maXx

and just to prove it, you pre-concluded i was male.

Sorry about that. I know tons of females that would call themselves maXx. I'm sure that we all do.

what.. it's got 2 x's didn't you know that denotes the female version?? wake up champ

Who's the guy on your profile then?

lol, eddie vedder. pity for the ladies here it's not me.

and just to prove it, you pre-concluded i was male.

Sorry about that. I know tons of females that would call themselves maXx. I'm sure that we all do.

what.. it's got 2 x's didn't you know that denotes the female version?? wake up champ

You must be such a boring person if you need everyone to cross their 't's and dot their 'i's in respect to proper English, what a nerd. It doesn't matter how i put my argument to you, i've realised your brain was closed before this conversation started; one which ends now as far as i'm concerned

and just to prove it, you pre-concluded i was male.

There's nothing to get. To say that someone has two things in front of them and they choose the thing that they like less is completely ridiculous. It doesn't matter in the least bit how you feel about it, it was Axl's choice to make and he did what every single human being on earth would do and chose his favorite.

It is beyond my level of comprehension as to how that simple fact can be beyond your level of comprehension.

no one expects you to comprehend me or anyone else, just state your opinion on the subject, that will suffice. i don't think i said anywhere that axl knowingly chose the thing he least liked. i said he didn't promote the album cause it turned out crap. at the time he probably loved all the hedonism associated with overproducing but the end result told a different story. oh well, too late.

edit.. i shouldn't say it's all crap cause it's not that bad an album in its entirety, except in comparison to what we are discussing here,

Why are you changing your argument when we've already established that you believe that he willingly and consciously released music that he thought was inferior to earlier versions of the exact same music? That is exactly what you said in the post you quoted when you switched our names.

If this is your new argument, fine. You are entitled to your opinion. Even though I don't care about it in the least, and I haven't throughout this whole conversation. The conversation was never about what you liked more. It was about the stupidity behind claiming that Axl had 2 or more versions of the same song and chose to release the version that he liked the least. If that is no longer what the conversation is about, I see no reason to continue it.

well You see you must be narrow minded to not see that a person can think they are making something better, and in hindsight find it was worse. what is wrong with you?

Damn_Smooth, on 07 October 2012 - 03:53 PM, said:

So he liked the demos, but he needed to fuck around with them until he made something that he likes worse; and he released his least favorite version.

he made something that he likes, not liked, worse .. and [whether you care about me liking it or not] it turned out to be the worser version, and even though he must like the Cd release after all he put into it, a part of him surely knows the demos had something more raw and better. he also knows he could have released the album more true to them, but chose not too for whatever reason he has. but obviously all this is speculation on my part as is most of the crap that is written here.

EDIT:

-you're just an argumentative little bitch aren't you? you should have been able to get what i was on about from the start but evidently your need to cupcake and insult is too great.

There's nothing to get. To say that someone has two things in front of them and they choose the thing that they like less is completely ridiculous. It doesn't matter in the least bit how you feel about it, it was Axl's choice to make and he did what every single human being on earth would do and chose his favorite.

It is beyond my level of comprehension as to how that simple fact can be beyond your level of comprehension.

no one expects you to comprehend me or anyone else, just state your opinion on the subject, that will suffice. i don't think i said anywhere that axl knowingly chose the thing he least liked. i said he didn't promote the album cause it turned out crap. at the time he probably loved all the hedonism associated with overproducing but the end result told a different story. oh well, too late.

edit.. i shouldn't say it's all crap cause it's not that bad an album in its entirety, except in comparison to what we are discussing here,

Fuckin' Aussie

...are you one ?

you have to admit it's a good song though.

maXx-

Why did you switch our names in our quote tags? It's bad enough that you honestly believe that Axl preferred the demos and didn't release them, I don't want credit for it.

