got a leak. That was never the title of the song. If you were around back then, you would know that. You are just embarrassing yourself. 

1 minute ago, axlrosefan4life said:

A lot more 

How is silkworms, I always wanted to hear the HOB studio version. I was so sad when Axl butchered it with that newest leak from last year. 

1 minute ago, Axl_morris said:

Universal will be angry they can't sell you a box load of shit with these demos.

They will still be able to that GNR AFD box set was 90% stuff everyone has already had via import cds. they just remastered them. 

Just now, junior201 said:

he needs to give the material to an anonymous person so that person can do it

Or just use a VPN and make a new UN and share it that way, once a few people have it, it will be shared eith everyone

1 minute ago, Gunner55 said:

I'm no legal aid in any capacity but on paper this sounds plausible. If I were in that position thought I'd still be too worried to take the chance but that's just me. 

These cds have not been through the hands of multiple people.  These two clip leaks are not even from him.  As long as people are not stupid and post them in open,  not sure if trading or sharing them is even illegal.  Because if it was then everyone would be screwed for just having all these leaks.

5 minutes ago, Estrangedfx said:

I get that these are being obtained, but without risking his own ass, how are we even sure we will be hearing anything from this?? I mean, all this talk of "donating/contributing funds" is sweet and all, but it's more likely he'll need some major, MAJOR legal aid if he gets into any trouble.

 

Id love to hear any of these as much as anybody, but isn't is just a wee bit selfish on our part? I mean, I have a family. I'm sure Axlfan4life does, too. Would any of you risk literally, doing jail time, not to mention all the fines and lawsuits this guy could potentially be facing???

So realistically, $200 here, another $400 there from various fans isn't going to do much. Raise $20,000. You think that's going to retain a lawyer for longer than a few days??

Just be a little considerate and concerned for him. Not just appreciative he's doing what nine of us, including myself could afford (not just financially) rise. He's risking his life and we'll being here, too. Just remember that. 

Here is the thing, these were legally bought though from Zutats storage locker.  So the question to ask is are these now the property ofthe person that owns them. As long as he does not sell them or put them on a website to stream, is he allowed to do what he wants with them.

Like for example, all those UYI rough cut cds that are passed around, no one is every worried about sharing those and those were never officially released 

As long as he is not posting them online, and through back channels like trading or giving them people, not sure if that is even illegal. The reason why Skewll got into trouble is because he put them up on his streaming site.

2 minutes ago, UsedYourIllusion said:

GN'R is also one of the most bootlegged bands of all time. I can't think of a band with more "silver" and released bootlegs, notwithstanding bands like Grateful dead who tour for 40 years, record every show, and release them for free

 pearl jam has released every live show since the 90s on cd

1 hour ago, Azifwekare said:

It looks like [the guy leaking stuff] removed themselves from [wherever they were spreading the leaks from - I don't wanna get myself banned here], and their posts of the tracklist photos are gone...

Does this mean anything? Is it a good or a bad sign? Are they planning the next move or just gone into hiding?

So these clips are all we are going to get? That sucks if that is it.

Just now, RussTCB said:

Oh, I'm not trying to justify anything. I'm just saying that I sure wish GNR would release music I can pay them for. 

I agree if they put out a box set of all those cds of Chin Dems songs and AFD by the 99 band, and it was like 100 songs, id pay $299 for that. 

50 minutes ago, RussTCB said:

Huh? Those songs not being on CD would actually support my theory given that the album we got was mostly made up of songs that leaked. 

Your theory is right because there were like 3 or so songs on CD that were not supposed to make the album CITR being one (that was going to be on the 3rd album) but since a ton of stuff leaked Axl just put all the leaked songs on one album. 

52 minutes ago, Estrangedfx said:

Silkworms..... Meh. However, that teeny-tiny little breakdown, when the gentle guitars come in and Axl sings/croons/whispers a few lyrics, before the song explodes back into absurdity.... It's quite a beautiful few melodic moments in any otherwise mess of a song. You know what part I'm referring to? I can't make out the lyrics, really. 

Having said that,. ANYTHING with Axl on vocals, in any form, I'm happy to hear. 

As for Hard School, minus it's ridiculous title... It's pretty god damn awesome. That additional minute long clip exceeded my expectations. The original leak, i was  optimistic. Now, I'm convinced it's a gem. 

Hard School was probably just a working title like all of these titles for the most part

59 minutes ago, Caught_in_a_Coma said:

When Brian Wilson released Smile decades after it was intended to release, didn't he include a lot of different takes of the songs?  I feel like there's a great potential for Axl to do something similar with ChiDem era stuff. 

He could easily put it on iTunes for like $99 for all 20 CDs.  And make bank on it