Liam x Noel,who's the best?

[Gallagher Rose]

Which is the best member from Oasis,Liam or Noel?

I can say Liam is a great frontman,a real rock star who doesn't give a fuck about the press..but overall Noel is the best.He's a great songwriter and singer.

It's a shame that Liam's voice is ruined nowadays,but Noel still does a good job and keep the band alive.

If Axl had a brother to kick his ass and release the albums,like Liam has,it would be great.

Vote and discuss.

Edited May 8, 2007 by Gallagher Rose

[Revolver Paul]

Noels the music man and Liam is the image guy. Null vote they're both important.

[JeanGenie]

Noel no doubt. he basicly is oasis. although the additude thing Liam brings in is quite entertaining. not to forget that he used to have an awesome voice.

[Dangelus]

Oasis are shit so I couldn't vote... Stupid fools dared question the musical genius that is Bloc Party despite the fact that every whiny bloody Oasis song sounds EXACTLY the same as the last!

[The Sandman]

Gah, can't decide - both are awesome.

[carsonskitz]

Noel...i love his voice

his songs are also out of this world

liam rocks though!

rock2

[Guest Satanisk_Slakt]

They are great,I can't decide

[fantomas]

Liam for attitude and stage presence and vocals. Noel for vocals and being a genius. Can't have one without the other.

[Randy Lahey]

I voted for Noel since he's the main songwriter. Liam's voice is what makes Oasis stand out for me though. Liam and Axl are far and away my favorite singers of the last 20 years.

Edited May 9, 2007 by Randy Lahey

[jack99]

They're both great at what they do. Noel is a fantastic songwriter, the fact that he wrote all tracks for Oasis first three albums speaks for itself. Liam's got a lot of attutide on and off stage and a very original style of singing, a perfect match to Noel's songs.

Oasis is my second fav band afer GN'R.

[Midnight Rambler]

I cant pick, you cant have one without the other. God Oasis used to be so good, the first two albums, plus all the amazing b-sides as well. It was an exciting time.

[Lithium]

As a musician, Noel.

[pe_teko]

Noel is a genius. He designed OASIS, but Liam's voice and attitude made them the best band from 94 to 97.

2005 CD is great IMO... and I'm waiting for their next album. GREAT BAND.

My vote for NOEL

[Guest Satanisk_Slakt]

Poor Liam.

[Opax]

They're both untalented fuck-wits

[damian 1200]

Oasis are shit so I couldn't vote... Stupid fools dared question the musical genius that is Bloc Party despite the fact that every whiny bloody Oasis song sounds EXACTLY the same as the last!

Bloc Party?, musical genius?, BAHAHA

I voted Noel.

[fantomas]

They're both untalented fuck-wits

And Axl isn't?

[Gallagher Rose]

Liam has no vote,impressive!

And to be honest,Bloc Party are a bunch of fags,specially the nigerian fuckhead.

Edited May 25, 2007 by Gallagher Rose

[GnR lives on]

noel... dont look back in anger...enough said.. look at his performances of wonderwall and other songs on youtube and he wrote the songs...

i love liam too but noel takes it

[Pico]

Liam is awesome, but he should get his voice fixed. Noel's never had any low points (perhaps on SOTSOG), so therefore he gets my vote.

Bonehead kills them all, though.

[steveysham]

Noel is the real talent of the bad, liam wasn't a great singer and then he fucked up his voice aswell.

[Axls Rose]

can't stand either of them although i would say Noel is a lesser dick head of the two