Edit: You also should have quoted my whole post.

i made my point with what i quoted, and didn't change your intent, did I? & i fixed the name tags, that was unintentional.

i don't know why axl didn't stay true to the early demos cause i'm not him, but sometimes people just go too far with a thing until it loses it's honesty. probably obsessive (it's common these days), don't tell me you don't get that?

no, because of his obsessive need to overproduce and fuck around with a good thing

like bumblefoot fucked around a good thing on the chinese democracy album with fretless?

yes, exactly

no, because of his obsessive need to overproduce and fuck around with a good thing

So he liked the demos, but he needed to fuck around with them until he made something that he likes worse; and he released his least favorite version.

exactly, he can't help it

Ron's fretless is pretty clear on the Chinese Democracy verses, between the choruses.

And on the Shackler's Revenge solo.

And that's all...

exactly, and that's all.

edit.. quote error.

gosh, it hasn't even happened yet. what a huge disappointment it will be to so many if something 'comes up' and he cancels.

nevertheless, i do agree it's long overdue and i too am curious to hear him speak.

Shewholikesitroush-

How many of those released songs with playing from your dream guys also feature playing from Ron Thal? If you clear your thoughts of Finckdick for a second, even someone with your abysmally small level of intelligence can come up with the correct answer, which would be all of them.

Another question for you- How many writing credits does your fantasy tag team have between them on CD? Concentrate as hard as a mental dwarf such as yourself can, and you might be able to come up with 4. Since we know that your mother is also your sister, I'm not exactly sure that you have enough appendages to count that high though, so I'll cut you some slack on that one.

I have a few more, but I don't want to overwork your nerdraging ass. As soon as you clean up the mess you made this time, get back to me.

..., if Axl was so proud of these mutants that you lust after; he would have promoted CD when it released, and we would have CD2 by now. ...

maybe he wasn't proud of the final product, period, because it sucked compared to the excitement as heard in the early leaks with the 'mutants' at their best

That makes perfect sense, because he couldn't have just released those versions. Right?

no, because of his obsessive need to overproduce and fuck around with a good thing

..., if Axl was so proud of these mutants that you lust after; he would have promoted CD when it released, and we would have CD2 by now. ...

maybe he wasn't proud of the final product, period, because it sucked compared to the excitement as heard in the early leaks with the 'mutants' at their best

i'm suprised you don't have on TAY, you have just about every other shirt ever made right ??

.... new album by the current lineup, ...

...with songs written by them, would be good.

It's official. You are a complete waste of time and you have no knowledge of anything related to GN'R.

finck6 is right, and you're not

For fuck’s sake, there are two people here that are too stupid to know that Ron played on every single song on CD? Where are these fucktards coming from?

"axl's vision for nugnr is robin finck and buckethead. not dj ashba and bumblefoot" quote finck6

It's official. You are a complete waste of time and you have no knowledge of anything related to GN'R.

finck6 is right, and you're not

I used to blast Cum on Feel the Noize by Quiet Riot - probably around 1st grade. Even back then I had excellent taste.

Weren't that Slade?

did quiet riot cover it?

today i heard 'who loves you' by the four seasons and it took me back... in a surprisingly nice way

Traci Guns has about as much influence on GNR musically and Tracy the back up singer in the UYI tour

It's jut not Guns N' Roses without Tracy and Traci.

Fuck Tracy! Roberta all the way!

I wonder where those chicks are nowadays.

Were they hot? I don't remember.

you don't remember because you were just an itty bitty baby back then

the pic is pretty cool. why anyone worries about it being shared is beyond me. it's not embarrassing or overly personal. her facebook page is barely private, in that i suspect all friend requests are approved anyhow.

Duff and Izzy have gotten past the name thing, and have went onstage and performed with Axl.

Adler has practically begged to go onstage and play with Axl.

Slash would - in a heartbeat - go onstage and play with Axl.

so why is axl being such a prick then and holding it back, if you're so right?

*some of the other things you said I agreed with

awesome, no peace no surrender no retreat. see you on the other side.

so DF, you saved the best for last rock1

Steely Dan - Peg

It's actually silly to display stuff you're not able to sell

agreed, a bit try-hard