bacardimayne Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 November Rain. Estranged is great, but November Rain is in another league.
Takeshi Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 November Rain is an awesome song but Estranged just has that emotional depth that makes it so much better. It's the sound of an artist really baring his soul.
SLCPUNK Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 im never sure which one to say as better sometimes what do you think? Estranged....just beautiful. Although NR is has a special meaning to me as well.
macapala Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 I like Estranged the most because its more fun to play on guitar. November Rain is kind of boring up until the first solo.
sweetness Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 Regardless of whatever sounds more "emotional" or "epic", November Rain is a much better compositionthe way people blow Estranged out of proportion around here has seriously ruined it for me, not even close to being one of GNR's best songs let alone ThE gReAtEsT mAsTeRpIeCe Of AlL tIeM.
bacardimayne Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 Regardless of whatever sounds more "emotional" or "epic", November Rain is a much better compositionthe way people blow Estranged out of proportion around here has seriously ruined it for me, not even close to being one of GNR's best songs let alone ThE gReAtEsT mAsTeRpIeCe Of AlL tIeM.Not often do I agree with you, but I do here. Estranged is a great song, but November Rain is perfection. The best power ballad ever written.
chaos Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 Estranged is the best GNR song, and if you disagree, you know nothing about GNR.Or...you just have a different opinion and no pole stuck up your jacksie.
Guest Satanisk_Slakt Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 November Rain. I like Estranged better, but there is no reason not to play one of their four big songs (WTTJ, PC, SCOM and NR).
Christian Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 Estranged is great, but November Rain is in another league. A lower league of course.Exactly. Estrange is untouchable.
God of Thunder Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 They are both good songs, but personally Estranged gets more to me....I love the guitar solos
Audrey Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 November Rain is an awesome song but Estranged just has that emotional depth that makes it so much better. It's the sound of an artist really baring his soul. Totally with ya!!!! it's very hard to pick though, but if I have to.. estranged
Powerage5 Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 (edited) it's funny, even in 2002 you guys were even waiting for estranged to be played....never got played then either....might be stuck to youtube videosYou seriously bumped an 8 year old thread just to say that? On topic, Estranged by a mile. Only GN'R song that comes close is This I Love IMO. Edited March 15, 2010 by Powerage5
JesusisSavior Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 (edited) They are both good songs, but personally Estranged gets more to me....I love the guitar solosWhich is whyyyyyyyy I would die if new gnr butchered them. I think them not touching that song a wise move.November Rain's already been molested Edited March 15, 2010 by JesusisSavior
Powerage5 Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 They are both good songs, but personally Estranged gets more to me....I love the guitar solosWhich is whyyyyyyyy I would die if new gnr butchered them. I think them not touching that song a wise move.November Rain's already been molestedUmm...no.
appetite4illusions Posted March 15, 2010 Posted March 15, 2010 They are both good songs, but personally Estranged gets more to me....I love the guitar solosWhich is whyyyyyyyy I would die if new gnr butchered them. I think them not touching that song a wise move.November Rain's already been molestedUmm...no.She's just got a mighty stick up her ass. Nothing can be done about that apparently.Ot, I think Estranged is the epitome of maudlin sentimentality. It's such a mopey-dopey ballad. A silly one too.
WhatsHerface Posted March 16, 2010 Posted March 16, 2010 November Rain, just because the solo is my favorite solo of all time.Estranged is fucking beautiful though, evreything about it is awesome.
axlstud Posted March 16, 2010 Posted March 16, 2010 it's funny, even in 2002 you guys were even waiting for estranged to be played....never got played then either....might be stuck to youtube videosYou seriously bumped an 8 year old thread just to say that? On topic, Estranged by a mile. Only GN'R song that comes close is This I Love IMO.hahaha yes I did, I just thought it was interesting that the exact same conversation was going on 8 years ago.
Recommended Posts