gunsnaxls Posted March 18, 2006 Share Posted March 18, 2006 It's so funny how people think the other members in the old Gn'r besides Axl were rubbish. All 4 of those guys (discounting Adler) were very instrumental in their success. Without any of those four, Gn'r would never have been as good. Axl obviously meant a ton to the old lineup and obviously means a ton to the new lineup, but the other guys had a ton of input. And you people who are saying that Axl is God are basing this on a few new demos which are good, but certainly not mind-blowing. All 4 songs are solid, with some better than the others, but none is a classic or even close to some of Gn'rs best stuff from back in the day. And this is after 13 years w/o an album. So based on a few good demos after 13 years, you are regarding this stuff as proof that Axl was the only creative force? It was the whole band that was creative, and however good CD is will be based not only on Axl, but the new guys in this band as well. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts